有症状主动脉瓣狭窄共享决策的学习曲线
该混合方法试点研究在2个学术医疗中心纳入35例有症状的重度主动脉瓣狭窄患者,由6名心脏团队医生使用决策辅助工具。重复使用决策辅助工具与共享决策评分逐步提高相关,并与患者知识及满意度改善相关,但决策冲突未改变。定性访谈显示医生未感知决策辅助工具有显著获益。
要点
- 重复使用决策辅助工具与观察者OPTION5共享决策评分逐步提高相关。
- 多次使用决策辅助工具与患者知识及满意度改善相关,但决策冲突未改变。
- 医生访谈中未感知决策辅助工具显著获益,持续实施可能性低。
核心结论
- 心脏团队医生使用决策辅助工具与共享决策及以患者为中心结局改善相关,但医生未感知显著获益,持续实施可能性低。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究,包含非随机前后干预及医生访谈,于2015年4月30日至2017年12月7日在新英格兰北部2个学术医疗中心开展。
- 纳入35例有症状主动脉瓣狭窄且手术风险高至禁忌的患者,由6名医生使用重度主动脉瓣狭窄决策辅助工具,患者在经导管主动脉瓣置换与药物治疗间选择。
主要发现
- 观察者OPTION5共享决策评分随决策辅助工具重复使用逐步提高:常规诊疗17.9(7.6),首次使用60.5(30.9),第五次使用79.0(8.4),常规诊疗与第五次使用比较P < .001。
- 多次使用决策辅助工具与患者知识增加相关(平均差异18.0%;95% CI,1.2%-34.8%;P = .04)。
- 多次使用决策辅助工具与患者满意度提高相关(平均差异6.7%;95% CI,2.5%-10.8%;P = .01)。
- 决策冲突未改变:常规诊疗96.0%(9.4%),首次使用93.8%(12.5%),第五次使用95.0%(11.2%),P = .60。
- 定性分析显示医生认为自身已在无决策辅助工具下采用共享决策方法,且决策辅助工具未被老年患者充分理解,价值观澄清或卒中风险讨论不频繁。
临床怎么用
- 心脏团队可考虑重复使用决策辅助工具以提升共享决策质量及患者知识与满意度。
- 需关注老年患者对决策辅助工具的理解程度,并加强价值观澄清及卒中风险讨论。
- 医生对决策辅助工具的感知获益不足可能影响持续实施,需针对性干预。
局限性
- 非随机前后干预设计,样本量小(35例患者、6名医生),为试点研究。
- 医生均为男性,且仅在新英格兰北部2个学术医疗中心开展。
- 定性访谈在干预结束后较长时间进行,可能存在回忆偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Shared decision-making (SDM) is widely advocated for patients with valvular heart disease yet is not integrated into the heart team model for patients with symptomatic aortic stenosis. Decision aids (DAs) have been shown to improve patient-centered outcomes and may facilitate SDM. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether the repeated use of a DA by heart teams is associated with greater SDM, along with improved patient-centered outcomes and clinician attitudes about DAs. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This mixed-methods study included a nonrandomized pre-post intervention and clinician interviews. It was conducted between April 30, 2015, and December 7, 2017, with quantitative analysis performed between January 12, 2017, and May 26, 2017, within 2 academic medical centers in northern New England among 35 patients with symptomatic aortic stenosis who were at high to prohibitive risk for surgery. The qualitative analysis was performed between August 6, 2018, and May 7, 2019. The Severe Aortic Stenosis Decision Aid was delivered by 6 clinicians, with patients choosing between transcatheter aortic valve replacement and medical management. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Clinician SDM performance was measured using the Observer OPTION5 scale with dual-independent coding of audiotaped clinic visits. Previsit and postvisit surveys measured the patient's knowledge, satisfaction, and decisional conflict. Audiotaped clinician interviews were coded, and qualitative thematic analysis was performed. RESULTS: Six male clinicians and 35 patients (19 of 34 women [55.9%; 1 survey was missing]; mean [SD] age, 85.8 [7.8] years) participated in the study. Shared decision-making increased stepwise with repeated use of the DA (mean [SD] Observer OPTION5 scores: usual care, 17.9 [7.6]; first use of a DA, 60.5 [30.9]; fifth use of a DA, 79.0 [8.4]; P < .001 for comparison between usual care and fifth use of DA). Multiple uses of the DA were associated with increased patient knowledge (mean difference, 18.0%; 95% CI, 1.2%-34.8%; P = .04) and satisfaction (mean difference, 6.7%; 95% CI, 2.5%-10.8%; P = .01) but not decisional conflict (mean [SD]: usual care, 96.0% [9.4%]; first use of DA, 93.8% [12.5%]; fifth use of DA, 95.0% [11.2%]; P = .60). Qualitative analysis of clinicians' interviews revealed that clinicians perceived that they used an SDM approach without DAs and that the DA was not well understood by elderly patients. There was infrequent values clarification or discussion of stroke risk. CONCLUSION AND RELEVANCE: In a mixed-methods pilot study, use of a DA for severe aortic stenosis by heart team clinicians was associated with improved SDM and patient-centered outcomes. However, in qualitative interviews, heart team clinicians did not perceive a significant benefit of the DA, and therefore sustained implementation is unlikely. This pilot study of SDM clarifies new research directions for heart teams.
引用
- Coylewright M, O'Neill E, Sherman A, et al. The Learning Curve for Shared Decision-making in Symptomatic Aortic Stenosis. JAMA Cardiol. 2020. PMID: 31995126. doi:10.1001/jamacardio.2019.5719
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。