级联卷积神经网络自动测量负重侧位X线角度诊断平足
本研究基于1200张年轻韩国男性负重侧位足部X线片开发级联CNN深度学习模型,通过22个标志点自动测量三个角度诊断平足。模型测量误差小于人类观察者,并可提高观察者测量准确性和缩短测量时间。外部验证集误差与原测试集相当或更优。
要点
- 级联CNN可自动检测22个标志点并测量平足诊断角度,误差小于骨科医生和全科医生。
- 外部验证集误差与原测试集人类观察者相当或更优,提示模型泛化性良好。
核心结论
- 级联CNN模型在平足诊断的角度测量中准确性和可靠性显著优于人类观察者,并能提高观察者的测量准确性和缩短测量时间。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用1200张年轻成人韩国男性负重侧位足部X线片开发模型,由经验丰富的骨科医生确定22个标志点和三个诊断角度作为参考标准。
- 另一名骨科医生和一名全科医生独立在测试集上识别标志点并测量角度。
- 外部验证使用来自三级转诊中心的100张和公共数据库的17张X线片。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 模型测量三个平足诊断角度相对于参考标准的绝对平均误差小于两名人类观察者。
- 模型辅助下观察者OS平均误差从2.35°±3.01°降至1.55°±2.09°,观察者GP从1.99°±2.76°降至1.56°±2.19°(均p<0.001)。
- 观察者OS总测量时间从195分钟降至135分钟,观察者GP从205分钟降至155分钟。
- 外部验证集模型绝对平均误差与原测试集人类观察者相当或更优。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片时可利用深度学习模型自动测量标志点和角度,提高平足诊断的客观性和效率。
- 模型可作为辅助工具减少观察者间和观察者内变异,但需注意训练数据仅来自年轻韩国男性。
局限性
- 模型开发仅使用年轻成人韩国男性负重侧位足部X线片,外部验证样本量较小(100例和17例)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Diagnosis of flatfoot using a radiograph is subject to intra- and inter-observer variabilities. Here, we developed a cascade convolutional neural network (CNN)-based deep learning model (DLM) for an automated angle measurement for flatfoot diagnosis using landmark detection.
METHODS: We used 1200 weight-bearing lateral foot radiographs from young adult Korean males for the model development. An experienced orthopedic surgeon identified 22 radiographic landmarks and measured three angles for flatfoot diagnosis that served as the ground truth (GT). Another orthopedic surgeon (OS) and a general physician (GP) independently identified the landmarks of the test dataset and measured the angles using the same method. External validation was performed using 100 and 17 radiographs acquired from a tertiary referral center and a public database, respectively.
RESULTS: The DLM showed smaller absolute average errors from the GT for the three angle measurements for flatfoot diagnosis compared with both human observers. Under the guidance of the DLM, the average errors of observers OS and GP decreased from 2.35° ± 3.01° to 1.55° ± 2.09° and from 1.99° ± 2.76° to 1.56° ± 2.19°, respectively (both p < 0.001). The total measurement time decreased from 195 to 135 min in observer OS and from 205 to 155 min in observer GP. The absolute average errors of the DLM in the external validation sets were similar or superior to those of human observers in the original test dataset.
CONCLUSIONS: Our CNN model had significantly better accuracy and reliability than human observers in diagnosing flatfoot, and notably improved the accuracy and reliability of human observers.
KEY POINTS: • Development of deep learning model (DLM) that allows automated angle measurements for landmark detection based on 1200 weight-bearing lateral radiographs for diagnosing flatfoot. • Our DLM showed smaller absolute average errors for flatfoot diagnosis compared with two human observers. • Under the guidance of the model, the average errors of two human observers decreased and total measurement time also decreased from 195 to 135 min and from 205 to 155 min.
引用
- Ryu, Shin, Shin, et al. Automated diagnosis of flatfoot using cascaded convolutional neural network for angle measurements in weight-bearing lateral radiographs. Eur Radiol. 2023. PMID: 36856842. doi:10.1007/s00330-023-09442-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。