痴呆研究中人群、种族与地域多样性的系统综述
该研究系统检索2018年9月至2019年8月神经病学、老年医学、精神病学及综合医学前100种期刊中的痴呆研究,评估研究结果的可推广性。302项研究显示,诊断平均年龄为74.1岁,诊所来源患者较人群来源患者年轻8.8岁,研究主要来自北美和欧洲且以白人为主。
要点
- 诊所来源痴呆患者诊断年龄比人群来源者年轻约8.8岁
- 影像和脑脊液标志物主要用于诊所来源的较年轻患者
- 研究地域和种族多样性不足,结果可推广性受限
核心结论
- 当代痴呆研究在种族和地域多样性方面有限,主要基于诊所来源的较年轻患者,需在未选择队列中提高包容性和深度表型分析以改善可推广性。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed中2018年9月1日至2019年8月31日神经病学、神经科学、老年医学、精神病学和综合医学前100种期刊的痴呆研究。
- 共识别513项研究,排除211项样本少于50例痴呆患者的研究,最终纳入302项研究。
- 由两名评价者提取研究特征,包括研究场所、参与者数量、诊断年龄和生物标志物使用。
主要发现
- 302项研究纳入痴呆患者的中位数(四分位距)为214例(98-628),诊断平均(标准差)年龄为74.1岁(8.0)。
- 180项诊所来源研究的诊断平均(标准差)年龄为71.8(6.4)岁,79项人群来源研究为80.6(4.7)岁,平均差8.8岁(95%CI,7.3-10.2)。
- 磁共振成像、正电子发射断层成像和脑脊液检查多在诊所来源研究中进行(80%至96%),患者平均(标准差)年龄为71.6(5.1)岁。
- 人群来源研究较诊所来源研究更常采用纵向设计(82% vs 40%)。
- 89%的研究来自北美和欧洲;在74项(22%)报告种族的研究中,白人参与者中位数(四分位距)为89%(78-97)。
临床怎么用
- 解读痴呆研究证据时需考虑研究场所和人群来源对诊断年龄及可推广性的影响。
- 对老年、非白人及社区来源痴呆患者应用研究结论时应谨慎,关注证据代表性不足问题。
局限性
- 仅检索前100种期刊且限定一年时间窗,可能遗漏其他期刊和时段的研究。
- 仅22%的研究报告种族信息,种族多样性评估数据有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: For informed decision making on diagnosis and treatment of dementia, physicians and their patients rely on the generalizability of evidence from published studies to clinical practice. However, it is uncertain whether everyday care of elderly patients with dementia is sufficiently captured in contemporary research. OBJECTIVE: To systematically review contemporary dementia research in terms of study and patient characteristics in order to assess generalizability of research findings. EVIDENCE REVIEW: PubMed was searched for dementia studies published in the top 100 journals in the fields of neurology and neuroscience, geriatrics, psychiatry, and general medicine between September 1, 2018, and August 31, 2019. Two reviewers extracted study characteristics, including setting, number of participants, age at diagnosis, and use of biomarkers. FINDINGS: Among 513 identified studies, 211 (41%) included fewer than 50 individuals with dementia and were excluded. The remaining 302 studies included a median (interquartile range) of 214 patients (98-628) with a mean (SD) age at diagnosis of 74.1 years (8.0). Age at diagnosis differed with study setting. Patients in the 180 clinic-based studies had a mean (SD) age of 71.8 (6.4) years at time of diagnosis compared with 80.6 (4.7) years among patients in the 79 population-based studies (mean difference, 8.8 years; 95% CI, 7.3-10.2). Use of magnetic resonance imaging, positron emission tomography imaging, and cerebrospinal fluid imaging was mostly done in clinic-based studies (80% to 96%) and consequently in relatively young patients (mean [SD] age, 71.6 [5.1] years). A longitudinal design was more common in population-based studies than in clinic-based studies (82 % vs 40%). Most studies originated from North America and Europe (89%), including almost exclusively White participants (among 74 studies [22%] reporting on ethnicity: median [interquartile range], 89% [78-97]). The 3 most studied cohorts represented 21% of all included study populations. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Contemporary dementia research is limited in terms of racial and geographic diversity and draws largely from clinic-based populations with relatively young patients. Greater inclusivity and deeper phenotyping in unselected cohorts could improve generalizability as well as diagnosis and development of effective treatments for all patients with dementia.
引用
- Mooldijk SS, Licher S, Wolters FJ, et al. Characterizing Demographic, Racial, and Geographic Diversity in Dementia Research: A Systematic Review. JAMA Neurol. 2021. PMID: 34491284. doi:10.1001/jamaneurol.2021.2943
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。