重新审视比例恢复模型:基于Fugl-Meyer评估天花板效应的验证
本研究基于韩国卒中功能与康复队列,纳入849例首次缺血性卒中患者,分析上肢Fugl-Meyer评估(FMA)的天花板效应及比例恢复模型的有效性。 logistic回归显示初始神经功能缺损每增加1单位及发病年龄影响6个月时达到FMA满分的比值比(分别为1.0386和0.9736);倾向性评分匹配显示初始上肢神经功能缺损差异导致恢复比例差异(0.92±0.20 vs 0.81±0.31,P<0.001)。结论认为比例恢复模型不成立。
要点
- 上肢FMA天花板效应在初始运动缺损较轻的患者中明显。
- 初始神经功能缺损和发病年龄影响6个月时达到FMA满分的比值比。
- 初始上肢神经功能缺损不同导致恢复比例存在差异,比例恢复模型不成立。
核心结论
- 上肢FMA天花板效应在初始运动缺损较轻的患者中明显,恢复比例随初始上肢运动缺损不同而变化,比例恢复模型不成立。
主要发现
- logistic回归分析显示,初始神经功能缺损每增加1单位及发病年龄影响6个月时达到上肢FMA满分的比值比,分别为1.0386和0.9736。
- 倾向性评分匹配显示,初始上肢神经功能缺损差异导致恢复比例差异(0.92±0.20 [0–1] 对比 0.81±0.31 [0–1],P<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估上肢运动恢复时需考虑FMA天花板效应,初始缺损较轻者更易达到满分,比例恢复模型不适用于个体化预测。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to verify the validity of the proportional recovery model in view of the ceiling effect of the Fugl-Meyer Assessment. METHODS: We reviewed the medical records of patients enrolled in the Korean Stroke Cohort for Functioning and Rehabilitation between August 2012 and May 2015. Recovery proportion was defined as the actual change in Fugl-Meyer Assessment score of the upper extremity between 7 days and 6 months poststroke, relative to the initial neurological impairment. We then used logistic regression to identify clinical factors attributable to a ceiling effect of the Fugl-Meyer Assessment score of the upper extremity and propensity score matching to verify the validity of the proportional recovery rule. RESULTS: We screened 10 636 patients and analyzed 849 patients (mean age, 65.4±11.9 years; female, 320 [37.7%]) with first-ever ischemic stroke. We found, through logistic regression analysis, that a one-unit increase in the initial neurological impairment and the age at stroke onset affected the odds ratio (1.0386 and 0.9736, respectively) of achieving the full Fugl-Meyer Assessment score of the upper limb at 6 months poststroke. We also demonstrated, through propensity score matching, that the difference in initial neurological impairment of the upper extremity resulted in discrepancy of the recovery proportion (0.92±0.20 [0–1] versus 0.81±0.31 [0–1], P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrated that the ceiling effect of the Fugl-Meyer Assessment score of the upper extremity is pronounced in patients with mild initial motor deficits of the upper extremity and that the recovery proportion varies according to the initial motor deficit of the upper limb using logistic regression analysis and propensity score matching, respectively. These results suggest that the proportional recovery model is not valid.
引用
- Lee HH, Kim DY, Sohn MK, et al. Revisiting the Proportional Recovery Model in View of the Ceiling Effect of Fugl-Meyer Assessment. Stroke. 2021. PMID: 34134508. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.120.032409
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。