五瓣脉冲电场消融联合后壁隔离治疗持续性房颤的学习曲线
该研究纳入182例接受透视和心腔内超声引导五瓣脉冲电场消融的持续性房颤患者,分析肺静脉隔离联合后壁隔离的学习曲线及解剖因素对急性消融不完整的影响。结果显示消融不完整率随手术经验增加而下降,早期阶段发生率为55%,中期为32%,晚期为4.8%。手术阶段是消融不完整的主要决定因素,左房容积仅呈轻度独立相关。
要点
- 前20例手术中消融不完整率最高,建议早期加强标测验证。
- 左房容积每增加1mL,消融不完整风险仅轻度升高。
- 即使经验丰富,系统电解剖标测仍对发现和纠正不完整消融很重要。
核心结论
- 五瓣脉冲电场消融联合肺静脉隔离和后壁隔离的消融完整性随手术经验增加逐步改善。
- 手术经验似乎是消融不完整的主导因素,左房容积仅有轻度作用。
- 即使累积大量手术经验后,系统电解剖标测对识别和纠正不完整消融仍然重要。
研究设计与样本
- 连续纳入182例持续性房颤患者,接受透视和心腔内超声引导的五瓣脉冲电场消融。
- 采用分段逻辑回归和序列区块分析识别学习阶段。
- 多变量模型评估手术阶段、左房容积和后壁几何形态与消融不完整的关系。
主要发现
- 学习曲线存在,消融不完整减少最明显发生在前20例手术。
- 早期阶段不完整消融发生率为55%,中期为32%,晚期为4.8%。
- 手术阶段是不完整消融的主要决定因素,早期和中期风险分别约为晚期的24倍和9倍。
- 左房容积每增加1mL,不完整消融风险独立增加(OR 1.009)。
- 后壁几何形态与消融不完整无独立相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 不完整消融定义为系统重新标测后仍存在残留传导,需要额外脉冲电场消融。
- 手术阶段划分:第1-20例为早期,第21-160例为中期,第161例及以上为晚期。
临床怎么用
- 开展该术式初期应重点关注消融完整性,通过系统标测及时发现不完整消融。
- 左房容积较大的患者需注意不完整消融风险,但经验积累仍是关键因素。
局限性
- 晚期阶段随访时间较短,可能影响心律失常复发率的比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
ABSTRACT Background Pentaspline pulsed-field ablation (PFA) has emerged as a novel modality for pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) and posterior wall isolation (PWI) in persistent atrial fibrillation (AF). However, the learning curve associated with combined PVI + PWI and the contribution of anatomical factors to acute lesion completeness remain incompletely defined. Methods We analyzed 182 consecutive patients with persistent AF undergoing fluoroscopy- and intracardiac echocardiography–guided PFA. Acute incomplete lesions were defined as residual conduction requiring additional PFA applications after systematic remapping. Learning phases were identified using segmented logistic regression and sequential block analysis. Multivariable models evaluated procedural phase, left atrial volume (LAV), and posterior wall geometry. Results A learning curve was observed, with the greatest reduction in incomplete lesion formation occurring during the first 20 procedures. Incomplete lesions occurred in 55% of cases 1–20 (early phase), 32% of cases 21–160 (intermediate phase), and 4.8% of cases ≥ 161 (late phase). Procedural phase was the dominant determinant of incomplete lesions, with approximately 24-fold and 9-fold higher odds during the early and intermediate phases, respectively. Larger LAV showed a modest independent association (OR 1.009 per mL), whereas posterior wall geometry was not independently associated. Mid-term arrhythmia recurrence did not differ across phases, although follow-up duration was shorter in the late phase. Conclusions Lesion completeness during pentaspline PFA with PVI + PWI improves progressively with increasing procedural experience. Although larger LAV may contribute modestly to incomplete lesion formation, procedural experience appears to play the predominant role. Systematic electroanatomical remapping remains important for identifying and correcting incomplete lesions even after substantial procedural experience has been accumulated.
引用
- Journal of Cardiovascular Electrophysiology:Learning Curve of Pentaspline Pulsed‐Field Ablation With Posterior Wall Isolation for Persistent Atrial Fibrillation
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。