指南与共识冠心病

冠状动脉旁路移植术中转流时间流量测量的应用:系统评价与专家意见声明

The Use of Intraoperative Transit Time Flow Measurement for Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery: Systematic Review of the Evidence and Expert Opinion Statements.
指南 / 共识 · Circulation · 2021-10-04

本文通过系统评价和改良Delphi法专家共识,评估转流时间流量测量(TTFM)在冠状动脉旁路移植术(CABG)质量控制中的作用。现有证据支持TTFM读数与桥血管通畅性和术后临床结局相关,但方法学异质性高,对动脉桥和左前降支桥的证据更稳健。共识形成10条专家声明以标准化TTFM的临床应用。

要点

  • TTFM读数与CABG术后桥血管通畅性和临床结局相关,但研究间方法学异质性大。
  • 证据对动脉桥及左前降支桥更稳健,对静脉桥证据相对较弱。
  • 专家共识形成10条声明,旨在标准化TTFM使用并指导临床决策。

核心结论

  • TTFM虽可能增加手术费用和时长并需学习曲线,但鉴于桥血管功能障碍的潜在临床后果,其成本/获益比似乎总体有利。

研究设计与样本

  • 遵循PRISMA标准对TTFM及其他CABG质量控制方法进行系统评价。
  • 由19名专家采用三步改良Delphi法(两轮电子投票和一次最终面对面虚拟会议)制定专家建议。

主要发现

  • 现有证据支持TTFM读数与桥血管通畅性和术后临床结局存在关联,但已发表系列间方法学异质性高。
  • 证据对动脉桥而非静脉桥、以及对左前降支桥更为稳健。
  • TTFM使用增加手术时长和费用,但无数据量化此效应。

关键数值与推荐

  • 基于系统评价制定10条TTFM临床实践专家声明。
  • 6条在首轮投票获批,3条在第二轮获批,1条在虚拟会议获批。

临床怎么用

  • 共识声明有助于标准化TTFM在临床实践中的使用,并为临床决策提供指导。

局限性

  • 已发表系列间方法学异质性高。
  • TTFM增加手术时长和费用的效应缺乏数据量化。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Transit time flow measurement (TTFM) allows quality control in coronary artery bypass grafting but remains largely underused, probably because of limited information and the lack of standardization. We performed a systematic review of the evidence on TTFM and other methods for quality control in coronary artery bypass grafting following PRISMA standards and elaborated expert recommendations by using a structured process. A panel of 19 experts took part in the consensus process using a 3-step modified Delphi method that consisted of 2 rounds of electronic voting and a final face-to-face virtual meeting. Eighty percent agreement was required for acceptance of the statements. A 2-level scale (strong, moderate) was used to grade the statements based on the perceived likelihood of a clinical benefit. The existing evidence supports an association between TTFM readings and graft patency and postoperative clinical outcomes, although there is high methodological heterogeneity among the published series. The evidence is more robust for arterial, rather than venous, grafts and for grafts to the left anterior descending artery. Although TTFM use increases the duration and the cost of surgery, there are no data to quantify this effect. Based on the systematic review, 10 expert statements for TTFM use in clinical practice were formulated. Six were approved at the first round of voting, 3 at the second round, and 1 at the virtual meeting. In conclusion, although TTFM use may increase the costs and duration of the procedure and requires a learning curve, its cost/benefit ratio seems largely favorable, in view of the potential clinical consequences of graft dysfunction. These consensus statements will help to standardize the use of TTFM in clinical practice and provide guidance in clinical decision-making.

来源:Circulation,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gaudino M, Sandner S, Di Giammarco G, et al. The Use of Intraoperative Transit Time Flow Measurement for Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery: Systematic Review of the Evidence and Expert Opinion Statements. Circulation. 2021. PMID: 34606302. doi:10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.121.054311

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。