深度学习加速肝脏扩散加权成像:自由呼吸与呼吸触发采集的个体内比较及补充体模研究
在86例肝脏MRI患者中比较呼吸触发常规DWI、自由呼吸深度学习DWI和呼吸触发深度学习DWI,呼吸触发深度学习DWI信噪比更高、病灶敏感度与常规DWI相当(0.96 vs 常规DWI),采集时间缩短23.9%;自由呼吸深度学习DWI采集时间缩短61.5%,但病灶敏感度(0.91)显著低于常规DWI且运动相关图像质量较差。
要点
- 呼吸触发深度学习DWI病灶敏感度0.96(95%CI 0.90-0.99),与呼吸触发常规DWI相当,信噪比更高且扫描时间缩短23.9%。
- 自由呼吸深度学习DWI扫描时间缩短61.5%,但病灶敏感度0.91(95%CI 0.85-0.95)显著低于常规DWI,肝脏边缘模糊、肝内血管分界差。
- 各DWI序列整体ADC值无显著差异,自由呼吸与呼吸触发深度学习DWI的ADC标准差显著低于常规DWI(P≤0.003)。
核心结论
- 与呼吸触发常规DWI相比,呼吸触发深度学习DWI信噪比更优、局灶性肝脏病灶敏感度相当且采集时间缩短,可作为呼吸触发常规DWI的合适替代;自由呼吸深度学习DWI在运动相关挑战上存在不足,进一步改进后可能用于时间效率优先的简化筛查方案。
研究设计与样本
- 个体内比较研究,纳入86例有肝脏MRI指征的患者,均接受呼吸触发常规DWI、自由呼吸深度学习DWI和呼吸触发深度学习DWI,除并行成像因子和平均次数外成像参数匹配;另进行专用扩散体模研究;由两名腹部放射科医师独立采用5分法评估图像质量。
关键影像表现/征象
- 呼吸触发深度学习DWI较呼吸触发常规DWI肝脏边缘更锐利、图像噪声更少、心脏运动伪影更轻微(均P<0.001);自由呼吸深度学习DWI较呼吸触发常规DWI肝脏边缘更模糊、肝内血管分界更差。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 呼吸触发深度学习DWI病灶敏感度0.96(95%CI 0.90-0.99),与呼吸触发常规DWI相当,且信噪比和对比噪声比显著更高(P≤0.006)。
- 自由呼吸深度学习DWI病灶敏感度0.91(95%CI 0.85-0.95),显著低于呼吸触发常规DWI(P=0.001),病灶显著度评分也显著更低。
- 各DWI序列在患者和体模中整体ADC值无显著差异,左肝顶ADC值以呼吸触发常规DWI最高。
- 自由呼吸和呼吸触发深度学习DWI的整体ADC标准差显著低于呼吸触发常规DWI(均P≤0.003)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 呼吸触发深度学习DWI在保持病灶检出敏感度的同时提高信噪比并缩短扫描时间,可作为呼吸触发常规DWI的合适替代;自由呼吸深度学习DWI因肝脏边缘模糊和血管分界差、病灶敏感度较低,进一步改进后可能用于时间效率优先的简化筛查方案。
局限性
- 自由呼吸深度学习DWI在运动相关挑战上存在不足(原文结论中提及)。
- 自由呼吸深度学习DWI需进一步改进才可能用于时间效率优先的简化筛查方案(原文结论中提及)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Deep learning-reconstructed diffusion-weighted imaging (DL-DWI) is an emerging promising time-efficient method for liver evaluation, but analyses regarding different motion compensation strategies are lacking. This study evaluated the qualitative and quantitative features, sensitivity for focal lesion detection, and scan time of free-breathing (FB) DL-DWI and respiratory-triggered (RT) DL-DWI compared with RT conventional DWI (C-DWI) in the liver and a phantom.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Eighty-six patients indicated for liver MRI underwent RT C-DWI, FB DL-DWI, and RT DL-DWI with matching imaging parameters other than the parallel imaging factor and number of averages. Two abdominal radiologists independently assessed qualitative features (structural sharpness, image noise, artifacts, and overall image quality) using a 5-point scale. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) along with the apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) value and its standard deviation (SD) were measured in the liver parenchyma and a dedicated diffusion phantom. For focal lesions, per-lesion sensitivity, conspicuity score, SNR, and ADC value were evaluated. Wilcoxon signed rank test and repeated-measures analysis of variance with post hoc test revealed the difference in DWI sequences.
RESULTS: Compared with RT C-DWI, the scan times for FB DL-DWI and RT DL-DWI were reduced by 61.5% and 23.9%, respectively, with statistically significant differences between all 3 pairs (all P 's < 0.001). Respiratory-triggered DL-DWI showed a significantly sharper liver margin, less image noise, and more minor cardiac motion artifact compared with RT C-DWI (all P 's < 0.001), whereas FB DL-DWI showed more blurred liver margins and poorer intrahepatic vessels demarcation than RT C-DWI. Both FB- and RT DL-DWI showed significantly higher SNRs than RT C-DWI in all liver segments (all P 's < 0.001). There was no significant difference in overall ADC values across DWI sequences in the patient or phantom, with the highest value recorded in the left liver dome by RT C-DWI. The overall SD was significantly lower with FB DL-DWI and RT DL-DWI than RT C-DWI (all P 's ≤ 0.003). Respiratory-triggered DL-DWI showed a similar per-lesion sensitivity (0.96; 95% confidence interval, 0.90-0.99) and conspicuity score to those of RT C-DWI and significantly higher SNR and contrast-to-noise ratio values ( P ≤ 0.006). The per-lesion sensitivity of FB DL-DWI (0.91; 95% confidence interval, 0.85-0.95) was significantly lower than that of RT C-DWI ( P = 0.001), with a significantly lower conspicuity score.
CONCLUSIONS: Compared with RT C-DWI, RT DL-DWI demonstrated superior SNR, comparable sensitivity for focal hepatic lesions, and reduced acquisition time, making it a suitable alternative to RT C-DWI. Despite FB DL-DWI's weakness in motion-related challenges, further refinement could potentiate FB DL-DWI in the context of abbreviated screening protocols, where time efficiency is a high priority.
引用
- Kim, Kim, Lee, et al. Deep Learning-Accelerated Liver Diffusion-Weighted Imaging: Intraindividual Comparison and Additional Phantom Study of Free-Breathing and Respiratory-Triggering Acquisitions. Invest Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37212468. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000000988
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。