教育研究:医学生为何选择神经科——个人陈述的计算语言学分析
该研究对5年内提交至某机构的2,405份神经科住院医师申请个人陈述进行去标识化计算语言学分析,通过词频、TF-IDF和K-means聚类识别关键词与主题。结果显示卒中、癫痫和痴呆被提及频率高于肌萎缩侧索硬化和腕管综合征,常见主题包括对大脑的着迷、研究兴趣和帮助患者的愿望等。
要点
- 神经科申请者个人陈述中卒中、癫痫、痴呆提及频率高于肌萎缩侧索硬化和腕管综合征。
- 常见主题包括对大脑着迷、研究兴趣、帮助患者愿望和早期神经科兴趣。
- 这是首个针对神经科个人陈述的计算语言学分析,可辅助教育策略和招募。
核心结论
- 该首个神经科个人陈述计算语言学分析揭示了医学生选择神经科的动机和兴趣主题。
研究设计与样本
- 对5年内提交至某机构的2,405份神经科住院医师申请个人陈述进行去标识化,并使用3种计算语言学软件分析。
主要发现
- 卒中词频为2,178,癫痫为970,痴呆为944,均高于肌萎缩侧索硬化的220和腕管综合征的10。
- 最常引用的专有名词为Oliver Sacks(词频94)和Sherlock Holmes(词频41)。
- 常见主题包括对大脑的着迷、研究兴趣、帮助患者的愿望、早期神经科兴趣、持续学习追求、珍视与患者相处时间、神经疾病家族史和求知欲。
临床怎么用
- 研究结果可用于增强学生对神经科的兴趣,并帮助制定教育项目以识别、支持和招募未来神经科医生。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To understand medical students' motivations for choosing neurology and how applicants conceptualize the field, as this information can be used to enhance interest in neurology and develop educational programs to help identify, support, and recruit future neurologists. BACKGROUND: Applicants to neurology residencies submit personal statements describing themselves and their motivations. Textual analysis of personal statements has been performed in internal medicine and general surgery, but never before in neurology. We hypothesized that specific words and themes would be mentioned in residency personal statements with high frequencies indicating students' motivations. METHODS: We used computational linguistics software to assess key words and thereby study motivations, expectations, and themes present among neurology applicants. A total of 2,405 personal statements submitted over 5 years to our institution were de-identified and compiled into a database for evaluation through 3 computational linguistics software programs. We performed calculations of term frequencies (TF) and TF-inverse document frequencies and performed K-means clustering to identify unique words and common themes. RESULTS: Specific disease states were discussed. For example, stroke (TF 2,178), epilepsy (TF 970), and dementia (TF 944) were referenced more often than amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (TF 220) and carpal tunnel (TF 10). The most common proper names cited were Oliver Sacks (TF 94) and Sherlock Holmes (TF 41). Common themes included fascination with the brain, interest in research, desire to help patients, early interests in neurology, continued pursuit of learning, appreciation for time with patients, family history with neurologic illness, and intellectual curiosity. CONCLUSIONS: This first computational linguistic analysis of neurology personal statements provides understanding into medical students' motivations and interests. Ongoing subgroup and thematic analyses may inform educational strategies and enhance recruitment to our field.
引用
- Grzebinski S, Cheung H, Sanky C, et al. Educational Research: Why Medical Students Choose Neurology: A Computational Linguistics Analysis of Personal Statements. Neurology. 2021. PMID: 33658327. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000011753
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。