文献速递瓣膜病与结构性心脏病

主动脉瓣置换的碳排放分析:经导管与外科手术的环境足迹

Carbon emission analysis of aortic valve replacement: the environmental footprint of transcatheter vs. surgical procedures.
PubMed 文献 · Eur Heart J · 2025-01-01

本研究对2023年3月至9月接受外科主动脉瓣置换(SAVR)和经导管主动脉瓣置换(TAVR,分手术室与导管室两组)的患者进行生命周期评估,按ISO14067标准计算碳排放。结果显示SAVR总碳排放约620-750 kg CO2e,约为TAVR(280-360 kg CO2e)的两倍,术后ICU和病房护理是最大贡献部分。

要点

  • SAVR总碳排放约620-750 kg CO2e,显著高于TAVR的280-360 kg CO2e。
  • 术后ICU和病房护理占SAVR碳排放59%,占TAVR约52-55%。
  • SAVR术中碳排放约241 kg CO2e,高于TAVR的约100-103 kg CO2e。

核心结论

  • SAVR的碳排放约为手术室TAVR或导管室TAVR的两倍。
  • 这些发现可能在未来制定人群层面决策和指南时予以考虑。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入2023年3月至9月接受SAVR(n=10)、手术室TAVR(n=10)和导管室TAVR(n=10)的患者,排除同期接受其他手术者。
  • 依据ISO14067标准,基于术前、术中、术后材料、操作和能源等原始数据构建碳排放模型,以kg CO2e计量。
  • 报告的总碳排放变异系数为10%,单个生命周期阶段变异系数最高25%。

主要发现

  • 手术室TAVR、导管室TAVR和SAVR的中位年龄分别为77岁(范围65-91)、82岁(范围71-96)和66岁(范围51-79)。
  • 中位STS风险分别为4.9%、2.8%和1.4%,各组射血分数相似。
  • 手术室TAVR、导管室TAVR和SAVR的总生命周期碳排放分别为280-340 kg CO2e、290-360 kg CO2e和620-750 kg CO2e(SAVR vs 任一种TAVR,P < .05)。
  • 术后ICU和病房护理碳排放:手术室TAVR约170 kg CO2e(占总55%)、导管室TAVR约170 kg CO2e(占52%)、SAVR约405 kg CO2e(占59%)(SAVR vs 任一种TAVR,P < .05)。
  • ICU住院时长占总碳排放比例:手术室TAVR约27%、导管室TAVR约25%、SAVR约43%;术中碳排放约分别为100、103和241 kg CO2e。

临床怎么用

  • 在人口层面决策和未来指南制定中,可考虑将SAVR与TAVR的碳排放差异纳入评估。
  • 优化术后ICU和病房护理路径可能有助于降低主动脉瓣置换的整体碳排放。

局限性

  • 总碳排放变异系数为10%,单个生命周期阶段变异系数最高25%。
  • 样本量较小(每组n=10)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The impact of climate change is increasingly recognized as a major public health determinant. A life cycle assessment to determine the carbon emissions associated with open surgical aortic valve replacement (SAVR) and transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) in the operating room (OR), and the cath lab (CATH) was performed. METHODS: Total carbon footprint from SAVR (n = 10) and TAVR (n = 10 OR-TAVR, n = 10 CATH-TAVR) from March to September 2023 was calculated. Patients undergoing any other procedure at the time of SAVR or TAVR were excluded. A model for carbon footprints, measured in kilograms of CO2 equivalents (kg CO2e) was created following ISO14067 standards, based on primary data (materials, procedures, energies, in the pre-operative, operative, and post-operative setting). Reported footprints carry a coefficient of variation of 10% for totals and up to 25% for individual life cycle stages, as standard in carbon footprinting analysis. RESULTS: Median age for OR-TAVR, CATH-TAVR, and SAVR was 77 (range 65-91), 82 (7196), and 66 (51-79) years, respectively. Median Society of Thoracic Surgeons risk for same was 4.9, 2.8, and 1.4%, respectively. Ejection fraction was similar across groups. Total life cycle carbon footprint for OR-TAVR, CATH-TAVR, and SAVR was 280-340 kg CO2e, 290-360 kg CO2e, and 620-750 kg CO2e, respectively (P < .05 SAVR vs either TAVR). Post-operative intensive care unit and floor care accounted for the largest portion of the carbon footprint, including ∼170 kg CO2e for OR-TAVR (55% of total), 170 kg CO2e for CATH-TAVR (52% of total), and 405 kg CO2e for SAVR (59% of total) (P < .05 SAVR vs either TAVR). Of the total, intensive care unit length of stay was a large contributor to the carbon footprint, comprising ∼27% of OR-TAVR, 25% of CATH-TAVR, and 43% of the SAVR footprint. Approximate intraoperative carbon footprint was 100 kg CO2e for OR-TAVR, 103 kg CO2e for CATH-TAVR, and 241 kg CO2e for SAVR. The intraoperative footprint of SAVR was driven by biological waste, post-operative length of stay, and inhaled anaesthetic gases. CONCLUSIONS: The carbon footprint of SAVR is about twice as high as those from OR-TAVR or CATH-TAVR. These findings should potentially be considered when making population level decisions and guidelines moving into the future.

来源:Eur Heart J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Blitzer D, Meinrenken CJ, Apelgren NB, et al. Carbon emission analysis of aortic valve replacement: the environmental footprint of transcatheter vs. surgical procedures. Eur Heart J. 2025. PMID: 40599126. doi:10.1093/eurheartj/ehaf379

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。