美国疑似卒中患者院前分诊策略评估
该研究采用决策树模型和地理信息系统,评估美国疑似卒中患者在发病4.5小时内救护车转运的院前分诊策略。修改算法可增加1013例(+1.8%)至1369例(+2.4%)良好结局,NNTI 28-32。结论认为当前AHA算法作为全国政策次优,应修改以允许更多延迟。
要点
- AHA算法全国实施增加594例良好结局(+1.0%),NNTI 28。
- 修改算法(无时间限制或<60分钟延迟)可增加1013-1369例良好结局。
- 无时间限制算法在32个州(65%)被首选,<60分钟延迟算法在10个州(20%)被首选。
核心结论
- 院前分诊策略可大幅改善美国缺血性卒中人群结局,但增加转运至介入中心的非LVO患者数量。
- 当前AHA算法作为全国政策次优,应修改以允许更多延迟。
研究设计与样本
- 决策树模型结合地理信息系统,评估发病4.5小时内救护车转运的疑似卒中患者。
- 比较策略:始终送最近中心、AHA算法(院前量表提示LVO且总驾车时间<30分钟且不排除溶栓)、修改算法(额外驾车时间<30分钟、<60分钟或无限制)、始终送介入中心。
- 主要结局为良好结局年数(mRS 0-2),首选策略需NNTI<100以预防一例死亡或严重残疾(mRS>2)。
主要发现
- 修改算法增加1013例(+1.8%)至1369例(+2.4%)良好结局,NNTI 28-32。
- 无时间限制算法在32个州(65%)被首选,<60分钟延迟算法在10个州(20%)被首选。
- 县级别定制政策略微减少总转运量(NNTI 31)。
临床怎么用
- 可考虑修改AHA算法,允许疑似LVO患者直接转运至介入中心时更多延迟。
- 实施院前分诊策略需权衡良好结局增加与非LVO患者转运增加。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Ischemic stroke patients with large vessel occlusion (LVO) could benefit from direct transportation to an intervention center for endovascular treatment, but non-LVO patients need rapid IV thrombolysis in the nearest center. Our aim was to evaluate prehospital triage strategies for suspected stroke patients in the United States. METHODS: We used a decision tree model and geographic information system to estimate outcome of suspected stroke patients transported by ambulance within 4.5 hours after symptom onset. We compared the following strategies: (1) Always to nearest center, (2) American Heart Association algorithm (ie, directly to intervention center if a prehospital stroke scale suggests LVO and total driving time from scene to intervention center is <30 minutes, provided that the delay would not exclude from thrombolysis), (3) modified algorithms with a maximum additional driving time to the intervention center of <30 minutes, <60 minutes, or without time limit, and (4) always to intervention center. Primary outcome was the annual number of good outcomes, defined as modified Rankin Scale score of 0-2. The preferred strategy was the one that resulted in the best outcomes with an incremental number needed to transport to intervention center (NNTI) <100 to prevent one death or severe disability (modified Rankin Scale score of >2). RESULTS: Nationwide implementation of the American Heart Association algorithm increased the number of good outcomes by 594 (+1.0%) compared with transportation to the nearest center. The associated number of non-LVO patients transported to the intervention center was 16 714 (NNTI 28). The modified algorithms yielded an increase of 1013 (+1.8%) to 1369 (+2.4%) good outcomes, with a NNTI varying between 28 and 32. The algorithm without time limit was preferred in the majority of states (n=32 [65%]), followed by the algorithm with <60 minutes delay (n=10 [20%]). Tailoring policies at county-level slightly reduced the total number of transportations to the intervention center (NNTI 31). CONCLUSIONS: Prehospital triage strategies can greatly improve outcomes of the ischemic stroke population in the United States, but increase the number of non-LVO stroke patients transported to an intervention center. The current American Heart Association algorithm is suboptimal as a nationwide policy and should be modified to allow more delay when directly transporting LVO-suspected patients to an intervention center.
引用
- Venema E, Burke JF, Roozenbeek B, et al. Prehospital Triage Strategies for the Transportation of Suspected Stroke Patients in the United States. Stroke. 2020. PMID: 33023425. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.120.031144
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。