多发性硬化的误诊:2017年McDonald标准对临床实践的影响
本文讨论多发性硬化(MS)误诊问题及2017年McDonald标准修订对误诊的影响。2017标准新增减少误诊的建议,但若应用不当(如未适当评估皮质病灶、症状性病灶和寡克隆带),仍可能导致误诊。对于非典型临床表现的患者,不应立即诊断MS,而应进一步评估或监测。
要点
- 2017年McDonald标准应仅用于验证研究中的典型脱髓鞘综合征患者。
- MRI病灶特征已定义,但评估皮质病灶、症状性病灶和寡克隆带时若应用不当可能致误诊。
- 对非典型临床表现患者,进一步评估或监测而非立即诊断MS是审慎的。
核心结论
- 2017年McDonald标准纳入了与MS误诊相关的问题并提出了预防建议,但临床和影像学评估的解释仍可能导致误诊。
- 对于非典型临床表现的患者,修订后的McDonald标准可能不易应用,此时进一步评估或监测而非立即诊断MS是审慎的。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述,讨论2017年McDonald标准修订对MS误诊问题的影响。
主要发现
- 研究表明,被误诊的患者常面临长期不必要的医疗风险和疾病负担。
- 2017年McDonald标准包含多项减少潜在误诊的新建议,应仅用于验证研究中的典型脱髓鞘综合征患者。
- 2017年修订版纳入皮质病灶评估、症状性病灶和阳性寡克隆带以满足诊断标准,若应用不当可能导致MS误诊。
关键数值与推荐
- 2017年McDonald标准应仅用于验证研究中的典型脱髓鞘综合征患者。
- MRI病灶特征已定义,预期McDonald标准在这些特征下可准确应用。
- 2017年修订版纳入皮质病灶评估、症状性病灶和阳性寡克隆带用于满足诊断标准。
临床怎么用
- 对于非典型临床表现的患者,修订后的McDonald标准可能不易应用,此时进一步评估或监测而非立即诊断MS是审慎的。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Misdiagnosis of multiple sclerosis (MS) (the incorrect assignment of a diagnosis of MS) remains a problem in contemporary clinical practice. Studies indicate that misdiagnosed patients are often exposed to prolonged unnecessary health care risks and morbidity. The recently published 2017 revision of the McDonald criteria for the diagnosis of MS provides an opportunity to consider the effect of these revisions on the problem of MS misdiagnosis. The 2017 McDonald criteria include several new recommendations to reduce potential for misdiagnoses. The criteria should be used for the types of patients in which validation studies were performed, specifically those patients who present with typical demyelinating syndromes. MRI lesion characteristics were defined for which McDonald criteria would be expected to perform with accuracy. However, 2017 revisions, which now include assessment for cortical lesions, and the inclusion of symptomatic lesions and positive oligoclonal bands for the fulfillment of diagnostic criteria, may have the potential to lead to misdiagnosis of MS if not applied appropriately. While the 2017 McDonald criteria integrate issues relating to MS misdiagnosis and incorporate specific recommendations for its prevention more prominently than prior criteria, the interpretation of clinical and radiologic assessments upon which these criteria depend will continue to allow misdiagnoses. In patients with atypical clinical presentations, the revised McDonald criteria may not be readily applied. In those situations, further evaluation or monitoring rather than immediate diagnosis of MS is prudent.
引用
- Solomon AJ, Naismith RT, Cross AH, et al. Misdiagnosis of multiple sclerosis: Impact of the 2017 McDonald criteria on clinical practice. Neurology. 2018. PMID: 30381369. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000006583
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。