在多参数MRI中加入混合多维MRI可提高诊断临床显著前列腺癌的阅片准确性和特异性
回顾性分析61例前列腺切除或MRI融合经直肠超声引导活检前接受mpMRI和HM-MRI的患者,比较4名阅片者(2名经验丰富、2名经验较少)单独mpMRI与mpMRI+HM-MRI的诊断性能。经验较少阅片者加用HM-MRI后每六分区准确性和特异性提高,经验丰富阅片者特异性保持相似,整体阅片者间一致性提高。
要点
- 经验较少阅片者加用HM-MRI后每六分区准确性(82%、81% vs 77%、71%)和特异性(89%、88% vs 84%、75%)提高。
- 经验丰富阅片者加用HM-MRI后每六分区和每患者特异性与单独mpMRI保持相似。
- 每患者阅片者间一致性(Fleiss Kappa)mpMRI+HM-MRI高于单独mpMRI(0.36 vs 0.17)。
核心结论
- 在mpMRI中加入HM-MRI(mpMRI+HM-MRI)提高了经验较少阅片者的特异性和准确性,并改善了整体阅片者间一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2012年8月至2020年2月间接受mpMRI(T2加权、扩散加权和增强扫描)和HM-MRI(多TE/b值组合)后行前列腺切除或MRI融合经直肠超声引导活检的61例患者,由2名经验丰富(R1、R2)和2名经验较少(MRI前列腺经验少于6年,R3、R4)阅片者在同一时段内分别解读单独mpMRI和mpMRI+HM-MRI,以病理为参考标准计算性能指标和Fleiss kappa阅片者间一致性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 阅片者记录PI-RADS 3-5评分、病灶位置及加用HM-MRI后的评分变化;基于病理计算AUC、敏感度、特异性、PPV、NPV和准确性;每六分区R3和R4的mpMRI+HM-MRI准确性分别为82%和81%,高于单独mpMRI的77%和71%(p=.006和<.001);每六分区R3和R4的mpMRI+HM-MRI特异性分别为89%和88%,高于单独mpMRI的84%和75%(p=.009和<.001);每患者R4的mpMRI+HM-MRI特异性从单独mpMRI的7%提高到48%(p<.001);每患者阅片者间一致性mpMRI+HM-MRI的Fleiss Kappa为0.36(95% CI 0.26, 0.46),高于单独mpMRI的0.17(95% CI 0.07, 0.27),p=.009。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对于经验较少的阅片者,加用HM-MRI可提高诊断临床显著前列腺癌的特异性和准确性并改善阅片者间一致性;经验丰富阅片者加用HM-MRI后特异性未见提高。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Compare reader performance when adding the Hybrid Multidimensional-MRI (HM-MRI) map to multiparametric MRI (mpMRI+HM-MRI) versus mpMRI alone and inter-reader agreement in diagnosing clinically significant prostate cancers (CSPCa).
METHODS: All 61 patients who underwent mpMRI (T2-, diffusion-weighted (DWI), and contrast-enhanced scans) and HM-MRI (with multiple TE/b-value combinations) before prostatectomy or MRI-fused-transrectal ultrasound-guided biopsy between August, 2012 and February, 2020, were retrospectively analyzed. Two experienced readers (R1, R2) and two less-experienced readers (less than 6-year MRI prostate experience) (R3, R4) interpreted mpMRI without/with HM-MRI in the same sitting. Readers recorded the PI-RADS 3-5 score, lesion location, and change in score after adding HM-MRI. Each radiologist's mpMRI+HM-MRI and mpMRI performance measures (AUC, sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV, and accuracy) based on pathology, and Fleiss' kappa inter-reader agreement was calculated and compared.
RESULTS: Per-sextant R3 and R4 mpMRI+HM-MRI accuracy (82% 81% vs. 77%, 71%; p=.006, <.001) and specificity (89%, 88% vs. 84%, 75%; p=.009, <.001) were higher than with mpMRI. Per-patient R4 mpMRI+HM-MRI specificity improved (48% from 7%; p<.001). R1 and R2 mpMRI+HM-MRI specificity per-sextant (80%, 93% vs. 81%, 93%; p=.51,>.99) and per-patient (37%, 41% vs. 48%, 37%; p=.16, .57) remained similar to mpMRI. R1 and R2 per-patient AUC with mpMRI+HM-MRI (0.63, 0.64 vs. 0.67, 0.61; p=.33, .36) remained similar to mpMRI, but R3 and R4 mpMRI+HM-MRI AUC (0.73, 0.62) approached R1 and R2 AUC. Per-patient inter-reader agreement, mpMRI+HM-MRI Fleiss Kappa, was higher than mpMRI (0.36 [95% CI 0.26, 0.46] vs. 0.17 [95% CI 0.07, 0.27]); p=.009).
CONCLUSION: Adding HM-MRI to mpMRI (mpMRI+HM-MRI) improved specificity and accuracy for less-experienced readers, improving overall inter-reader agreement.
引用
- Lee, Chatterjee, Harmath, et al. Improving reader accuracy and specificity with the addition of hybrid multidimensional-MRI to multiparametric-MRI in diagnosing clinically significant prostate cancers. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2023. PMID: 37358605. doi:10.1007/s00261-023-03969-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。