急性卒中诊疗中的医疗过失诉讼系统综述
该综述通过三大法律数据库检索美国急性卒中诊疗相关的医疗过失诉讼,共纳入246例缺血性卒中和26例颅内出血案件。结果显示56%案件无赔付,27%庭外和解,17%原告诉讼获胜;诉讼多涉及未能诊断和治疗,tPA相关诉讼常见,取栓相关诉讼较少但可能增加。
要点
- 急性卒中医疗过失诉讼风险高,56%案件无赔付但和解与判决赔付金额可观。
- 诉讼多指控未能诊断或治疗,tPA相关诉讼常见,取栓相关诉讼较少。
- 随着取栓指南更新和疗效证据强化,相关诉讼可能增加。
核心结论
- 急性卒中诊疗存在医疗过失诉讼风险,可导致显著经济后果。
- 多数诉讼指控未能诊断和未能治疗,tPA相关诉讼常见,取栓相关诉讼较少但可能增加。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索美国三大法律数据库的陪审团裁决和和解案件。
- 纳入与急性卒中诊疗过失相关的案件,共246例缺血性卒中和26例颅内出血。
主要发现
- 246例缺血性卒中相关案件和26例颅内出血相关案件。
- 151例(56%)无赔付,74例(27%)庭外和解,47例(17%)原告诉讼获胜。
临床怎么用
- 急性卒中诊疗中应注重及时诊断和治疗,尤其是tPA和取栓的适应证评估,以降低诉讼风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Background and Purpose- The emergency management of stroke is complex and highly time-sensitive. Recent landmark trials demonstrating the strong benefit of thrombectomy have led to rapid change in stroke management. This article reviews a large number of medical malpractice lawsuits related to the emergency management of stroke to characterize factors involved in these lawsuits. Methods- Three large legal databases were used to search for jury verdicts and settlements in cases related to the acute care of stroke patients in the United States. Search terms included "stroke" and "medical malpractice." Cases were screened to include only cases in which the allegation involved negligence in the acute care of a patient suffering a stroke. Results- We found 246 medical malpractice cases related to the acute management of ischemic stroke and 26 related to intracranial hemorrhage. Seventy-one cases specifically alleged a failure to treat with tPA (tissue-type plasminogen activator) and 7 cases alleged a failure to treat, or to timely treat, with thrombectomy. Overall there were 151 cases (56%) which ended with no payout, 74 cases (27%) were settled out of court, and 47 cases (17%) went to court and resulted in a verdict for the plaintiff. The average payout in settlements was $1 802 693, and the average payout in plaintiff verdicts was $9 705 099. Conclusions- Malpractice litigation is a risk in acute stroke care and can lead to significant financial consequences. The majority of malpractice lawsuits related to the emergency management of stroke allege a failure to diagnose and failure to treat. Allegations of a failure to treat acute ischemic stroke with tPA were frequently found and are common in lawsuits. Allegations of a failure to treat a large vessel occlusion with thrombectomy were less frequently found. Given recent changes in practice guidelines and the demonstrated strong treatment effect of thrombectomy, it is likely that such litigation will increase in the coming years.
引用
- Haslett JJ, Genadry L, Zhang X, et al. Systematic Review of Malpractice Litigation in the Diagnosis and Treatment of Acute Stroke. Stroke. 2019. PMID: 31422736. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.119.025352
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。