使用风险模型预测门诊心力衰竭个体患者未来一年死亡
研究纳入3个整合健康系统的10930例门诊心衰成人患者,用SHFM和MAGGIC风险计算器估计1年死亡概率并与实际死亡比较。群体水平预测尚可(C统计量0.66和0.69),但个体水平上模型对多数实际死亡者预测概率偏低,不能可靠识别个体。
要点
- SHFM对1661例死亡者中仅8例预测1年死亡概率>50%,敏感度0.5%。
- MAGGIC对1661例死亡者中52例预测>50%,敏感度3.1%。
- SHFM估计77.8%患者1年死亡概率<15%,该低危段却涵盖近三分之二死亡。
核心结论
- 心衰风险模型在群体水平表现尚可,但不能可靠预测哪些个体患者将在未来一年死亡。
研究设计与样本
- 2005至2008年纳入3个整合健康系统的门诊心衰成人患者,用SHFM和MAGGIC风险计算器估计死亡概率,基线协变量来自电子健康记录并插补缺失值。
主要发现
- 10930例患者中位年龄77岁,48.0%为女性;入组后1年内1661例死亡,生命表分析为15.9%。
- 群体水平1年预测死亡率:SHFM为9.7%(C统计量0.66),MAGGIC为17.5%(C统计量0.69)。
- SHFM预测1661例死亡者中8例1年死亡概率>50%(敏感度0.5%),5例存活至少1年者也被预测>50%(阳性预测值61.5%)。
- MAGGIC预测1661例死亡者中52例1年死亡概率>50%(敏感度3.1%),63例存活至少1年者也被预测>50%(阳性预测值45.2%)。
- SHFM估计8496例(77.8%)1年死亡概率<15%,该低危段涵盖997例死亡(近三分之二);MAGGIC估计多数1年内死亡者(914例)死亡概率<25%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: The clinical practice guidelines for heart failure recommend the use of validated risk models to estimate prognosis. Understanding how well models identify individuals who will die in the next year informs decision making for advanced treatments and hospice. OBJECTIVE: To quantify how risk models calculated in routine practice estimate more than 50% 1-year mortality among ambulatory patients with heart failure who die in the subsequent year. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Ambulatory adults with heart failure from 3 integrated health systems were enrolled between 2005 and 2008. The probability of death was estimated using the Seattle Heart Failure Model (SHFM) and the Meta-Analysis Global Group in Chronic Heart Failure (MAGGIC) risk calculator. Baseline covariates were collected from electronic health records. Missing covariates were imputed. Estimated mortality was compared with actual mortality at both population and individual levels. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: One-year mortality. RESULTS: Among 10 930 patients with heart failure, the median age was 77 years, and 48.0% of these patients were female. In the year after study enrollment, 1661 patients died (15.9% by life-table analysis). At the population level, 1-year predicted mortality among the cohort was 9.7% for the SHFM (C statistic of 0.66) and 17.5% for the MAGGIC risk calculator (C statistic of 0.69). At the individual level, the SHFM predicted a more than 50% probability of dying in the next year for 8 of the 1661 patients who died (sensitivity for 1-year death was 0.5%) and for 5 patients who lived at least a year (positive predictive value, 61.5%). The MAGGIC risk calculator predicted a more than 50% probability of dying in the next year for 52 of the 1661 patients who died (sensitivity, 3.1%) and for 63 patients who lived at least a year (positive predictive value, 45.2%). Conversely, the SHFM estimated that 8496 patients (77.8%) had a less than 15% probability of dying at 1 year, yet this lower-risk end of the score range captured nearly two-thirds of deaths (n = 997); similarly, the MAGGIC risk calculator estimated a probability of dying of less than 25% for the majority of patients who died at 1 year (n = 914). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Although heart failure risk models perform reasonably well at the population level, they do not reliably predict which individual patients will die in the next year.
引用
- Allen LA, Matlock DD, Shetterly SM, et al. Use of Risk Models to Predict Death in the Next Year Among Individual Ambulatory Patients With Heart Failure. JAMA Cardiol. 2017. PMID: 28002546. doi:10.1001/jamacardio.2016.5036
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。