急性缺血性卒中血管内取栓的美国可及性模式与优化方法
该研究利用地理映射分析美国卒中中心,发现仅19.8%美国人在15分钟内可直接到达血管内取栓中心。通过将非取栓中心转为取栓中心或绕过非取栓中心两种优化模型,均可提高直接可及性,其中绕行策略潜力更大。
要点
- 美国仅19.8%人口可在15分钟内直接到达取栓中心。
- 将10%非取栓中心转为取栓中心可提升全国15分钟可及性7.5%。
- 绕行非取栓中心至最近取栓中心可提升覆盖率16.7%。
核心结论
- 美国15分钟内直接取栓可及性不足五分之一人口。
- 增加取栓中心或绕行非取栓中心均能提升可及性。
- 绕行策略在最大化直接取栓可及性上潜力更大。
研究设计与样本
- 利用地理映射分析美国卒中治疗中心,依据2017年医疗保险与医疗补助服务中心取栓代码报告将中心分为非取栓或取栓中心。
- 采用adapted trauma-models计算直接取栓可及性。
- 使用两种优化模型:Model-A贪心算法翻转10%和20%非取栓中心;Model-B绕行方法,若从地理质心到最近取栓中心与到最近非取栓中心的驾车时间差在15分钟内则直接转运至取栓中心。
主要发现
- 1941个卒中中心中713个(37%)为取栓中心。
- 德州65个(43%)取栓中心,22%人口当前15分钟内可及;翻转10%高人口密度医院后提升至30.8%,绕行后45.5%直接可及。
- 纽约当前20.9%,翻转后34.7%,绕行后50.4%;加州当前25.5%,翻转后37.3%,绕行后53.9%;伊利诺伊州当前15.3%,翻转后21.9%,绕行后34.6%。
- 全国范围内,翻转前10%非取栓中心为取栓能力中心使15分钟直接可及性从19.8%增加7.5%;绕行非取栓中心15分钟使覆盖率增加16.7%。
临床怎么用
- 应识别各州取栓可及性差距并定制解决方案。
- 增加取栓中心或绕行非取栓中心均可作为优化策略。
- 绕行策略可能更有效最大化直接取栓可及性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Background and Purpose- Timely access to endovascular thrombectomy (EVT) centers is vital for best acute ischemic stroke outcomes. Methods- US stroke-treating centers were mapped utilizing geo-mapping and stratified into non-EVT or EVT if they reported ≥1 acute ischemic stroke thrombectomy code in 2017 to Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Direct EVT-access, defined as the population with the closest facility being an EVT-center, was calculated from validated trauma-models adapted for stroke. Current 15- and 30-minute access were described nationwide and at state-level with emphasis on 4 states (TX, NY, CA, IL). Two optimization models were utilized. Model-A used a greedy algorithm to capture the largest population with direct access when flipping 10% and 20% non-EVT to EVT-centers to maximize access. Model-B used bypassing methodology to directly transport patients to the nearest EVT centers if the drive-time difference from the geo-centroid to hospital was within 15 minutes from the geo-centroid to the closest non-EVT center. Results- Of 1941 stroke-centers, 713 (37%) were EVT. Approximately 61 million (19.8%) Americans have direct EVT access within 15 minutes while 95 million (30.9%) within 30 minutes. There were 65 (43%) EVT centers in TX with 22% of the population currently within 15-minute access. Flipping 10% hospitals with top population density improved access to 30.8%, while bypassing resulted in 45.5% having direct access to EVT centers. Similar results were found in NY (current, 20.9%; flipping, 34.7%; bypassing, 50.4%), CA (current, 25.5%; flipping, 37.3%; bypassing, 53.9%), and IL (current, 15.3%; flipping, 21.9%; bypassing, 34.6%). Nationwide, the current direct access within 15 minutes of 19.8% increased by 7.5% by flipping the top 10% non-EVT to EVT-capable in all states. Bypassing non-EVT centers by 15 minutes resulted in a 16.7% gain in coverage. Conclusions- EVT-access within 15 minutes is limited to less than one-fifth of the US population. Optimization methodologies that increase EVT centers or bypass non-EVT to the closest EVT center both showed enhanced access. Results varied by states based on the population size and density. However, bypass showed more potential for maximizing direct EVT-access. National and state efforts should focus on identifying gaps and tailoring solutions to improve EVT-access.
引用
- Sarraj A, Savitz S, Pujara D, et al. Endovascular Thrombectomy for Acute Ischemic Strokes: Current US Access Paradigms and Optimization Methodology. Stroke. 2020. PMID: 32078480. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.120.028850
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。