文献速递脑血管病

急性卒中转运优化模型:滴灌-直送模式的影响

Modeling the Optimal Transportation for Acute Stroke Treatment: The Impact of the Drip-and-Drive Paradigm.
PubMed 文献 · Stroke · 2019-11-18

研究基于德国西北部64 065 km²、12 703 561人口区域,用条件概率模型比较mothership、drip-and-ship与drip-and-drive三种转运模式。结果显示mothership覆盖面积最大,但当针到介入医师离开时间和介入医师到达至穿刺时间均<40分钟时,drip-and-drive覆盖面积大于drip-and-ship;流程减慢可使drip-and-drive覆盖面积降至1221 km²(2%)。

要点

  • mothership模式覆盖面积最大,但drip-and-drive在多数场景下优于drip-and-ship。
  • 针到介入医师离开时间和介入医师到达至穿刺时间均<40分钟时,drip-and-drive覆盖面积更大。
  • drip-and-drive流程减慢可使其覆盖面积降至1221 km²(2%)。

核心结论

  • 在德国西北部多数场景下,mothership覆盖面积最大,drip-and-drive覆盖面积大于drip-and-ship。
  • 不同转运模式可分散能力、分担成本与医院收入,并使初级卒中中心可24/7提供血管内治疗服务。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于血管内治疗与静脉溶栓衰减曲线的条件概率模型,比较三种转运模式的最佳覆盖面积。
  • 研究区域为下萨克森、汉堡和石勒苏益格-荷尔斯泰因,面积64 065 km²,2017年人口12 703 561(198人/km²)。

主要发现

  • mothership模式覆盖面积最大。
  • 当针到介入医师离开时间和介入医师到达至穿刺时间均<40分钟时,drip-and-drive覆盖面积大于drip-and-ship。
  • drip-and-drive流程减慢可使其覆盖面积降至1221 km²(2%)。

关键数值与推荐

  • drip-and-drive覆盖面积大于drip-and-ship的条件:针到介入医师离开时间<40分钟且介入医师到达至穿刺时间<40分钟。
  • drip-and-drive流程减慢时覆盖面积降至1221 km²(2%)。

临床怎么用

  • 在规划急性卒中转运网络时,可依据当地流程时间评估drip-and-drive是否优于drip-and-ship。
  • 维持针到介入医师离开时间和介入医师到达至穿刺时间均<40分钟对drip-and-drive覆盖面积至关重要。

局限性

  • 研究基于德国西北部特定区域建模,结果外推需谨慎。
  • 模型依赖衰减曲线与多种治疗时间参数假设,未报告实际临床结局验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Background and Purpose- Health systems are faced with the challenge of ensuring fast access to appropriate therapy for patients with acute stroke. The paradigms primarily discussed are mothership and drip and ship. Less attention has been focused on the drip-and-drive (DD) paradigm. Our aim was to analyze whether and under what conditions DD would predict the greatest probability of good outcome for patients with suspected ischemic stroke in Northwestern Germany. Methods- Conditional probability models based on the decay curves for endovascular therapy and intravenous thrombolysis were created to determine the best transport paradigm, and results were displayed using map visualizations. Our study area consisted of the federal states of Lower Saxony, Hamburg, and Schleswig-Holstein in Northwestern Germany covering an area of 64 065 km2 with a population of 12 703 561 in 2017 (198 persons per km2). In several scenarios, the catchment area, that is, the region that would result in the greatest probability of good outcomes, was calculated for each of the mothership, drip-and-ship, and the DD paradigms. Several different treatment time parameters were varied including onset-to-first-medical-response time, ambulance-on-scene time, door-to-needle time at primary stroke center, needle-to-door time, door-to-needle time at comprehensive stroke center, door-to-groin-puncture time, needle-to-interventionalist-leave time, and interventionalist-arrival-to-groin-puncture time. Results- The mothership paradigm had the largest catchment area; however, the DD catchment area was larger than the drip-and-ship catchment area so long as the needle-to-interventionalist-leave time and the interventionalist-arrival-to-groin-puncture time remain <40 minutes each. A slowed workflow in the DD paradigm resulted in a decrease of the DD catchment area to 1221 km2 (2%). Conclusions- Our study suggests the largest catchment area for the mothership paradigm and a larger catchment area of DD paradigm compared with the drip-and-ship paradigm in Northwestern Germany in most scenarios. The existence of different paradigms allows the spread of capacities, shares the cost and hospital income, and gives primary stroke centers the possibility to provide endovascular therapy services 24/7.

来源:Stroke,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ernst M, Schlemm E, Holodinsky JK, et al. Modeling the Optimal Transportation for Acute Stroke Treatment: The Impact of the Drip-and-Drive Paradigm. Stroke. 2019. PMID: 31735142. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.119.027493

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。