医疗责任改革与临床医生冠心病管理方式的相关性
该研究采用双重差分设计,比较2003至2005年间通过损害赔偿上限的9个州与20个无上限州医生的冠心病检测与治疗变化。
核心结论
- 医生在医疗责任风险降低后,对冠心病检测和治疗采取不同策略,容忍更多临床不确定性。
- 新上限州医生减少初始左心导管、应激试验后转诊导管及血运重建,但总体缺血评估量不变。
研究设计与样本
- 双重差分设计,比较9个新通过损害赔偿上限州与20个无上限州医生在冠心病检测和治疗上的变化。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应意识到医疗责任环境可能影响冠心病检测决策,尤其初始诊断选择和血运重建转诊。
- 在低医疗责任风险环境下,可更审慎地权衡侵入性检查与非侵入性应激测试的获益与风险。
局限性
- 研究为观察性设计,不能完全排除未测量混杂因素。
- 新上限州与无上限州在人口学、收入、医生密度和管理式医疗渗透率上存在差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Physicians often report practicing defensive medicine to reduce malpractice risk, including performing expensive but marginally beneficial tests and procedures. Although there is little evidence that malpractice reform affects overall health care spending, it may influence physician behavior for specific conditions involving clinical uncertainty. OBJECTIVE: To examine whether reducing malpractice risk is associated with clinical decisions involving coronary artery disease testing and treatment. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Difference-in-differences design, comparing physician-specific changes in coronary artery disease testing and treatment in 9 new-cap states that adopted damage caps between 2003 and 2005 with 20 states without caps. We used the 5% national Medicare fee-for-service random sample between 1999 and 2013. Physicians (n = 75 801; 36 647 in new-cap states) who ordered or performed 2 or more coronary angiographies. Data were analyzed from June 2015 to January 2018. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Changes in ischemic evaluation rates for possible coronary artery disease, type of initial evaluation (stress testing or coronary angiography), progression from stress test to angiography, and progression from ischemic evaluation to revascularization (percutaneous coronary intervention or coronary artery bypass grafting). RESULTS: We studied 36 647 physicians in new-cap states and 39 154 physicians in no-cap states. New-cap states had younger populations, more minorities, lower per-capita incomes, fewer physicians per capita, and lower managed care penetration. Following cap adoption, new-cap physicians reduced invasive testing (angiography) as a first diagnostic test compared with control physicians (relative change, -24%; 95% CI, -40% to -7%; P = .005) with an offsetting increase in noninvasive stress testing (7.8%; 95% CI, -3.6% to 19.3%; P = .17), and referred fewer patients for angiography following stress testing (-21%; 95% CI, -40% to -2%; P = .03). New-cap physicians also reduced revascularization rates after ischemic evaluation (-23%; 95% CI, -40% to -4%; P = .02; driven by fewer percutaneous coronary interventions). Changes in overall ischemic evaluation rates were similar for new-cap and control physicians (-0.05%; 95% CI, -8.0% to 7.9%; P = .98). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Physicians substantially altered their approach to coronary artery disease testing and follow-up after initial ischemic evaluations following adoption of damage caps. They performed a similar number of ischemic evaluations but conducted fewer initial left heart catheterizations, referred fewer stress-tested patients for left heart catheterizations, and referred fewer patients for revascularization. These findings suggest that physicians tolerate greater clinical uncertainty in coronary artery disease testing and treatment if they face lower malpractice risk.
引用
- Farmer SA, Moghtaderi A, Schilsky S, et al. Association of Medical Liability Reform With Clinician Approach to Coronary Artery Disease Management. JAMA Cardiol. 2018. PMID: 29874382. doi:10.1001/jamacardio.2018.1360
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。