文献速递冠心病血脂与心血管预防

PCI术后冠心病患者静息心率法与无氧阈法靶心率一致性评价

[Consistency evaluation of target heart rate determined by anaerobic threshold and by resting heart rate in patients with coronary artery disease after percutaneous coronary intervention].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Xin Xue Guan Bing Za Zhi · 2022-01-01

该诊断性试验纳入439例初次行PCI的冠心病患者,比较静息心率+20次/min的简易靶心率与CPET无氧阈法靶心率的一致性。两种方法靶心率差异无统计学意义(P=0.091),ICC为0.529(95%CI 0.458~0.593),Bland-Altman比值1.03±0.11,LOA 0.812~1.245,提示一致性较好但不能替代无氧阈法。

要点

  • 静息心率+20次/min与无氧阈法靶心率差异无统计学意义,ICC为0.529。
  • 静息心率+30次/min显著高于无氧阈法靶心率(P<0.001)。
  • 简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率一致性较好,但不能替代后者。

核心结论

  • PCI术后冠心病患者静息心率+20次/min的简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率一致性较好,但不能替代无氧阈法。

研究设计与样本

  • 诊断性试验,纳入2011年10月至2021年4月北京大学人民医院心内科初次行PCI的冠心病患者439例,年龄(56.2±8.8)岁,男性382例(87.0%)。

主要发现

  • 无氧阈靶心率为(90.0±11.8)次/min,简易靶心率(静息心率+20次/min)为(91.0±8.4)次/min,差异无统计学意义(P=0.091)。
  • 简易靶心率(静息心率+30次/min)为(101.0±8.4)次/min,显著高于无氧阈靶心率(P<0.001)。
  • 无氧阈靶心率与简易靶心率ICC为0.529(95%CI 0.458~0.593,P<0.001),Bland-Altman比值1.03±0.11,LOA 0.812~1.245。
  • 年龄<60岁组(n=247)ICC为0.492,≥60岁组(n=192)ICC为0.566;男性(n=382)ICC为0.540,女性(n=57)ICC为0.445。
  • 心肌梗死组(n=186)ICC为0.568,心绞痛组(n=253)ICC为0.495;使用β受体阻滞剂组(n=353)ICC为0.520,未使用组(n=86)ICC为0.570。

