慢性冠心病初始侵入性与保守策略后心绞痛轨迹分析
该研究为ISCHEMIA试验的二次分析,纳入2,977例基线有心绞痛的慢性冠心病患者,采用序数潜轨迹分析评估2年内心绞痛频率轨迹。两治疗组各识别出6种轨迹模式,侵入性组以快速缓解(27.1%)和早期改善伴持续偶发心绞痛(32.1%)最常见,保守组以轻度心绞痛无改善(42.1%)最常见且快速缓解较少(12.8%)。结论认为保守治疗者中不利心绞痛轨迹比例更高。
要点
- 基线有心绞痛的慢性冠心病患者2年内呈现6种不同心绞痛轨迹。
- 侵入性组快速缓解和早期改善伴偶发心绞痛最常见。
- 保守组轻度心绞痛无改善模式最常见且快速缓解比例较低。
核心结论
- 慢性冠心病伴心绞痛患者症状轨迹多样,从快速缓解到严重或持续心绞痛均有。
- 保守治疗者2年内不利心绞痛轨迹比例高于侵入性治疗者。
研究设计与样本
- ISCHEMIA试验的二次分析,纳入2012年7月至2018年1月慢性冠心病伴中重度缺血患者。
- 共2,977例基线有心绞痛者,1,505例(50.6%)随机至初始侵入性组,1,472例(49.4%)至初始保守组。
- 采用序数潜轨迹分析,分别评估两组2年内心绞痛频率轨迹。
主要发现
- 两组各识别出6种定性相似的轨迹模式:快速缓解、逐渐缓解、早期改善伴持续偶发心绞痛、严重心绞痛改善、轻度心绞痛无改善、严重心绞痛无改善。
- 侵入性组最常见为快速缓解(27.1%)和早期改善伴持续偶发心绞痛(32.1%)。
- 保守组最常见为轻度心绞痛无改善(42.1%),快速缓解占12.8%,早期改善伴持续偶发心绞痛占10.2%。
关键数值与推荐
- 心绞痛频率采用SAQ-AF评分,重分类为每日/每周(0-60分)、每月(61-99分)和无心绞痛(100分)。
- 基线无心绞痛者被排除。
临床怎么用
- 对慢性冠心病伴心绞痛患者,随时间监测健康状态轨迹有助于识别持续症状者并考虑额外治疗。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Clinical trials typically report average health status outcomes by treatment at single points in time, as opposed to participants' trajectories (or journeys) over time. Although ISCHEMIA (International Study of Comparative Health Effectiveness with Medical and Invasive Approaches) demonstrated better mean health status at discrete times with an invasive treatment among those with baseline angina, the patterns of individual participants' angina over time are unknown. OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to identify patterns of individual participants' angina over time after invasive or conservative management strategies for chronic coronary disease. METHODS: In this secondary analysis of the ISCHEMIA trial, which enrolled participants with chronic coronary disease and moderate to severe ischemia from July 2012 to January 2018, we used ordinal latent trajectory analysis to assess angina frequency over a 2-year period, separately for participants assigned to the initial invasive and initial conservative arms. Angina frequency was defined using the SAQ-AF (Seattle Angina Questionnaire Angina Frequency) score, recategorized as daily/weekly (0-60 points), monthly (61-99 points), and no angina (100 points). Participants without baseline angina were excluded. RESULTS: Among 2,977 participants with baseline angina, 1,505 (50.6%) were randomized to initial invasive and 1,472 (49.4%) to initial conservative management; baseline characteristics were well balanced between groups. Six distinct patterns of angina trajectories were identified in each arm and were qualitatively similar: 1) rapid resolution; 2) gradual resolution; 3) early improvement with persistent infrequent angina; 4) severe angina with improvement; 5) modest angina with minimal change; and 6) severe angina without improvement. In the invasive group, the most common patterns included rapid resolution (27.1%) and early improvement with persistent infrequent angina (32.1%), whereas the conservative group more often showed modest angina with minimal change (42.1%) and fewer cases of rapid resolution (12.8%) or early improvement with persistent infrequent angina (10.2%). CONCLUSIONS: Patients with chronic coronary disease and angina experienced diverse symptom trajectories, ranging from rapid resolution to severe or persistent angina. A greater proportion of conservatively managed patients experienced unfavorable angina patterns over 2 years compared with those treated invasively. When health status is monitored over time, such patterns may help identify patients with persistent symptoms who could benefit from additional therapy. (International Study of Comparative Health Effectiveness With Medical and Invasive Approaches [ISCHEMIA]; NCT01471522).
引用
- Ikemura N, Jones PG, Fu Z, et al. Trajectories of Angina After Initial Invasive vs Conservative Strategy for Chronic Coronary Disease. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2025. PMID: 40930615. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2025.06.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。