机械瓣与生物瓣主动脉瓣置换结果:年轻患者生物瓣需谨慎
本文回顾了机械瓣与生物瓣主动脉瓣置换的头对头随机对照试验及后续大型回顾性研究,指出机械瓣耐久但存在抗凝相关出血,生物瓣易发生瓣膜功能障碍并需再次手术,该趋势在年轻患者中更明显;后续研究未显示两种瓣膜在主动脉位置的生存优势差异,指南亦反映这一均衡;患者选择、预期寿命延长、房颤抗凝需求、经导管瓣中瓣技术及抗凝治疗进展持续影响年轻患者瓣膜选择。
要点
- 机械瓣耐久但伴抗凝相关出血,生物瓣易功能障碍需再次手术。
- 年轻患者中生物瓣功能障碍和再次手术风险更高。
- 后续回顾性研究未显示两种瓣膜在主动脉位置的生存优势差异。
核心结论
- 机械瓣耐久但伴抗凝相关出血,生物瓣易功能障碍需再次手术,该趋势在年轻患者中更强。
- 后续大型回顾性研究未显示两种瓣膜在主动脉位置植入年轻患者中的生存优势差异。
研究设计与样本
- 两项头对头随机对照试验比较组织瓣与机械心脏瓣膜假体。
- 后续多项大型回顾性研究使用已发表文献的荟萃分析或注册登记数据。
主要发现
- 两项随机对照试验证实机械瓣耐久但患者遭受抗凝相关出血。
- 接受组织瓣的患者更可能发生人工瓣膜功能障碍并需要再次手术。
- 该趋势在年轻患者中更强。
- 后续大型回顾性研究未能显示两种瓣膜在年轻患者主动脉位置植入时的生存优势。
临床怎么用
- 年轻患者选择主动脉瓣假体时需权衡机械瓣的抗凝出血风险与生物瓣的结构性衰败及再手术风险。
- 患者选择、预期寿命、房颤抗凝需求、经导管瓣中瓣技术及抗凝治疗进展均应纳入决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The first aortic valve prosthesis, implanted more than 50 years ago, was a mechanical prosthesis (ball-and-cage design). Over the ensuing decades, tissue prostheses and new mechanical designs were introduced to mitigate the need for anticoagulation with its associated side effects. Tissue and mechanical heart valve prostheses were compared in two head-to-head randomised control trials. Both of these confirmed that mechanical prostheses were durable but patients suffered anticoagulant-related bleeds. Patients who received a tissue prosthesis were more likely to suffer prosthetic dysfunction and require reoperation. This trend was stronger in younger patients. Since the publication of those two trials, several large retrospective studies using data from meta-analyses of published papers or registries have failed to show a survival advantage of either prostheses when implanted in the aortic position in younger patients. This equipoise has been reflected in the heart valve disease guidelines published by European and US societies. In recent years, the primacy of patient choice, the rapid increase in life expectancy of populations, the increased incidence of atrial fibrillation with requirement for anticoagulation, the advent of transcatheter techniques to treat degenerating tissue valves as well as advances in anticoagulant therapy and in new tissue and to a lesser extent mechanical prosthetic design continue to influence choice of aortic valve prosthesis in younger patients undergoing aortic valve replacement.
引用
- Briffa NP. Results of mechanical versus tissue AVR: caution in young patients with tissue AVR. Heart. 2019. PMID: 30846523. doi:10.1136/heartjnl-2018-313516
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。