卒中幸存者的吸烟悖论?通过解读两组数据揭示真相
研究利用台湾卒中登记(88 925例)和MJ队列(541 047人,15年随访1630例卒中死亡)两组独立数据,评估吸烟与卒中预后关系。发现吸烟者卒中发病年龄比不吸烟者早约11年(中位60.2岁 vs 71.6岁),年龄性别匹配后吸烟的预后优势消失;无卒中史吸烟者卒中死亡风险约增2倍,而有卒中史者死亡风险增7.83倍。早期戒烟可逆转或改善危害。
要点
- 吸烟者卒中发病比不吸烟者早约11年,中位年龄60.2岁对71.6岁。
- 年龄性别匹配后,吸烟者卒中后功能独立和死亡的优势消失。
- 有卒中史吸烟者死亡风险增7.83倍,远超无卒中史吸烟者的约2倍。
核心结论
- 吸烟者卒中死亡风险约增2倍,但卒中残疾持续时间比不吸烟者长11年,早期戒烟可减少或逆转危害。
研究设计与样本
- 台湾卒中登记纳入88 925例卒中病例,主要结局为3个月改良Rankin量表评分≤2的功能独立,按入院美国国立卫生研究院卒中量表评分分层。
- MJ队列纳入541 047名参加医学筛查的成年人,15年随访(1994-2008)期间发生1630例卒中死亡,按吸烟状态或卒中史评估风险比。
主要发现
- 吸烟者与不吸烟者卒中发病中位年龄分别为60.2岁和71.6岁,相差>11年。
- 按美国国立卫生研究院卒中量表评分分层,吸烟者3个月改良Rankin量表评分≤2的功能预后和死亡结局更优,但年龄和性别匹配后优势消失。
- 无卒中史吸烟者卒中死亡风险增加约2倍(缺血性卒中风险比2.05,出血性卒中风险比1.53),有卒中史吸烟者风险增加7.83倍。
- 较早年龄戒烟可逆转或改善结局。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估卒中预后时应考虑吸烟者发病年龄更早、残疾持续时间更长,不应将吸烟视为保护因素。
- 对有卒中史者应强调戒烟,早期戒烟可减少或逆转吸烟相关危害。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Background and Purpose- The observation that smokers with stroke could have better outcome than nonsmokers led to the term "smoking paradox." The controversy of such a complex claim has not been fully settled, even though different case mix was noted. Analyses were conducted on 2 independent data sets to evaluate and determine whether such a paradox truly exists. Methods- Taiwan Stroke Registry with 88 925 stroke cases, and MJ cohort with 541 047 adults participating in a medical screening program with 1630 stroke deaths developed during 15 years of follow-up (1994-2008). Primary outcome for stroke registry was functional independence at 3 months by modified Rankin Scale score ≤2, for individuals classified by National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale score at admission. For MJ cohort, mortality risk by smoking status or by stroke history was assessed by hazard ratio. Results- A >11-year age difference in stroke incidence was found between smokers and nonsmokers, with a median age of 60.2 years for current smokers and 71.6 years for nonsmokers. For smokers, favorable outcome in mortality and in functional assessment in 3 months with modified Rankin Scale score ≤2 stratified by the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale score was present but disappeared when age and sex were matched. Smokers without stroke history had a ≈2-fold increase in stroke deaths (2.05 for ischemic stroke and 1.53 for hemorrhagic stroke) but smokers with stroke history, 7.83-fold increase, overshadowing smoking risk. Quitting smoking at earlier age reversed or improved outcome. Conclusions- "The more you smoke, the earlier you stroke, and the longer sufferings you have to cope." Smokers had 2-fold mortality from stroke but endured stroke disability 11 years longer. Quitting early reduced or reversed the harms.
引用
- Wang HK, Huang CY, Sun YT, et al. Smoking Paradox in Stroke Survivors?: Uncovering the Truth by Interpreting 2 Sets of Data. Stroke. 2020. PMID: 32151234. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.119.027012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。