卒中后急性期后出院去向决策的关键因素:一项德尔菲研究
本研究采用四轮德尔菲法,由32名多学科专家组成的专家组对影响卒中患者急性期后护理级别选择的因素进行共识评定。首轮提出207个因素,经整合后对15个因素进行排序,最终9个因素获得共识评分,其中「可能从积极康复项目中获益」获得97%专家评为4分及以上,被视为最重要因素。研究提供了一套基于专家共识的关键因素,可用于开发临床决策支持工具。
要点
- 可能从积极康复中获益是选择急性期后护理级别的首要因素(97%专家评4分及以上)。
- 对专业康复技能临床医生的需求(94%)和持续医疗管理监测需求(84%)也获高度共识。
- 前病痴呆仅16%专家评为重要,家庭/照护者支持为39%,重要性相对较低。
核心结论
- 研究通过专家共识确定了影响卒中患者急性期后护理级别选择的关键因素,其中康复获益可能性、专业康复技能需求和医疗管理监测需求最为重要。
研究设计与样本
- 采用协作性四轮德尔菲法,专家组由32名成员组成,包括医生、物理治疗师、作业治疗师、言语语言病理学家、护士、卒中幸存者、管理者、政策专家及第三方保险公司相关人员。
主要发现
- 首轮提出207个因素,经讨论整合为15个因素;第二轮对15个因素排序,就10个因素达成共识;第三轮对10个因素排序,就9个因素达成共识;第四轮对9个因素进行Likert评分(5=最重要,1=不重要)。
- 专家评为4分及以上的百分比为:可能从积极康复项目中获益97%,需要具有专业康复技能的临床医生94%,需要积极持续的医疗管理和监测84%,能够耐受积极康复项目74%,需要照护者培训以回归社区48%,家庭/照护者支持39%,可能回归社区/家庭39%,能够回归物理家庭环境32%,前病痴呆16%。
关键数值与推荐
- 可能从积极康复项目中获益:97%专家评为4分及以上。
- 需要具有专业康复技能的临床医生:94%专家评为4分及以上。
- 需要积极持续的医疗管理和监测:84%专家评为4分及以上。
- 能够耐受积极康复项目:74%专家评为4分及以上。
- 需要照护者培训以回归社区:48%专家评为4分及以上。
临床怎么用
- 这些共识因素可用于开发临床决策支持工具,辅助临床医生在卒中患者急性期后出院去向决策中系统评估关键因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The criteria for determining the level of postacute care for patients with stroke are variable and inconsistent. The purpose of this study was to identify key factors influencing the selection of postacute level of care for these patients. METHODS: We used a collaborative 4-round Delphi process to achieve a refined list of factors influencing postacute level of care selection. Our Delphi panel of experts consisted of 32 panelists including physicians, physical therapists, occupational therapists, speech-language pathologists, nurses, stroke survivors, administrators, policy experts, and individuals associated with third-party insurance companies. RESULTS: In round 1, 207 factors were proposed, with subsequent discussion resulting in consolidation into 15 factors for consideration. In round 2, 15 factors were ranked with consensus on 10 factors; in round 3,10 factors were ranked with consensus on 9 factors. In round 4, the final round, 9 factors were rated with Likert scores ranging from 5 (most important) to 1(not important). The percentage of panelists who provided a rating of 4 or above were as follows: likelihood to benefit from an active rehabilitation program (97%), need for clinicians with specialized rehabilitation skills (94%), need for active and ongoing medical management and monitoring (84%), ability to tolerate an active rehabilitation program (74%), need for caregiver training to return to the community (48%), family/caregiver support (39%), likelihood to return to community/home (39%), ability to return to physical home environment (32%), and premorbid dementia (16%). CONCLUSIONS: This study provides an expert, consensus-based set of key factors to be considered when determining where stroke patients are discharged for postacute care. These factors may be useful in developing a decision support tool for use in clinical settings.
引用
- Stein J, Rodstein BM, Levine SR, et al. Which Road to Recovery?: Factors Influencing Postacute Stroke Discharge Destinations: A Delphi Study. Stroke. 2021. PMID: 34706561. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.121.034815
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。