多发性硬化研究中女性的可见度与代表性
该研究分析了4本普通神经病学杂志的2080篇文章和2本多发性硬化(MS)专刊的452篇文章,评估第一作者和资深作者的性别分布,并调查了ECTRIMS的性别代表性。结果显示,普通神经病学杂志中女性第一作者占36%、女性资深作者占25%;MS专刊中女性第一作者占44%、女性资深作者占35%;2017年ECTRIMS参会者中近50%为女性,但受邀演讲者中仅35%为女性。结论指出从初级到资深研究层级存在显著的女性流失,亟需采取支持性别平衡的策略。
要点
- 普通神经病学杂志女性第一作者36%、资深作者25%,MS专刊分别为44%和35%。
- 2017年ECTRIMS参会者近50%为女性,但受邀演讲者仅35%为女性。
- 从初级到资深研究层级存在显著的女性流失,需制定支持性别平衡的策略。
核心结论
- 在多个领域从初级到资深研究层级存在显著的女性流失。
- 亟需制定支持性别平衡的策略,包括导师计划、确保会议性别平衡以及审视女性学者面临的障碍以直接应对无意识偏见。
研究设计与样本
- 在线检索期刊编委会和内容以评估第一作者和资深作者。
- 回顾2017年各期刊已发表的目录。
- 联系ECTRIMS组织者Congrex,从在线摘要获取演讲者姓名以评估可见的意见领袖。
- 分析了4本普通神经病学杂志的2080篇文章和2本MS专刊的452篇文章。
主要发现
- 普通神经病学杂志中36%的文章第一作者为女性,25%的资深作者为女性。
- MS专刊中44%的第一作者和35%的资深作者为女性,独立作者的比例相似。
- ECTRIMS执行委员会中女性代表有限,但理事会的性别比例较为平衡。
- 2017年ECTRIMS参会者中近50%为女性,但受邀演讲者中仅35%为女性。
临床怎么用
- 在神经科临床与科研管理中关注女性从初级到资深层级的流失,制定导师计划支持女性学术发展。
- 在会议组织与学术活动中确保性别平衡,邀请女性学者作为演讲者。
- 审视并直接应对女性学者面临的无意识偏见等障碍。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To establish the gender distribution of multiple sclerosis (MS) researchers across high-impact neurologic publications, MS-specific journals, and the European Committee for Treatment and Research in MS (ECTRIMS). METHODS: Journal editorial boards and contents were retrieved online to assess first-named and senior authors. Published tables of contents for each journal from 2017 were reviewed. Congrex, the ECTRIMS organizers, were contacted and speaker names were obtained from online abstracts to assess visible opinion leaders. RESULTS: A total of 2,080 articles were analyzed across 4 general neurology journals, and 452 across 2 MS journals. Overall, 36% of general neurology articles had a female first name author and 25% had a female senior author. In MS-specific journals, 44% of first authors and 35% of senior authors were female, with similar proportions of unique authors. There is limited female representation on the ECTRIMS executive board, but reasonable balance on Council. Almost 50% of attendees in 2017 were female, but only 35% of invited speakers. CONCLUSIONS: There is substantial female drop-off between junior and senior research level across multiple areas. Strategies to support gender balance are urgently required, including developing mentorship schemes, ensuring gender balance in conferences, and thorough examination of the barriers facing female academics with direct challenges to address unconscious bias.
引用
- Thomson A, Horne R, Chung C, et al. Visibility and representation of women in multiple sclerosis research. Neurology. 2019. PMID: 30894447. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000007276
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。