胫骨结节-滑车沟距离:儿童人群中EOS与MRI的比较研究
本研究纳入27例(30膝)16岁以下同时接受MRI和EOS检查的儿童患者,由两名评估者在两个时间点测量TT-TG距离。EOS与MRI的平均TT-TG距离均为14 mm,两种模态各自观察者间和观察者内信度均优秀,但EOS与MRI之间的ICC仅为一般(评估者1为0.56,评估者2为0.65),作者认为EOS的TT-TG测量不应在未建立EOS专用阈值前用于决策。
要点
- EOS与MRI的平均TT-TG距离均为14 mm,但两种模态间一致性仅为一般。
- EOS观察者间ICC为0.97、观察者内ICC为0.98-0.99;MRI观察者间ICC为0.98、观察者内ICC为0.99。
- EOS与MRI比较的ICC:评估者1为0.56、评估者2为0.65。
核心结论
- EOS的TT-TG测量精确且可重复,但与MRI的TT-TG测量仅中等程度可比;在建立提示需行胫骨结节远端重排手术的EOS专用TT-TG值之前,EOS的TT-TG测量不应被用于决策。
研究设计与样本
- 比较研究,纳入27例(30膝)16岁以下同时接受MRI和EOS检查的儿童患者,其中男性14例、女性13例,平均年龄13岁(范围7-16岁);两名作者在两个独立时间点分别测量两种模态的TT-TG距离;EOS图像在水平2D平面上测量两点间距离,MRI图像在以后股骨髁轴线为参考的平面上测量;证据等级为II级。
诊断标准与关键数值
- EOS与MRI的平均TT-TG距离均为14 mm;观察者间信度:EOS的ICC为0.97,MRI的ICC为0.98;观察者内可重复性:EOS的ICC为0.98-0.99,MRI的ICC为0.99;EOS与MRI两种模态间比较:评估者1的ICC为0.56,评估者2的ICC为0.65。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,在建立EOS专用的、提示需行胫骨结节远端重排手术的TT-TG值之前,EOS的TT-TG测量不应被用于决策。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: This study aims to compare the relative reliability and accuracy of TT-TG measurements in EOS with that of MRI in a paediatric population.
METHODS: Patients were included if they underwent both an MRI and EOS scans and were under the age of 16. Two authors recorded the TT-TG distances on each modality at two separate time points. In the EOS images, the distance between the two points was measured in the horizontal 2D plane. In the MRI images, it was done in the plane referenced by posterior femoral condylar axis. The intra- and inter-rater reliability was assessed in each modality and between modalities.
RESULTS: Twenty-seven patients (30 knees), 14 males, and 13 females with an average age of 13 years (range: 7-16 years) were included in the study. The mean TT-TG distance on EOS scan and MRI scan was 14 mm. On inter- and intra-observer analysis, both imaging modalities had excellent reliability (0.97 ICC for EOS and 0.98 ICC for MRI inter-observer) and repeatability (0.98-0.99 ICC for EOS and 0.99 ICC for MRI for intra-observer). However, on comparing the two imaging modalities (EOS vs MRI), the ICC was fair (0.56 ICC for rater 1 and 0.65 ICC for rater 2).
CONCLUSION: While the EOS TT-TG measurements were precise and reproducible, they were only moderately comparable to MRI TT-TG measurements. Consequently, EOS TT-TG measurements should not be used for decision-making without the development of EOS-specific TT-TG values that indicate the need for distal realignment surgery.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II.
引用
- Murphy, Rudraraju, Mathews, et al. The tibial tubercle-trochlear groove distance: a comparison study between EOS and MRI in the paediatric population. Skeletal Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37300708. doi:10.1007/s00256-023-04385-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。