风湿性心脏病超声筛查的形态-机制学新标准
本研究在低风险儿童队列(n=364)和复合参考标准确诊风湿性心脏病(RHD)阳性队列(n=65)中,比较了世界心脏联合会(WHF)标准与新型形态-机制学(MM)筛查标准及简化排除试验的性能。MM标准在低风险队列中特异性为99.7%,显著高于WHF的95.9%(p=0.0002);在阳性队列中敏感性为92.4%,与WHF的89.2%无显著差异(p=0.2231)。MM排除试验在低风险队列中排除了98.6%的病例,且未排除任何阳性队列病例。
要点
- MM标准特异性显著优于WHF标准,减少正常病例误判。
- MM标准敏感性不劣于WHF标准。
- 简化排除试验有望用于两步法筛查。
核心结论
- MM筛查标准与WHF标准敏感性相当,但特异性显著提高。
- MM排除试验能有效排除阴性病例且不遗漏阳性病例。
研究设计与样本
- 研究评估WHF标准、MM标准和简化MM排除试验,在低风险RHD儿童队列(n=364)和复合参考标准RHD阳性队列(n=65)中进行比较。
主要发现
- 低风险队列中,MM和WHF标准筛查特异性分别为99.7%和95.9%(p=0.0002)。
- 阳性队列中,MM和WHF标准筛查敏感性分别为92.4%和89.2%(p=0.2231)。
- MM排除试验在低风险队列中排除359/364例(98.6%),在阳性队列中未排除任何病例。
关键数值与推荐
- MM标准评估瓣叶形态、运动及反流机制。
- 简化MM排除试验基于二尖瓣前叶受限的预定征象和任何主动脉瓣反流。
临床怎么用
- MM标准可用于提高RHD筛查特异性,减少过度诊断。
- 简化排除试验可作为两步法筛查的第一步,便于任务转移。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Screening echocardiography, guided by the current World Heart Federation (WHF) criteria, has important limitations that impede the establishment of large-scale rheumatic heart disease (RHD) control programmes in endemic regions. The criteria misclassify a significant number of normal cases as borderline RHD. Prior attempts to simplify them are limited by incorporation bias due to the lack of an externally validated, accurate diagnostic test for RHD. We set out to assess novel screening criteria designed to avoid incorporation bias and to compare this against the performance of the current WHF criteria. METHODS: The performance of the WHF and the morpho-mechanistic (MM) RHD screening criteria (a novel set of screening criteria that evaluate leaflet morphology, motion and mechanism of regurgitation) as well as a simplified RHD MM 'rule-out' test (based on identifying a predefined sign of anterior mitral valve leaflet restriction for the mitral valve and any aortic regurgitation for the aortic valve) were assessed in two contrasting cohorts: first, a low-risk RHD cohort consisting of children with a very low-risk RHD profile. and second, a composite reference standard (CRS) RHD-positive cohort that was created using a composite of two criteria to ensure a cohort with the highest possible likelihood of RHD. Subjects included in this group required (1) proven, prior acute rheumatic fever and (2) current evidence of predefined valvular regurgitation on echocardiography. RESULTS: In the low-risk RHD cohort (n=364), the screening specificities for detecting RHD of the MM and WHF criteria were 99.7% and 95.9%, respectively (p=0.0002). The MM rule-out test excluded 359/364 cases (98.6%). In the CRS RHD-positive cohort (n=65), the screening sensitivities for the detection of definite RHD by MM and WHF criteria were 92.4% and 89.2%, respectively (p=0.2231). The MM RHD rule-out test did not exclude any cases from the CRS RHD-positive cohort. CONCLUSION: Our proposed MM approach showed an equal sensitivity to the WHF criteria but with significantly improved specificity. The MM RHD rule-out test excluded RHD-negative cases while identifying all cases within the CRS RHD-positive cohort. This holds promise for the development of a two-step RHD screening algorithm to enable task shifting in RHD endemic regions.
引用
- Hunter LD, Doubell AF, Pecoraro AJK, et al. Morpho-mechanistic screening criteria for the echocardiographic detection of rheumatic heart disease. Heart. 2023. PMID: 37117004. doi:10.1136/heartjnl-2022-322192
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。