心脏康复可及性与利用的性别差异:心血管照护障碍与促进因素系统综述
女性在转诊和初始可及性阶段最一致地处于劣势,转诊后或调整临床、心理社会及结构性因素后差异常缩小。系统化转诊路径及针对交通、照护、合并症、经济负担和项目匹配的干预可改善公平性。
要点
- 女性在心脏康复转诊和初始可及性阶段差距最一致,转诊后差异可缩小。
- 系统化或自动转诊、联络支持转诊可提高女性心脏康复利用率。
- 交通、照护、合并症、经济负担和对 CR 知晓不足对女性影响更突出。
核心结论
- 心脏康复的性别差异具有阶段特异性,最强且最一致的差距出现在转诊和初始可及性阶段。
- 转诊后或采用系统化转诊路径时,性别差异可能缩小。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索 PubMed 2000 年 1 月至 2025 年 3 月期间报告性别特异性心脏康复利用结局的研究。
主要发现
- 一项大型多中心转诊策略队列中,女性总体转诊率为 57.8%,男性为 67.2%。
- 同一队列中,女性总体入组率为 49.3%,男性为 58.6%;但在已转诊患者中,女性后续入组率为 82%,男性为 85%。
- 交通、照护责任、合并症、经济限制和对心脏康复知晓不足对女性的影响不成比例地更高。
- 工作与时间冲突在男性中更为突出。
- 最大规模完成分析(n=5922)显示,调整后性别不是退出的独立预测因素(OR 0.89,95% CI 0.76–1.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 女性总体转诊率 57.8%,男性 67.2%;女性总体入组率 49.3%,男性 58.6%。
- 已转诊患者中,女性后续入组率 82%,男性 85%。
- 最大完成分析中,退出风险调整后 OR 0.89,95% CI 0.76–1.05。
- 自动或系统化转诊、联络支持转诊、就近项目地理匹配、灵活交付模式和定向导航被识别为促进因素。
临床怎么用
- 心脏康复服务应优先采用系统级转诊策略,以缩小转诊和初始可及性阶段的性别差距。
- 同时针对交通、照护责任、合并症、经济负担和项目匹配障碍实施干预。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
ABSTRACT Cardiac rehabilitation (CR) is central to secondary prevention, but women remain less likely than men to access and fully utilize CR. This systematic review examined sex differences across the CR utilization continuum, separating referral, enrollment, attendance or session exposure, and program completion, and evaluated barriers and facilitators at each stage. PubMed was searched for studies published from January 1, 2000 through March 2025 reporting sex-specific CR utilization outcomes. Supplementary citation searching was undertaken to improve completeness. Outcomes were classified as referral, enrollment, attendance or session exposure, and completion or dropout. Forty-six unique study cohorts, including over one million patients, met the inclusion criteria. Women were most consistently disadvantaged at referral and initial access. In several cohorts, sex differences narrowed after referral or after adjustment for clinical, psychosocial, and structural factors. A large multicentre referral-strategy cohort reported lower overall referral (57.8% vs. 67.2%) and enrollment (49.3% vs. 58.6%) in women than men, but among referred patients, subsequent enrollment was similar (82% vs. 85%). Across studies, transport, caregiving, comorbidity, financial constraints, and lower CR awareness disproportionately affected women, while work and time conflicts were more prominent among men. The largest completion analysis (n = 5922) found that sex was not an independent predictor of withdrawal after adjustment (OR 0.89, 95% CI 0.76–1.05). Automatic or systematic referral, liaison-supported referral, geographic matching to nearer programs, flexible delivery models, and targeted navigation were identified as facilitators of access and utilization. Sex disparities in CR are stage-specific rather than a single “adherence” phenomenon. The strongest and most consistent gap occurs at referral and initial access, while differences may narrow once patients are referred or when systematic referral pathways are used. Equity-focused CR services should combine system-level referral strategies with interventions addressing transport, caregiving, comorbidity, financial, and program-fit barriers.
引用
- Catheterization and Cardiovascular Interventions:Sex Differences in Cardiac Rehabilitation Access and Utilization: A Systematic Review of Barriers and Facilitators in Cardiovascular Care
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。