文献速递乳腺乳腺X线MR

应用层次分析法分析患者对对比增强乳腺X线摄影与MRI作为乳腺癌补充筛查选项的偏好

Analytic Hierarchy Process Analysis of Patient Preferences for Contrast-Enhanced Mammography Versus MRI as Supplemental Screening Options for Breast Cancer.
PubMed 文献 · J Am Coll Radiol · 2023-06-30

该研究于2022年3月23日至6月3日联系579名曾接受对比增强乳腺X线摄影(CEM)筛查和MRI的女性,采用基于层次分析法(AHP)的在线调查评估偏好。222名(38.3%)完成应答者中157名(70.7%,CI:64.7-76.7)偏好CEM而非MRI;幽闭恐惧症是最强CEM偏好因素(38名中37名偏好CEM,97%,CI:86.2-99.9),乳腺摆位是相对最强MRI偏好因素(74名中40名偏好CEM,54%,CI:42.1-65.7)。

要点

  • 222名完成应答者中157名(70.7%,CI:64.7-76.7)偏好CEM而非MRI作为补充筛查。
  • 强调幽闭恐惧症的38名应答者中37名(97%,CI:86.2-99.9)偏好CEM,为CEM偏好最强因素。
  • 强调乳腺摆位的74名应答者中40名(54%,CI:42.1-65.7)偏好CEM,为MRI偏好相对最强因素。

核心结论

  • 基于AHP的模型显示患者对CEM的偏好强于MRI,幽闭恐惧症倾向于偏好CEM,乳腺摆位相对倾向于偏好MRI;结果应有助于指导筛查CEM和MRI的实施。

研究设计与样本

  • 经机构审查委员会批准、符合HIPAA的方案,于2022年3月23日至6月3日联系579名曾接受CEM筛查和MRI的女性,邀请完成基于AHP模型的在线调查;采用分类数据分析方法评估影响偏好的因素,并进行Bonferroni多重性校正。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 222名应答者中157名(70.7%,CI:64.7-76.7)被判定为偏好CEM而非MRI。
  • 222名应答者中74名(33.3%)认为乳腺摆位是最重要标准,38名(17.1%)认为幽闭恐惧症最重要,37名(16.7%)认为静脉置管最重要,39名(17.6%)认为总体压力最重要。
  • 噪声水平、对比剂注射和漠不关心被强调最少,分别由10名(4.5%)、11名(5.0%)和13名(5.9%)女性提出。
  • 强调幽闭恐惧症的应答者中CEM偏好最普遍:37/38(97%,CI:86.2-99.9)。
  • 强调乳腺摆位的应答者中CEM偏好最不普遍:40/74(54%,CI:42.1-65.7)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者结论认为基于AHP的模型显示患者对CEM的偏好强于MRI,结果应有助于指导筛查CEM和MRI的实施。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: To guide implementation of supplemental breast screening by assessing patient preferences for contrast-enhanced mammography (CEM) versus MRI using analytic hierarchy process (AHP) methodology.

METHODS: In an institutional review board-approved, HIPAA-compliant protocol, from March 23 to June 3, 2022, we contacted 579 women who had both CEM screening and MRI. Women were e-mailed an invitation to complete an online survey developed using an AHP-based model to elicit preferences for CEM or MRI. Methods for categorical data analysis were used to evaluate factors affecting preferences, under the Bonferroni correction for multiplicity.

RESULTS: Complete responses were received from 222 (38.3%) women; the 189 women with a personal history of breast cancer had a mean age 61.8 years, and the 34 women without a personal history of breast cancer had a mean age of 53.6 years. Of 222 respondents, 157 (70.7%, confidence interval [CI]: 64.7-76.7) were determined to prefer CEM to MRI. Breast positioning was the most important criterion for 74 of 222 (33.3%) respondents, with claustrophobia, intravenous line placement, and overall stress most important for 38, 37, and 39 women (17.1%, 16.7%, and 17.6%), respectively, and noise level, contrast injection, and indifference being emphasized least frequently (by 10 [4.5%], 11 [5.0%], and 13 [5.9%] women, respectively). CEM preference was most prevalent (MRI least prevalent) for respondents emphasizing claustrophobia (37 of 38 [97%], CI: 86.2-99.9); CEM preference was least prevalent (MRI most prevalent) for respondents emphasizing breast positioning (40 of 74 [54%], CI: 42.1-65.7).

CONCLUSIONS: AHP-based modeling reveals strong patient preferences for CEM over MRI, with claustrophobia favoring preference for CEM and breast positioning relatively favoring preference for MRI. Our results should help guide implementation of screening CEM and MRI.

来源:J Am Coll Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Berg, Bandos, Sava, et al. Analytic Hierarchy Process Analysis of Patient Preferences for Contrast-Enhanced Mammography Versus MRI as Supplemental Screening Options for Breast Cancer. J Am Coll Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37394083. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2023.05.014

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。