神经源性吞咽障碍:系统综述与表型分类系统提案
该研究基于吞咽纤维内镜(FEES)表现,系统综述并开发了神经源性吞咽障碍的表型分类,在1012例随机选择的FEES视频中验证。共识别7种吞咽障碍表型,不同神经疾病具有不同表型分布,评定者间信度强(kappa=0.84),提示吞咽障碍表型有助于病因鉴别。
要点
- 神经源性吞咽障碍是多种表型的综合征,而非单一症状。
- 不同神经疾病具有特征性FEES吞咽障碍表型分布。
- 表型分类评定者间信度强(kappa=0.84),可用于鉴别诊断。
核心结论
- 神经源性吞咽障碍不是单一症状,而是多病因综合征,其表型模式取决于基础疾病。
- 吞咽障碍表型可促进不明原因吞咽障碍患者的鉴别诊断。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索MEDLINE自建库至2020年5月,纳入59篇文献进行定性综合。
- 基于FEES视频回顾分析开发神经源性吞咽障碍表型分类,并用1012例随机选择的FEES视频验证。
- 采用卡方检验比较不同神经疾病间吞咽障碍表型的分布。
主要发现
- 共识别7种吞咽障碍表型:过早食团溢出、吞咽反射延迟、会厌谷残留为主、梨状窦残留为主、咽喉运动障碍、易疲劳性吞咽无力、复杂障碍。
- 过早食团溢出和吞咽反射延迟主要见于卒中。
- 会厌谷残留为主最常见于帕金森病;梨状窦残留为主仅见于肌炎、运动神经元病和脑干卒中。
- 咽喉运动障碍见于非典型帕金森综合征和卒中;易疲劳性吞咽无力常见于重症肌无力。
- 复杂障碍伴异质性吞咽模式是肌萎缩侧索硬化症的主要机制。
关键数值与推荐
- 评定者间信度强,kappa=0.84。
- 共159篇文献被识别,其中59篇纳入定性综合。
- 验证队列为1012例随机选择的FEES视频。
临床怎么用
- 对不明原因吞咽障碍患者,可根据FEES表型提示潜在神经疾病,辅助鉴别诊断。
- 在帕金森病、非典型帕金森综合征、卒中、重症肌无力、肌萎缩侧索硬化症等疾病中,可依据特征性表型优化评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Introduction and validation of a phenotypic classification of neurogenic dysphagia based on flexible endoscopic evaluation of swallowing (FEES). METHODS: A systematic literature review was conducted, searching MEDLINE from inception to May 2020 for FEES findings in neurologic diseases of interest. Based on a retrospective analysis of FEES videos in neurologic diseases and considering the results from the review, a classification of neurogenic dysphagia was developed distinguishing different phenotypes. The classification was validated using 1,012 randomly selected FEES videos of patients with various neurologic disorders. Chi-square tests were used to compare the distribution of dysphagia phenotypes between the underlying neurologic disorders. RESULTS: A total of 159 articles were identified, of which 59 were included in the qualitative synthesis. Seven dysphagia phenotypes were identified: (1) "premature bolus spillage" and (2) "delayed swallowing reflex" occurred mainly in stroke, (3) "predominance of residue in the valleculae" was most common in Parkinson disease, (4) "predominance of residue in the piriform sinus" occurred only in myositis, motoneuron disease, and brainstem stroke, (5) "pharyngolaryngeal movement disorder" was found in atypical Parkinsonian syndromes and stroke, (6) "fatigable swallowing weakness" was common in myasthenia gravis, and (7) "complex disorder" with a heterogeneous dysphagia pattern was the leading mechanism in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. The interrater reliability showed a strong agreement (kappa = 0.84). CONCLUSION: Neurogenic dysphagia is not a symptom, but a multietiologic syndrome with different phenotypic patterns depending on the underlying disease. Dysphagia phenotypes can facilitate differential diagnosis in patients with dysphagia of unclear etiology.
引用
- Warnecke T, Labeit B, Schroeder J, et al. Neurogenic Dysphagia: Systematic Review and Proposal of a Classification System. Neurology. 2020. PMID: 33318164. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000011350
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。