基于心电图的深度学习与临床危险因素预测新发房颤
研究在麻省总医院初级保健人群中训练卷积神经网络(ECG-AI),用12导联心电图推断5年新发房颤(AF)风险,并与CHARGE-AF临床评分及二者联合模型比较。结果显示ECG-AI与CHARGE-AF预测效能相当且互补,联合模型CH-AI的AUC最高,校准误差低,显著性分析提示P波影响最大。
要点
- ECG-AI预测新发AF的效能与CHARGE-AF临床评分相当,二者具有互补性
- 联合ECG-AI与CHARGE-AF的CH-AI模型在内部及两个外部测试集中AUC均最高
- 显著性分析显示P波对AI模型预测影响最大
核心结论
- 基于12导联心电图的AI分析与临床危险因素模型对新发AF的预测效能相似,两种方法互补,ECG-AI可高效量化未来AF风险。
研究设计与样本
- 研究在麻省总医院接受纵向初级保健的患者中训练卷积神经网络(ECG-AI),用12导联心电图推断5年新发AF风险。
- 分别拟合ECG-AI 5年AF概率、CHARGE-AF临床风险评分及二者联合(CH-AI)三个Cox比例风险模型。
- 在内部测试集及两个外部测试集(Brigham and Women's Hospital与UK Biobank)中评估区分度(AUC)与校准,UK Biobank因随访有限重新校准以估计2年AF风险。
主要发现
- AUC在CHARGE-AF为MGH 0.802(95%CI 0.767-0.836)、BWH 0.752(95%CI 0.741-0.763)、UK Biobank 0.732(95%CI 0.704-0.759)。
- AUC在ECG-AI为MGH 0.823(95%CI 0.790-0.856)、BWH 0.747(95%CI 0.736-0.759)、UK Biobank 0.705(95%CI 0.673-0.737)。
- AUC在CH-AI最高,为MGH 0.838(95%CI 0.807-0.869)、BWH 0.777(95%CI 0.766-0.788)、UK Biobank 0.746(95%CI 0.716-0.776)。
- 校准误差在ECG-AI为MGH 0.0212、BWH 0.0129、UK Biobank 0.0035;CH-AI为MGH 0.012、BWH 0.0108、UK Biobank 0.0001。
- 显著性分析中ECG的P波对AI模型预测影响最大;ECG-AI与CHARGE-AF线性预测值相关(Pearson r:MGH 0.61、BWH 0.66、UK Biobank 0.41)。
临床怎么用
- 可将ECG-AI作为临床危险因素模型之外的工具,用于量化新发AF的长期风险。
- 将ECG-AI概率与CHARGE-AF评分联合(CH-AI)可获更高区分度,支持二者互补使用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Artificial intelligence (AI)-enabled analysis of 12-lead ECGs may facilitate efficient estimation of incident atrial fibrillation (AF) risk. However, it remains unclear whether AI provides meaningful and generalizable improvement in predictive accuracy beyond clinical risk factors for AF. METHODS: We trained a convolutional neural network (ECG-AI) to infer 5-year incident AF risk using 12-lead ECGs in patients receiving longitudinal primary care at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH). We then fit 3 Cox proportional hazards models, composed of ECG-AI 5-year AF probability, CHARGE-AF clinical risk score (Cohorts for Heart and Aging in Genomic Epidemiology-Atrial Fibrillation), and terms for both ECG-AI and CHARGE-AF (CH-AI), respectively. We assessed model performance by calculating discrimination (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve) and calibration in an internal test set and 2 external test sets (Brigham and Women's Hospital [BWH] and UK Biobank). Models were recalibrated to estimate 2-year AF risk in the UK Biobank given limited available follow-up. We used saliency mapping to identify ECG features most influential on ECG-AI risk predictions and assessed correlation between ECG-AI and CHARGE-AF linear predictors. RESULTS: The training set comprised 45 770 individuals (age 55±17 years, 53% women, 2171 AF events) and the test sets comprised 83 162 individuals (age 59±13 years, 56% women, 2424 AF events). Area under the receiver operating characteristic curve was comparable using CHARGE-AF (MGH, 0.802 [95% CI, 0.767-0.836]; BWH, 0.752 [95% CI, 0.741-0.763]; UK Biobank, 0.732 [95% CI, 0.704-0.759]) and ECG-AI (MGH, 0.823 [95% CI, 0.790-0.856]; BWH, 0.747 [95% CI, 0.736-0.759]; UK Biobank, 0.705 [95% CI, 0.673-0.737]). Area under the receiver operating characteristic curve was highest using CH-AI (MGH, 0.838 [95% CI, 0.807 to 0.869]; BWH, 0.777 [95% CI, 0.766 to 0.788]; UK Biobank, 0.746 [95% CI, 0.716 to 0.776]). Calibration error was low using ECG-AI (MGH, 0.0212; BWH, 0.0129; UK Biobank, 0.0035) and CH-AI (MGH, 0.012; BWH, 0.0108; UK Biobank, 0.0001). In saliency analyses, the ECG P-wave had the greatest influence on AI model predictions. ECG-AI and CHARGE-AF linear predictors were correlated (Pearson r: MGH, 0.61; BWH, 0.66; UK Biobank, 0.41). CONCLUSIONS: AI-based analysis of 12-lead ECGs has similar predictive usefulness to a clinical risk factor model for incident AF and the approaches are complementary. ECG-AI may enable efficient quantification of future AF risk.
引用
- Khurshid S, Friedman S, Reeder C, et al. ECG-Based Deep Learning and Clinical Risk Factors to Predict Atrial Fibrillation. Circulation. 2021. PMID: 34743566. doi:10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.121.057480
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。