文献速递心力衰竭与心肌病

晚期心力衰竭患者转诊专科姑息治疗的标准:国际德尔菲共识研究

Criteria for Referral of Patients With Advanced Heart Failure for Specialized Palliative Care.
PubMed 文献 · J Am Coll Cardiol · 2022-01-01

该研究采用德尔菲法,邀请5大洲具备心脏病学与姑息治疗整合经验的临床专家,对34项疾病相关、24项需求相关和9项时间相关标准进行3轮评分,共识定义为≥70%同意。专家就25项主要转诊标准达成共识,归为6个主题;多数(68%)主要标准的同意率≥90%。这些标准经进一步验证后,或有助于规范住院和/或门诊姑息治疗的可及性。

要点

  • 国际专家就25项晚期心衰转诊专科姑息治疗的主要标准达成共识。
  • 主要标准涵盖疾病/合并症、心衰治疗、住院利用、预后、症状负担及决策/社会支持6类。
  • 68%的主要标准同意率≥90%,标准经进一步验证后或可规范姑息治疗可及性。

核心结论

  • 国际专家就大量晚期心衰患者转诊专科姑息治疗的标准达成共识,经进一步验证后或可用于标准化住院和/或门诊的姑息治疗可及性。

研究设计与样本

  • 德尔菲研究,邀请来自5大洲、具备心脏病学与姑息治疗整合经验的临床专家,对34项疾病相关、24项需求相关和9项时间相关标准进行3轮评分,共识定义为≥70%同意。
  • 第一轮应答率为44/46(96%),第二轮为41/46(89%),第三轮为43/46(93%)。

主要发现

  • 专家小组就25项主要标准达成共识,这些标准归入6个主题。
  • 6个主题包括:晚期/难治性心衰、合并症和并发症(如心脏恶病质、心肾综合征)(n=8);晚期心衰治疗(如慢性正性肌力药物、心脏移植前)(n=4);住院利用(如急诊就诊、住院)(n=2);预后估计(n=1);症状负担/痛苦(如严重躯体/情绪/精神痛苦)(n=6);决策/社会支持(如目标照护讨论)(n=4)。
  • 多数(68%)主要标准的同意率≥90%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共识定义为≥70%同意。
  • 主要标准定义为专家认可单独满足该标准即足以证明转诊合理。
  • 25项主要标准分布在6个主题下,其中68%的主要标准同意率≥90%。

临床怎么用

  • 这些共识标准可用于识别晚期心衰患者中适合转诊专科姑息治疗的对象,并指导转诊时机。
  • 标准涵盖疾病、需求和时间维度,有助于在住院和/或门诊环境中标准化姑息治疗的可及性。

局限性

  • 研究为德尔菲共识,标准需进一步验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Patients with advanced heart failure have substantial supportive care needs. Specialist palliative care can be beneficial, but it is unclear who is most appropriate for referral and when patients should be referred. OBJECTIVES: We conducted a Delphi study of international experts to identify consensus referral criteria for specialist palliative care for patients with advanced heart failure. METHODS: Clinicians from 5 continents with expertise in the integration of cardiology and palliative care were asked to rate 34 disease-based, 24 needs-based, and 9 time-based criteria over 3 rounds. Consensus was defined a priori as ≥70% agreement. A criterion was coded as major if the experts endorsed that meeting that criterion alone was adequate to justify a referral. RESULTS: The response rate was 44 of 46 (96%), 41 of 46 (89%), and 43 of 46 (93%) in the first, second, and third rounds, respectively. Panelists reached consensus on 25 major criteria for specialist palliative care referral. The 25 major criteria were categorized under 6 topics, including "advanced/refractory heart failure, comorbidities, and complications" (eg, cardiac cachexia, cardiorenal syndrome) (n = 8), "advanced heart failure therapies" (eg, chronic inotropes, precardiac transplant) (n = 4), "hospital utilization" (eg, emergency room visits, hospitalization) (n = 2), "prognostic estimate" (n = 1), "symptom burden/distress" (eg, severe physical/emotional/spiritual distress) (n = 6), and "decision making/social support" (eg, goals-of-care discussions) (n = 4). The majority (68%) of major criteria had ≥90% agreement. CONCLUSIONS: International experts reached consensus on a large number of criteria for referral to specialist palliative care. With further validation, these criteria may be useful for standardizing palliative care access in the inpatient and/or outpatient settings.

来源:J Am Coll Cardiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chang, Allen, McClung, et al. Criteria for Referral of Patients With Advanced Heart Failure for Specialized Palliative Care. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2022. PMID: 35863850. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2022.04.057

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。