运动负荷超声心动图诊断射血分数保留心衰的多中心研究
本研究纳入482例不明原因慢性呼吸困难患者,在侵入性血流动力学运动试验同步超声下,验证运动负荷超声联合静息左心房顺应性对射血分数保留心衰(HFpEF)的诊断效能。结果显示,现有H2FPEF、HFA-PEFF和HFpEF-ABA评分联合运动超声敏感性仅55%-60%,准确性61%-67%。联合左心房顺应性并采用分别优化敏感性与特异性的界值后,确诊分类患者敏感性提升至95%-99%,需侵入性检查者由约60%降至约30%,结果在国际多中心队列中验证。
要点
- 现有运动超声诊断HFpEF敏感性仅55%-60%,不能替代侵入性检查。
- 联合左心房顺应性并采用分别优化的界值可提升敏感性至95%-99%。
- 采用优化界值可使需侵入性检查者由约60%降至约30%。
核心结论
- 目前常用的HFpEF无创诊断方法敏感性不足,运动负荷超声不能替代侵入性检查。
- 加入左心房应变并采用分别优化的判定与排除界值可扩展无创诊断分类,同时识别仍需侵入性检查的患者。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入482例慢性不明原因呼吸困难患者,均接受侵入性血流动力学运动试验并同步进行超声心动图。
- 验证结果在国际多中心队列中复核,该队列患者接受静息-运动超声及侵入性运动试验。
主要发现
- 482例中386例存在HFpEF,96例为非心源性呼吸困难。
- 使用现行推荐运动超声联合H2FPEF、HFA-PEFF或HFpEF-ABA评分的敏感性为55%-60%,准确性为61%-67%。
- 在运动超声基础上加入静息左心房顺应性异常,可将敏感性提升至84%-85%,但假阳性率升至31%-43%。
- 确诊分类患者中采用优化界值后敏感性提升至95%-99%,需侵入性运动检查者由约60%降至约30%。
关键数值与推荐
- 判定HFpEF界值为运动E/e'≥13.8或静息左心房顺应性≤1.6%。
- 排除HFpEF界值为运动E/e'<7.2且静息左心房顺应性>4.4%。
- 不满足上述判定或排除条件的患者归为不确定组,仍需侵入性检查确诊。
- 静息左心房顺应性由左心房储器应变除以E/e'计算。
临床怎么用
- 对不明原因呼吸困难患者,不应单独依赖现行运动超声评分来排除HFpEF。
- 可联合静息左心房顺应性与运动E/e',采用分别优化的界值进行判定、排除或识别需侵入性检查者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Exercise stress echocardiography is recommended as an alternative to invasive testing for diagnosing heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF), but an evidence-based operational framework guiding its application is lacking. METHODS: Patients with chronic unexplained dyspnoea underwent invasive haemodynamic exercise testing with simultaneous echocardiography to test the hypotheses that (i) the current diagnostic algorithms (H2FPEF, HFA-PEFF, and HFpEF-ABA scores) could be enhanced when combined with exercise echocardiography; and (ii) incorporating resting left atrial (LA) compliance (LA reservoir strain divided by E/e') could further improve diagnostic triage, using separate cut points optimizing sensitivity and specificity. Findings were then validated in an international multicentre cohort. RESULTS: Of 482 patients, HFpEF was present in 386 and non-cardiac dyspnoea in 96. Sensitivity to detect HFpEF was only 55%-60% and accuracy 61%-67% using individual diagnostic scores with currently recommended exercise echocardiography. Addition of abnormal resting LA compliance to exercise echocardiography increased sensitivity to 84%-85% but increased the false-positive rate to 31%-43%. Applying separate cut points that optimize specificity and sensitivity (either exercise E/e' ≥ 13.8 or resting LA compliance ≤1.6% to rule-in HFpEF; both exercise E/e' < 7.2 and resting LA compliance >4.4% to rule-out HFpEF, remaining patients indeterminate who require invasive testing) improved sensitivity to 95%-99% among definitively classified patients and reduced the number of patients that require invasive exercise testing from ∼60% to ∼30%. Findings were replicated in a multicentre, international validation cohort of patients undergoing rest-exercise echocardiography and invasive exercise testing. CONCLUSIONS: Currently used non-invasive approaches to HFpEF diagnosis have inadequate sensitivity, indicating that exercise echocardiography cannot supplant invasive testing. Addition of LA strain imaging with optimized rule-in or rule-out values improves diagnostic triage by expanding non-invasive rule-in/rule-out classifications while identifying patients who still require invasive testing in the evaluation of HFpEF.
引用
- Harada, Reddy, Sorimachi, et al. Exercise stress echocardiography for diagnosis of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction: a multicentre study. Eur Heart J. 2026. PMID: 42720269. doi:10.1093/eurheartj/ehag716
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。