增加取栓能力后患者量与结局变化的模拟研究
本研究用MATLAB Simulink模拟三中心系统,比较初级卒中中心获得血管内取栓(EVT)能力后在不同地理与转运模式下的患者量和结局变化。结果发现,在Bypass模式下新增EVT能力使TSC卒中患者总量绝对增加40.1%,急性卒中治疗量增加31.2%至31.9%;良好临床结局在全人群绝对增加0.2%至0.6%。
要点
- Bypass模式下TSC卒中患者总量绝对增加40.1%
- Bypass模式下TSC急性卒中治疗量绝对增加31.2%至31.9%
- 良好临床结局在全人群绝对增加0.2%至0.6%
核心结论
- 增加EVT能力使患者和治疗量向TSC转移,但整体人群健康改善有限。
- 卫生系统在考虑增加EVT能力时应权衡医院与患者的相对获益。
研究设计与样本
- 使用MATLAB 2017a Simulink模拟三中心系统:一个具备EVT能力的综合卒中中心、一个不具备EVT能力的初级卒中中心、一个获得EVT能力的初级卒中中心(TSC)。
- 在 urban 和 rural 两种地理设置下,采用 Nearest Center 和 Bypass 两种转运模式进行模拟。
- 良好临床结局概率基于临床试验报告的治疗类型和时机确定。
主要发现
- Bypass模式下新增EVT能力使TSC卒中患者总量绝对增加40.1%,急性卒中治疗量绝对增加31.2%至31.9%。
- Nearest Center模式下TSC卒中患者总量不变,但急性卒中治疗量绝对增加9.3%至9.5%。
- 良好临床结局在全人群绝对增加0.2%至0.6%,在TSC人群绝对增加0.3%至1.8%。
关键数值与推荐
- Bypass模式:严重卒中患者送至最近的EVT capable中心,其他患者送至最近中心。
- Nearest Center模式:患者送至最近中心,不论EVT能力。
临床怎么用
- 在Bypass转运模式下,为初级卒中中心增加EVT能力可显著增加TSC的患者量和治疗量。
- 增加EVT能力对整体人群良好临床结局的改善幅度较小,需综合评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: With the rising demand for endovascular thrombectomy (EVT) and introduction of thrombectomy-capable stroke centers (TSC), there is interest among existing stroke hospitals to add EVT capability to attract and retain stroke patient referrals. In this work, we quantify changes in patient volumes and outcomes when adding EVT capability to an existing stroke center. METHODS: In MATLAB 2017a Simulink, we simulate a 3-center system comprising an EVT-capable comprehensive stroke center, an EVT-incapable primary stroke center, and an EVT-incapable primary stroke center that gains EVT capability (TSC). We model these changes in 2 geographic settings (urban and rural) using 2 routing paradigms (Nearest Center and Bypass). In Nearest Center, patients are sent to the nearest center regardless of EVT capability. In Bypass, patients with severe strokes are sent to the nearest EVT-capable center, and all others are sent to the nearest center. Probability of good clinical outcome is determined by type and timing of treatment using outcomes reported in clinical trials. RESULTS: Adding EVT capability in the Bypass model produced an absolute increase of 40.1% in total volume of patients with stroke and 31.2% to 31.9% in total volume of acute stroke treatments at the TSC. In the Nearest Center model, the total volume of patients with stroke did not change, but total volume of acute stroke treatment at the TSC had an absolute increase of 9.3% to 9.5%. Good clinical outcomes saw an absolute increase of 0.2% to 0.6% in the whole population and 0.3% to 1.8% in the TSC population. CONCLUSIONS: Adding EVT capability shifts patient and treatment volume to the TSC. However, these changes produce modest improvement in overall population health. Health systems should weigh relative hospital and patient benefits when considering adding EVT capability.
引用
- Zhou MH, Kansagra AP. Changes in Patient Volumes and Outcomes After Adding Thrombectomy Capability. Stroke. 2021. PMID: 33866819. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.120.032389
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。