欧洲重症医学会共识与专家建议:普通与神经重症监护单元中重症医师的全身基础超声技能
欧洲重症医学会组建19人国际专家组,采用Delphi法就重症超声基础技能形成74条共识声明(脑7条、肺20条、心脏20条、腹部20条、血管7条),其中49条为强推荐(66.2%同意)、8条弱推荐(10.8%)、3条弱反对(4.1%)、14条未达成共识(19.9%)。该共识为重症超声基础应用提供指导,并为培训与研究项目奠定基础。
要点
- 共识共形成74条声明,脑7条、肺20条、心脏20条、腹部20条、血管7条。
- 强推荐49条(66.2%同意),弱推荐8条(10.8%),弱反对3条(4.1%),未达成共识14条(19.9%)。
- 未达成共识的声明多因专家组认为相关技能过于高级。
核心结论
- 该共识为重症超声基础应用提供指导,并为培训和研究项目的发展奠定基础。
研究设计与样本
- 欧洲重症医学会执行委员会委托并监督该共识的方法学与结构,组建了19名具有重症超声专长的国际专家小组,另设1名无投票权的方法学家。
- 专家组分为脑、肺、心脏、腹部和血管超声五个亚组,确定领域并生成问题清单,采用基于迭代方法的Delphi流程形成最终共识声明。
- 声明分类为强推荐(84%同意)、弱推荐(74%同意)和无推荐(低于74%),分别表示支持或反对。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 强推荐定义为84%同意,弱推荐定义为74%同意,无推荐定义为低于74%同意。
- 共74条声明:脑7条、肺20条、心脏20条、腹部20条、血管7条。
- 强推荐49条(66.2%),弱推荐8条(10.8%),弱反对3条(4.1%),未达成共识14条(19.9%)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 该共识为重症监护单元中重症超声的基础使用提供指导。
- 专家组认为未达成共识的多数技能过于高级。
- 共识结果还引出了研究议程和培训项目的讨论。
局限性
- 14条声明(19.9%)未达成共识。
- 未达成共识的多数情况是专家组认为相关技能过于高级。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To provide consensus, and a list of experts' recommendations regarding the basic skills for head-to-toe ultrasonography in the intensive care setting.
METHODS: The Executive Committee of the European Society of Intensive Care (ESICM) commissioned the project and supervised the methodology and structure of the consensus. We selected an international panel of 19 expert clinicians-researchers in intensive care unit (ICU) with expertise in critical care ultrasonography (US), plus a non-voting methodologist. The panel was divided into five subgroups (brain, lung, heart, abdomen and vascular ultrasound) which identified the domains and generated a list of questions to be addressed by the panel. A Delphi process based on an iterative approach was used to obtain the final consensus statements. Statements were classified as a strong recommendation (84% of agreement), weak recommendation (74% of agreement), and no recommendation (less than 74%), in favor or against.
RESULTS: This consensus produced a total of 74 statements (7 for brain, 20 for lung, 20 for heart, 20 for abdomen, 7 for vascular Ultrasound). We obtained strong agreement in favor for 49 statements (66.2%), 8 weak in favor (10.8%), 3 weak against (4.1%), and no consensus in 14 cases (19.9%). In most cases when consensus was not obtained, it was felt that the skills were considered as too advanced. A research agenda and discussion on training programs were implemented from the results of the consensus.
CONCLUSIONS: This consensus provides guidance for the basic use of critical care US and paves the way for the development of training and research projects.
引用
- Robba C, Wong A, Poole D, et al. Basic ultrasound head-to-toe skills for intensivists in the general and neuro intensive care unit population: consensus and expert recommendations of the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine. Intensive Care Med. 2021. PMID: 34787687. doi:10.1007/s00134-021-06486-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。