门至溶栓时间低于20分钟时诊断脑缺血的准确性
在2013年5月至2015年11月期间,对1015例经救护车送达、适合再通治疗的卒中代码患者进行观察性队列研究,评估入院诊断准确性。急性脑缺血诊断正确率为91.1%(604/663),出血性卒中为99.2%(117/118),卒中模仿为61.5%(144/234)。误诊150例(14.8%),其中135例(90.0%)初始影像无急性发现,100例(67.6%)NIHSS评分为0至2分。误诊改变了70例的医疗管理,包括不必要的治疗和溶栓遗漏等。
要点
- 急性脑缺血入院诊断正确率为91.1%(604/663),出血性卒中为99.2%(117/118),卒中模仿为61.5%(144/234)。
- 误诊患者中90.0%(135/150)初始影像无急性发现,67.6%(100/150)NIHSS评分为0至2分。
- 误诊导致70例医疗管理改变,包括13例不必要的溶栓和5例溶栓遗漏。
核心结论
- 研究结果支持在训练有素、大批量集中化卒中服务中实现高度优化的门至针时间的安性。
- 需要增强影像学和前置专家参与以进一步改善快速卒中诊断。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性队列研究,纳入2013年5月至2015年11月期间经救护车送达的1015例卒中代码患者,均为再通治疗候选者。
- 入院评估由卒中神经科医生或受过专门卒中培训的神经科住院医师完成,主要使用基于CT的影像学。
主要发现
- 急性脑缺血(缺血性卒中/短暂性脑缺血发作)入院诊断正确率为91.1%(604/663)。
- 出血性卒中入院诊断正确率为99.2%(117/118)。
- 卒中模仿入院诊断正确率为61.5%(144/234)。
- 150例(14.8%)误诊患者中,135例(90.0%)初始影像无急性发现,100例(67.6%)NIHSS评分为0至2分。
- 误诊改变医疗管理70例,包括不必要的治疗(溶栓13例,其他24例)、溶栓遗漏5例、卒中模仿特定治疗延迟13例(中位56[31-93]小时)、抗血小板药物延迟14例(中位1[1-2]天)。
关键数值与推荐
- 误诊延长急诊停留时间(中位6.6[4.7-10.4]小时 vs 5.8[3.7-9.2]小时;p=0.001)。
- 误诊导致不必要的卒中单元停留10例。
- 详细审查发现8例(0.8%)误诊可能或很可能加重结局,但无因误诊导致的死亡。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To clarify diagnostic accuracy and consequences of misdiagnosis in the admission evaluation of stroke-code patients in a neurologic emergency department with less than 20-minute door-to-thrombolysis times. METHODS: Accuracy of admission diagnostics was studied in an observational cohort of 1,015 stroke-code patients arriving by ambulance as candidates for recanalization therapy between May 2013 and November 2015. Immediate admission evaluation was performed by a stroke neurologist or a neurology resident with dedicated stroke training, primarily utilizing CT-based imaging. RESULTS: The rate of correct admission diagnosis was 91.1% (604/663) for acute cerebral ischemia (ischemic stroke/TIA), 99.2% (117/118) for hemorrhagic stroke, and 61.5% (144/234) for stroke mimics. Of the 150 (14.8%) misdiagnosed patients, 135 (90.0%) had no acute findings on initial imaging and 100 (67.6%) presented with NIH Stroke Scale score 0 to 2. Misdiagnosis altered medical management in 70 cases, including administration of unnecessary treatments (thrombolysis n = 13, other n = 24), omission of thrombolysis (n = 5), delays to specific treatments of stroke mimics (n = 13, median 56 [31-93] hours), and delays to antiplatelet medication (n = 14, median 1 [1-2] day). Misdiagnosis extended emergency department stay (median 6.6 [4.7-10.4] vs 5.8 [3.7-9.2] hours; p = 0.001) and led to unnecessary stroke unit stay (n = 10). Detailed review revealed 8 cases (0.8%) in which misdiagnosis was possible or likely to have worsened outcomes, but no death occurred as a result of misdiagnosis. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings support the safety of highly optimized door-to-needle times, built on thorough training in a large-volume, centralized stroke service with long-standing experience. Augmented imaging and front-loaded specialist engagement are warranted to further improve rapid stroke diagnostics.
引用
- Pihlasviita S, Mattila OS, Ritvonen J, et al. Diagnosing cerebral ischemia with door-to-thrombolysis times below 20 minutes. Neurology. 2018. PMID: 29997196. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000005954
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。