文献速递骨肌介入CT

骨样骨瘤消融技术的时间驱动作业成本法成本比较

Time-Driven Activity-Based Cost Comparison of Osteoid Osteoma Ablation Techniques.
PubMed 文献 · J Am Coll Radiol · 2023-07-19

11年回顾性研究对比骨样骨瘤消融中锥形束CT叠加透视引导与常规CT引导、微波消融与射频消融的成本,共91例患者96次手术。锥形束CT组麻醉诱导、手术及房间时间均显著长于常规CT组,校正混杂后总成本仍更高;射频消融总成本接近高于微波消融。

要点

  • 锥形束CT组麻醉诱导、手术及房间时间均显著长于常规CT组。
  • 校正年龄、引导方式、消融方式及体位后,锥形束CT总成本仍高于常规CT。
  • 射频消融总成本接近高于微波消融,但手术时间无显著差异。

核心结论

  • 骨样骨瘤消融使用锥形束CT叠加透视引导较常规CT引导导致更长的房间时间和更高成本。
  • 选择影像引导方式时应将这些成本因素与锥形束CT潜在的辐射剂量优势权衡。
  • 较低年龄、使用射频消融及非仰卧位另外导致成本增加。

研究设计与样本

  • 11年回顾性研究,纳入所有接受骨样骨瘤消融的患者。
  • 共91例患者行96次消融手术,锥形束CT组66次,常规CT组30次。
  • 消融设备包括Cool tip射频消融探头(Covidien,明尼阿波利斯,明尼苏达州)或Neuwave PR微波消融探头(Ethicon,拉里坦,新泽西州)。
  • 记录每例的房间时间和即刻恢复时间,采用时间驱动作业成本法分析费率相关变量(工资、设备折旧、房间时间及部分耗材),时间无关成本包括一次性介入放射耗材和消融系统,并按变动与固定支出用常规成本会计方法报告各服务部门成本。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 麻醉诱导时间:锥形束CT组22.7 ± 8.7分钟 vs 常规CT组15.9 ± 7.2分钟,P < .001。
  • 手术时间:锥形束CT组64.7 ± 27.5分钟 vs 常规CT组47.3 ± 15.3分钟,P = .001。
  • 房间时间:锥形束CT组137.7 ± 33.7分钟 vs 常规CT组103.9 ± 22.6分钟,P < .001。
  • 手术时间微波消融组62.1 ± 27.4分钟 vs 射频消融组56.1 ± 23.3分钟,P = .27,无显著差异。
  • 多因素回归显示较低年龄(P = .046)、使用锥形束CT(P = .001)、使用射频消融(P = .02)及非仰卧位(P = .01)显著增加总手术成本。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 原文结论指出,选择影像引导方式时应将锥形束CT较常规CT增加的成本与锥形束CT潜在的辐射剂量优势进行权衡。
  • 对于较低年龄、使用射频消融及非仰卧位的病例,应注意其与总手术成本增加相关。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: Compare the cost of performing an osteoid osteoma ablation using cone beam CT (CBCT) with overlay fluoroscopic guidance to ablation using conventional CT (CCT) guidance and microwave ablation (MWA) to radiofrequency ablation (RFA).

METHODS: An 11-year retrospective study was performed of all patients undergoing osteoid osteoma ablation. Ablation equipment included a Cool tip RFA probe (Covidien, Minneapolis, Minnesota) or a Neuwave PR MWA probe (Ethicon, Rariton, New Jersey). The room times as well as immediate recovery time were recorded for each case. Cost analysis was then performed using time-driven activity-based costing for rate-dependent variables including salaries, equipment depreciation, room time, and certain supplies. Time-independent costs included the disposable interventional radiology supplies and ablation systems. Costs were reported for each service providing care and using conventional cost accounting methods with variable and fixed expenditures.

RESULTS: A total of 91 patients underwent 96 ablation procedures in either CBCT (n = 66) or CCT (n = 30) using either MWA (n = 51) or RFA (n = 45). The anesthesia induction (22.7 ± 8.7 min versus 15.9 ± 7.2 min, P < .001), procedure (64.7 ± 27.5 min versus 47.3 ± 15.3 min; P = .001), and room times (137.7 ± 33.7 min versus 103.9 ± 22.6. min; P < .001) were significantly longer for CBCT procedures. The procedure time did not differ significantly between MWA and RFA (62.1 ± 27.4 min versus 56.1 ± 23.3 min; P = .27). Multiple regression analysis demonstrated lower age (P = .046), CBCT use (P = .001), RFA use (P = .02), and nonsupine patient position (P = .01) significantly increased the total procedural cost. After controlling for these variables, the total cost of CBCT ($5,981.32 ± $523.93 versus $5,378.93 ± $453.12; P = .001) remained higher than CCT and the total cost of RFA ($5,981.32 ± $523.93 versus $5,674.43 ± $549.14; P = .05) approached a higher cost than MWA.

CONCLUSION: The use of CBCT with overlay fluoroscopic guidance for osteoid osteoma ablation resulted in longer in-room times and greater cost when compared with CCT. These cost considerations should be weighed against potential radiation dose advantage of CBCT when choosing an image guidance modality. Younger age, RFA use, and nonsupine patient position additionally contributed to higher costs.

来源:J Am Coll Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Reis J, Koo KSH, Shivaram GM, et al. Time-Driven Activity-Based Cost Comparison of Osteoid Osteoma Ablation Techniques. J Am Coll Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37473855. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2023.02.035

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。