文献速递冠心病

HEART评分组分再加权对急诊胸痛危险分层的影响:多中心验证研究

Does increasing model complexity improve HEART-based chest pain risk stratification? A multicentre development and held-out emergency department validation study
RSS 订阅 · Open Heart

三种模型AUROC相近,但CVLR与XGBoost的AUPRC显著高于HEART。数据驱动再加权改善风险排序,但未扩大低危分类比例。

要点

  • HEART组分数据驱动再加权可改善精确率-召回率表现,但AUROC无显著提升。
  • CVLR与XGBoost相比HEART未见扩大低危分类比例。
  • 在该验证队列中30天MACE发生率为3.23%。

核心结论

  • 对HEART组分进行数据驱动再加权可改善精确率-召回率表现与风险排序,但XGBoost相较分类CVLR无增量获益。
  • 各模型在可比敏感性工作点下低危分类比例未见扩大。

主要发现

  • 验证队列中267例(3.23%)发生30天MACE。
  • HEART、CVLR和XGBoost的AUROC分别为0.855、0.857和0.856,两两比较p>0.05。
  • CVLR的AUPRC为0.237,XGBoost为0.244,均显著高于HEART的0.187(p<0.001)。
  • CVLR与XGBoost之间AUPRC无显著差异(p=0.305)。
  • 在可比敏感性工作点,HEART、CVLR和XGBoost分别将63.74%、59.39%和61.58%的患者分类为低危。

关键数值与推荐

  • 低危MACE发生率:HEART为0.53%,CVLR为0.51%,XGBoost为0.57%。
  • 模型预测目标为30天MACE。
  • 模型输入仅限HEART评分的五个组分:病史、心电图、年龄、危险因素和肌钙蛋白。

临床怎么用

  • 在仅使用HEART五组分的前提下,数据驱动再加权有望改善胸痛风险排序,但XGBoost并不优于较简单的CVLR。

局限性

  • 本研究为回顾性设计,数据来自已有HEART评分的患者。
  • 仅在一个地理独立的急诊科进行验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Background and objectives The History, ECG, Age, Risk factors and Troponin (HEART) score is widely used for emergency department (ED) chest pain risk stratification, but its fixed-point structure may not optimally represent relationships between its components and major adverse cardiac events (MACE). We evaluated whether increasingly flexible modelling approaches improve prediction when restricted to the same five HEART components. Methods We conducted a retrospective multicentre cohort study of 47 853 adult ED patients with chest pain and documented HEART scores across six EDs from 2021 to 2023. Data from five EDs (n=39 587) were used for model development and one geographically held-out ED (n=8266) was used for validation. The conventional HEART score was compared with categorical cross-validated logistic regression (CVLR) and extreme gradient boosting (XGBoost) for predicting 30-day MACE. Performance was assessed using the area under the receiver operating characteristic (AUROC), the area under the precision–recall curve (AUPRC), the Brier score, paired bootstrap comparisons and clinical performance at comparable-sensitivity operating points. Results In the held-out validation cohort, 267 patients (3.23%) experienced 30-day MACE. AUROCs were similar for HEART (0.855), CVLR (0.857) and XGBoost (0.856; pairwise p>0.05). In contrast, both data-driven models demonstrated significantly higher AUPRC than HEART: CVLR (0.237 vs 0.187; =0.050, p<0.001) and XGBoost (0.244 vs 0.187; =0.057, p<0.001) with no significant difference between CVLR and XGBoost (p=0.305). At comparable-sensitivity operating points, HEART, CVLR and XGBoost classified 63.74%, 59.39% and 61.58% of patients as low risk, respectively, with corresponding low-risk MACE rates of 0.53%, 0.51% and 0.57%. Conclusions Data-driven reweighting of HEART components improved precision–recall performance and risk ranking compared with fixed HEART scoring. However, XGBoost provided no incremental benefit over categorical CVLR, and neither approach expanded low-risk classification at comparable sensitivity.

来源:Open Heart,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Open Heart:Does increasing model complexity improve HEART-based chest pain risk stratification? A multicentre development and held-out emergency department validation study

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。