临床怎么用

  • 在无法进行CPET时,可用静息心率+20次/min估算PCI术后冠心病患者的运动靶心率,但需知晓其不能替代无氧阈法。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To evaluate the consistency on the determination of target heart rate by simple calculation method based on resting heart rate and by anaerobic threshold method in cardiopulmonary exercise test (CPET) for patients with coronary artery disease after percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI). Methods: This study was a diagnostic test. Patients with coronary artery disease who underwent the first PCI in the Department of Cardiology of Peking University People's Hospital from October 2011 to April 2021 were enrolled. Patients were further divided into subgroups according to gender, age (<60 years group and ≥60 years group), with or without myocardial infarction history (myocardial infarction group and angina pectoris group) and whether β blockers were applied. The general clinical data of patients, resting heart rate (RHR) and anaerobic threshold heart rate in CPET were collected through the electronic medical record system. The simple target rate (RHR plus 20 or 30 bpm) and the target rate calculated by anaerobic threshold (anaerobic threshold heart rate minus 10 bpm) were both calculated in each patient. Consistency test of target heart rate derived by above the two methods was shown by intra-class correlation (ICC) and Bland-Altman plots. Results: A total of 439 patients were included, age was (56.2±8.8) years, body mass index was (25.77±2.34) kg/m2, there were 382 males (87.0%). The target heart rate determined by anaerobic threshold method was (90.0±11.8)bpm, and the simple target heart rate determined by RHR plus 20 bpm was (91.0±8.4)bpm. There was no significant difference on the target heart rate derived from the two calculation methods (P=0.091). The simple target heart rate determined by RHR plus 30 bpm was (101.0±8.4)bpm, which was significant higher than that determined by anaerobic threshold method (P<0.001). In the following analysis, RHR plus 20 bpm was defined as the simple target heart rate. The ICC value of target heart rate determined by anaerobic threshold and resting rate plus 20 bpm was 0.529(95%CI 0.458-0.593, P<0.001). Bland-Altman plots analysis showed that the ratio of the simple target heart rate and the target heart rate determined by anaerobic threshold method was 1.03±0.11 and the 95% limits of agreement (LOA) were 0.812-1.245. In the subgroup of patients aged<60 years (n=247), the ICC value was 0.492, the ratio by Bland-Altman plots analysis was 1.02±0.11 and LOA was 0.814-1.234; in the subgroup of patients aged ≥60 years (n=192), the ICC value was 0.566, the ratio by Bland-Altman plots analysis was 1.03±0.11 and LOA was 0.810-1.260. In male subgroup(n=382), the ICC value was 0.540, the ratio by Bland-Altman plots analysis was 1.03±0.11 and LOA was 0.813-1.246; in female subgroup(n=57), the ICC value was 0.445, the ratio by Bland-Altman plots analysis was 1.03±0.11 and LOA was 0.810-1.240.In myocardial infarction subgroup (n=186), the ICC value was 0.568, the ratio by Bland-Altman plots analysis was 1.02±0.11 and LOA was 0.810-1.227; in angina pectoris subgroup (n=253), the ICC value was 0.495, the ratio by Bland-Altman plots analysis was 1.04±0.11 and LOA was 0.813-1.260. In the subgroup of patients with β blockers (n=353), the ICC value was 0.520, the ratio by Bland-Altman plots analysis was 1.03±0.11 and LOA was 0.810-1.252; in the subgroup of patients without β blockers (n=86), the ICC value was 0.570, the ratio by Bland-Altman plots analysis was 1.02±0.10 and LOA was 0.821-1.219. Conclusions: The simple target heart rate determined by RHR plus 20 bpm is consistent with the target heart rate determined by anaerobic threshold in patients with coronary artery disease after PCI. But the simple target heart rate determined by RHR plus 20 bpm can't replace the target heart rate determined by anaerobic threshold in this patient cohort. 目的: 评价对于接受经皮冠状动脉介入治疗(PCI)的冠心病患者,简易计算法所得的靶心率与通过心肺运动试验(CPET)所得的无氧阈靶心率的一致性。 方法: 该研究为诊断性试验。纳入2011年10月至2021年4月北京大学人民医院心内科收治的初次行PCI的冠心病患者,并进一步根据性别、年龄(<60岁组和≥60岁组)、是否曾发生心肌梗死(心肌梗死组和心绞痛组)及是否应用β受体阻滞剂分组,进行亚组分析。通过电子病历系统收集患者的一般临床资料及CPET测得的静息心率和无氧阈心率。分别通过简易计算法(静息心率+20或30次/min)和无氧阈法(无氧阈心率-10次/min)计算运动靶心率,采用配对t检验对二者进行差异性检验,通过计算组内相关系数(ICC)和Bland-Altman 法检验二者的一致性。 结果: 共纳入患者439例,年龄(56.2±8.8)岁,体重指数(25.77±2.34)kg/m2,男性382例(87.0%)。入选患者测得的无氧阈靶心率为(90.0±11.8)次/min,简易靶心率(静息心率+20次/min)为(91.0±8.4)次/min,二者差异无统计学意义(P=0.091),简易靶心率(静息心率+30次/min)为(101.0±8.4)次/min,与无氧阈靶心率比较差异有统计学意义(P<0.001)。后续研究中将“静息心率+20次/min”视为简易靶心率。无氧阈靶心率与简易靶心率一致性检验的ICC值为0.529,95%CI 0.458~0.593,P<0.001。Bland-Altman法评价结果示,简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率的比值为1.03±0.11,95%一致性界限(LOA)为0.812~1.245。年龄<60岁组患者(n=247)简易靶心率与无氧阈法靶心率一致性检验的ICC值为0.492,Bland-Altman 法评价的结果示简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率的比值为1.02±0.11,LOA为0.814~1.234;年龄≥60岁组患者(n=192)简易靶心率与无氧阈法靶心率一致性检验的 ICC值为0.566,Bland-Altman 法评价结果示简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率的比值为1.03±0.11, LOA为0.810~1.260。男性患者(n=382)简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率一致性检验的ICC值为0.540,Bland-Altman 法评价结果示简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率的比值为1.03±0.11,LOA为0.813~1.246;女性患者(n=57)简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率一致性检验的ICC值为0.445,Bland-Altman 法评价结果示简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率的比值为1.03±0.11,LOA为0.810~1.240。心肌梗死组患者(n=186)简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率一致性检验的ICC值为0.568,Bland-Altman法评价结果示简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率的比值为1.02±0.11,LOA为0.810~1.227;心绞痛组患者(n=253)简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率一致性检验的ICC值为0.495,Bland-Altman 法评价结果示简易靶心率与无氧阈法靶心率的比值为1.04±0.11,LOA为0.813~1.260。使用β受体阻滞剂组患者(n=353)简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率一致性检验的ICC值为0.520,Bland-Altman法评价结果示简易靶心率与无氧阈法靶心率的比值为1.03±0.11,LOA为0.810~1.252;未使用β受体阻滞剂组患者(n=86)简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率一致性检验的ICC值为0.570,Bland-Altman 法评价结果示简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率的比值为1.02±0.10,LOA为0.821~1.219。 结论: 对于PCI术后的冠心病患者,通过“静息心率+20次/min”所得的简易靶心率与无氧阈靶心率一致性较好,但不能替代后者。.

来源:Zhonghua Xin Xue Guan Bing Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Niu SP, Guo L, Guo DJ, et al. [Consistency evaluation of target heart rate determined by anaerobic threshold and by resting heart rate in patients with coronary artery disease after percutaneous coronary intervention]. Zhonghua Xin Xue Guan Bing Za Zhi. 2022. PMID: 35589597. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112148-20210529-00460

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。