中国普通人群中低剂量CT肺癌筛查肺结节管理:美国国家综合癌症网络与欧洲立场声明方案的比较
前瞻性纳入中国40-74岁无症状人群1000例基线低剂量CT筛查,比较NCCN与EUPS(容积和直径)方案对肺结节的管理分类。NCCN、EUPS容积和EUPS直径方案转诊呼吸科比例分别为0.6%、1.9%、1.4%,短期复查比例分别为4.5%、9.7%、4.5%;10例肺癌中1例在EUPS容积方案下可更早诊断。
要点
- EUPS方案转诊阈值低于NCCN方案,转诊呼吸科比例更高(EUPS容积1.9% vs NCCN 0.6%)。
- EUPS容积方案推荐短期复查的比例低于EUPS直径方案(9.7% vs 4.5%)。
- EUPS容积方案可能使部分肺癌更早诊断(10例中1例)。
核心结论
- 在中国普通人群首轮筛查中,EUPS方案较NCCN方案转诊阈值更低,导致更多转诊呼吸科,可能使癌症更早诊断;EUPS容积方案较EUPS直径方案推荐更少短期复查。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,中国40-74岁无症状人群连续1000例基线低剂量CT筛查,由两名独立阅片者分别手动测量(NCCN方案)和半自动测量容积与直径(EUPS容积和直径方案),将参与者分为三组管理:下一轮筛查、短期复查低剂量CT、转诊呼吸科。
诊断标准与关键数值
- NCCN方案:转诊呼吸科比例0.6%,短期复查比例4.5%。
- EUPS容积方案:转诊呼吸科比例1.9%,短期复查比例9.7%。
- EUPS直径方案:转诊呼吸科比例1.4%,短期复查比例4.5%。
- 10例肺癌患者中,若遵循EUPS容积方案,1例可更早诊断。
局限性
- 原文结论指出随访研究应显示两种方案对(间期)癌症诊断的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) lung cancer screening often refers individuals to unnecessary examinations. This study aims to compare the European Position Statement (EUPS) and National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) protocols in management of participants at baseline screening round.
METHODS: LDCT lung cancer screening was prospectively performed in a Chinese asymptomatic population aged 40-74 years. A total of 1,000 consecutive baseline LDCT scans were read twice independently. All screen-detected lung nodules by the first reader were included. The first reader manually measured the diameter of lung nodules (NCCN protocol), and the second reader semi-automatically measured the volume and diameter (EUPS volume and diameter protocols). The protocols were used to classify the participants into three management groups: next screening round, short-term repeat LDCT scan and referral to a pulmonologist. Groups were compared using Wilcoxon test for paired samples. Number of lung cancers by protocols was provided.
RESULTS: Of the 1,000 participants (61.4±6.7 years old), 168 lung nodules in 124 participants were visually detected and manually measured in the first reading, and re-measured semi-automatically. Applying the NCCN protocol, EUPS volume and diameter protocol, the proportion of referrals among all participants was 0.6%, 1.9%, and 1.4%, respectively. The proportion of short-term repeat scans was 4.5%, 9.7% and 4.5%, respectively. Among the 10 lung cancer patients, one would have been diagnosed earlier if the EUPS volume protocol would have been followed.
CONCLUSIONS: In a first round screening in a Chinese general population, the lower threshold for referral in the EUPS protocol as compared to the NCCN protocol, leads to more referrals to a pulmonologist, with the potential of earlier cancer diagnosis. The EUPS volume protocol recommends fewer participants to short-term repeat LDCT scan than the EUPS diameter protocol. Follow-up studies should show the impact of both protocols on (interval) cancer diagnosis.
引用
- Du Y, Li Y, Dorrius MD, et al. Comparison of National Comprehensive Cancer Network and European Position Statement protocols for nodule management in low-dose computed tomography lung cancer screening in a general Chinese population. J Thorac Dis. 2021. PMID: 35070370. doi:10.21037/jtd-21-1312
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。