人工智能增强心电图在心血管诊断与风险预测中的表型选择性
结果显示,针对结构性或功能性心脏异常的AI-ECG模型与广泛心血管表型相关(OR 2.16-4.41,P<10⁻⁶),且各模型表型关联模式高度相似(相关系数0.67-0.96),提示AI-ECG模型是广泛的心血管风险标志物而非特定疾病分类器。
要点
- AI-ECG模型虽针对特定心脏异常设计,但与多种心血管表型广泛关联。
- 不同AI-ECG模型的表型关联模式高度相似,相关系数0.67-0.96。
- AI-ECG模型应作为广泛心血管生物标志物,而非二元诊断工具。
核心结论
- AI-ECG模型检测并预测广泛心血管疾病的存在与未来发展,倾向相似,挑战其作为二元诊断工具的角色,支持作为更广泛的心血管生物标志物使用。
研究设计与样本
- 部署6个基于图像的AI-ECG模型:5个验证模型分别检测左心室收缩功能障碍、主动脉瓣狭窄、二尖瓣反流、左心室肥厚和结构性心脏病复合模型;1个阴性对照模型检测生物学性别。
- 另开发6个实验模型识别非心血管疾病,使用全表型关联研究框架将诊断代码转化为可解释表型。
- 采用逻辑回归评估AI-ECG概率与横断面表型的关联,Cox回归评估与新发心血管疾病的关联,计算Pearson相关系数比较表型特征。
主要发现
- 5个结构性或功能性心脏异常的AI-ECG模型与心血管表型的关联可能性高于其他表型组(比值比范围2.16至4.41,P<10⁻⁶),而性别模型未显示类似模式。
- 所有AI-ECG模型均与各自目标表型显著关联,但也与广泛其他心血管表型显示相似或更强的关联。
- 针对不同疾病训练的AI-ECG模型表型关联相似,非心血管疾病模型未观察到此现象;模型间表型关联模式相关性高(0.67-0.96)。
- 该模式在所有模型和外部数据集中一致,横断面和前瞻性分析均一致。
临床怎么用
- AI-ECG模型不应仅作为特定心血管疾病的二元诊断工具,而应作为广泛心血管风险生物标志物用于风险分层和早期预警。
- 临床解读AI-ECG结果时需注意其与多种心血管表型的广泛关联,避免过度局限于单一目标疾病。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Artificial intelligence (AI)-enhanced ECG (AI-ECG) models are often designed to detect specific anatomical and functional cardiac abnormalities. Understanding the selectivity of their phenotypic associations is essential to inform their clinical use. Here, we sought to assess whether AI-ECG models function as condition-specific classifiers or broader cardiovascular risk markers. METHODS: We included 4 distinct study populations drawn from both electronic health records and prospective cohort studies. We deployed 6 image-based AI-ECG models: 5 validated models for the detection of left ventricular systolic dysfunction, aortic stenosis, mitral regurgitation, left ventricular hypertrophy, and a composite model for structural heart disease; and 1 negative control AI-ECG model for biological sex. Additionally, we developed 6 experimental models designed to identify noncardiovascular conditions. Diagnosis codes from electronic health records and cohorts were transformed into interpretable phenotypes using a phenome-wide association study framework. We assessed associations of AI-ECG probabilities with cross-sectional phenotypes using logistic regression and with new-onset cardiovascular diseases using Cox regression. Pearson correlation coefficients were calculated to compare phenotypic signatures. RESULTS: The study included one random ECG from 233 689 individuals (mean age 59±18 years, 130 084 [56%] women) across sites. Each of the 5 AI-ECG models for structural and functional cardiac disorders was more likely to be associated with cardiovascular phenotypes compared with other phenotype groups (odds ratios ranging from 2.16 to 4.41, P<10⁻⁶), whereas the sex model did not show a similar pattern. All AI-ECG models were significantly associated with their respective target phenotype but also showed similar or stronger associations with a broad range of other cardiovascular phenotypes. Phenotypic associations were similar across AI-ECG models trained for different conditions, which was not observed in models for noncardiovascular conditions. Correlation of phenotype association patterns between models was high (0.67-0.96). This pattern was consistent across all models and external data sets and in both cross-sectional and prospective analyses. CONCLUSIONS: Despite being developed to detect specific cardiovascular conditions, AI-ECG models detect the presence and predict the future development of a broad range of cardiovascular diseases with similar propensity. This challenges their role as binary diagnostic tools and instead supports their use as broader cardiovascular biomarkers.
引用
- Croon PM, Dhingra LS, Biswas D, et al. Phenotypic Selectivity of Artificial Intelligence-Enhanced Electrocardiography in Cardiovascular Diagnosis and Risk Prediction. Circulation. 2025. PMID: 40888124. doi:10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.125.076279
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。