机器学习从CT灌注预测急性缺血梗死核心:ISLES挑战赛经验
ISLES-2018挑战赛纳入4个中心103例急性前循环大血管闭塞卒中患者,在CTP后快速行DWI并以其病灶分割为参考标准,其中63例训练、40例测试。
要点
- 机器学习可从CTP预测梗死组织,精度优于临床常规阈值法。
- 最佳Dice系数为0.51,绝对梗死体积差约10.2 mL。
- 顶级算法多基于深度学习,并利用原始灌注数据及合成互补信息。
核心结论
- 机器学习方法可从CTP预测梗死组织,准确度优于临床常规阈值法。
- 该数据集将保持公开,可用于持续测试算法改进。
研究设计与样本
- ISLES挑战赛数据来自4个中心,共103例急性前循环大血管闭塞卒中病例。
- 病例在CTP后快速接受DWI,DWI病灶分割由人工完成并作为参考标准。
- 数据分为63例训练集与40例测试集,按整体性能排序方法。
主要发现
- 至CTP的中位时间为185分钟(四分位距180-238),CTP至MRI的中位时间为36分钟(四分位距25-79)。
- 中位梗死病灶大小为15.2 mL(四分位距5.7-45)。
- Dice系数与绝对体积差的最佳表现分别为0.51与10.1 mL,来自不同团队。
- 按排名标准,排名第一团队的算法平均Dice系数为0.51、平均绝对体积差为10.2 mL,优于常规阈值法(Dice系数0.3;体积差15.3)。
关键数值与推荐
- 最佳Dice系数为0.51,最佳绝对体积差为10.1 mL,分别来自不同团队。
- 排名第一团队平均Dice系数0.51、平均绝对体积差10.2 mL。
- 常规阈值法Dice系数0.3、体积差15.3。
- 至CTP中位时间185分钟(四分位距180-238),CTP至MRI中位时间36分钟(四分位距25-79)。
- 中位梗死病灶大小15.2 mL(四分位距5.7-45)。
临床怎么用
- 对晚时间窗取栓决策,机器学习CTP梗死核心预测可能比阈值法更准确。
- 参赛算法几乎均基于深度学习,顶级方法利用原始灌注数据并合成互补信息。
- 公开数据集可用于外部验证与算法迭代改进。
局限性
- 测试集仅40例,样本量有限。
- 最佳Dice系数仅0.51,预测精度仍有提升空间。
- 数据仅来自4个中心,外推性需进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The ISLES challenge (Ischemic Stroke Lesion Segmentation) enables globally diverse teams to compete to develop advanced tools for stroke lesion analysis with machine learning. Detection of irreversibly damaged tissue on computed tomography perfusion (CTP) is often necessary to determine eligibility for late-time-window thrombectomy. Therefore, the aim of ISLES-2018 was to segment infarcted tissue on CTP based on diffusion-weighted imaging as a reference standard. METHODS: The data, from 4 centers, consisted of 103 cases of acute anterior circulation large artery occlusion stroke who underwent diffusion-weighted imaging rapidly after CTP. Diffusion-weighted imaging lesion segmentation was performed manually and acted as a reference standard. The data were separated into 63 cases for training and 40 for testing, upon which quality metrics (dice score coefficient, Hausdorff distance, absolute lesion volume difference, etc) were computed to rank methods based on their overall performance. RESULTS: Twenty-four different teams participated in the challenge. Median time to CTP was 185 minutes (interquartile range, 180-238), the time between CTP and magnetic resonance imaging was 36 minutes (interquartile range, 25-79), and the median infarct lesion size was 15.2 mL (interquartile range, 5.7-45). The best performance for Dice score coefficient and absolute volume difference were 0.51 and 10.1 mL, respectively, from different teams. Based on the ranking criteria, the top team's algorithm demonstrated for average Dice score coefficient and average absolute volume difference 0.51 and 10.2 mL, respectively, outperforming the conventional threshold-based method (dice score coefficient, 0.3; volume difference, 15.3). Diverse algorithms were used, almost all based on deep learning, with top-ranked approaches making use of the raw perfusion data as well as methods to synthetically generate complementary information to boost prediction performance. CONCLUSIONS: Machine learning methods may predict infarcted tissue from CTP with improved accuracy compared with threshold-based methods used in clinical routine. This dataset will remain public and can be used to test improvement in algorithms over time.
引用
- Hakim A, Christensen S, Winzeck S, et al. Predicting Infarct Core From Computed Tomography Perfusion in Acute Ischemia With Machine Learning: Lessons From the ISLES Challenge. Stroke. 2021. PMID: 33957774. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.120.030696
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。