文献速递脑血管病

卒中取栓无效性取决于再灌注而非通过次数:匹配病例对照研究

Lack of Reperfusion Rather Than Number of Passes Defines Futility in Stroke Thrombectomy: A Matched Case-Control Study.
PubMed 文献 · Stroke · 2021-06-15

结果显示,即使多次通过,成功再灌注仍与90天改良Rankin量表分布改善和功能独立率提高相关,且未增加实质血肿2型或90天死亡率。提示不应以任意通过次数阈值预测再通无效而早期终止手术。

要点

  • 4-5次通过后成功再灌注者90天功能独立率31%,显著高于匹配失败组的8.9%。
  • ≥6次通过后成功再灌注者功能独立率36.8%,仍高于匹配失败组的11.1%。
  • 再灌注组与失败组的实质血肿2型和90天死亡率无显著差异。

核心结论

  • 多次通过后实现再灌注仍可改善结局,不应以任意通过次数阈值判定无效而早期终止取栓。

主要发现

  • 与匹配的再灌注失败组(n=62)相比,4-5次通过后再灌注组(n=62)90天mRS分布有有利偏移(调整OR 3.992,95%CI 1.807–8.512,P=0.001),功能独立率更高(31% vs 8.9%,P=0.004,调整OR 9.860,95%CI 2.323–41.845,P=0.002)。
  • 与匹配的再灌注失败组(n=42)相比,≥6次通过后再灌注组(n=42)90天mRS分布有有利偏移(调整OR 2.640,95%CI 1.073–6.686,P=0.037),功能独立率更高(36.8% vs 11.1%,P=0.004,调整OR 5.392,95%CI 1.185–24.530,P=0.029)。
  • 再灌注组与未再灌注组的实质血肿2型发生率和90天死亡率相当。

关键数值与推荐

  • 再灌注成功定义为mTICI 2b-3,失败定义为mTICI 0-2a。
  • 4-5次通过后再灌注组与失败组比较:功能独立率31% vs 8.9%(P=0.004),调整OR 9.860(95%CI 2.323–41.845)。
  • ≥6次通过后再灌注组与失败组比较:功能独立率36.8% vs 11.1%(P=0.004),调整OR 5.392(95%CI 1.185–24.530)。

临床怎么用

  • 对于颅内颈内动脉或大脑中动脉M1/M2闭塞患者,即使取栓通过次数达到4次以上,仍应积极尝试实现再灌注,不应仅因通过次数多而提前终止手术。

局限性

  • 本研究为回顾性数据库分析,样本量有限,且未报告通过次数阈值的随机对照验证,结论需谨慎推广。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: There is a robust relationship between the duration of ischemia and functional outcomes after mechanical thrombectomy. Higher number of mechanical thrombectomy passes strongly correlate with lower chances of favorable outcomes. Indeed, previous studies have suggested that after multiple passes the procedure may be futile. However, using uncontrolled thresholds to define thrombectomy futility might be misleading. We aim to compare the outcome of successful reperfusion after 4 to 5 passes and ≥6 passes with those of failed reperfusion. METHODS: A prospectively acquired mechanical thrombectomy database from January 2012 to October 2019 was reviewed. Patients were included if they had intracranial internal carotid artery or middle cerebral artery-M1/M2 occlusions and either achieved successful reperfusion after ≥4 passes or failed reperfusion. Reperfused patients (mTICI2b-3) were divided into 2 subgroups; (1) 4 to 5 passes and (2) ≥6 passes. Each subgroup was compared with a matched group of mechanical thrombectomy failure (mTICI0-2a). The primary outcome was the shift in the degree of disability at 90-day as measured by the modified Rankin Scale. RESULTS: A total of 273 patients were included. As compared with matched failed reperfusion patients (n=62), those reperfused after 4 to 5 passes (n=62) had a favorable shift in the overall modified Rankin Scale score distribution (adjusted odds ratio, 3.992 [95% CI, 1.807–8.512], P=0.001] and higher rates of functional independence (31% versus 8.9%, P=0.004, adjusted odds ratio; 9.860 [95% CI, 2.323–41.845], P=0.002) at 90 days. Similarly, when compared with a matched group of failed reperfusion (n=42), patients reperfused after ≥6 passes (n=42) demonstrated a favorable shift in the overall modified Rankin Scale score distribution (adjusted odds ratio, 2.640 [95% CI, 1.073–6.686], P=0.037) and had higher rates of functional independence (36.8% vs 11.1%, P=0.004, adjusted odds ratio, 5.392 [95% CI, 1.185–24.530], P=0.029) at 90 day. Rates of parenchymal hematoma type-2 and 90-day mortality were comparable in the reperfused and nonreperfused groups. CONCLUSIONS: Achieving reperfusion despite multiple passes leads to improved outcomes compared with failed procedures. Arbitrary uncontrolled thresholds for a maximum number of passes to predict futile recanalization may lead to inappropriate early termination of procedures.

来源:Stroke,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Mohammaden MH, Haussen DC, Pisani L, et al. Lack of Reperfusion Rather Than Number of Passes Defines Futility in Stroke Thrombectomy: A Matched Case-Control Study. Stroke. 2021. PMID: 34126760. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.120.033539

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。