区分倾斜试验诱发的晕厥与惊厥性癫痫发作中的运动现象
本研究通过视频脑电图分析65例倾斜试验诱发的晕厥和50次惊厥性癫痫发作,评估肌阵挛和强直姿势的特点。晕厥中肌阵挛较少(中位数2次 vs 48次,p<0.001)且节律性较低,肌张力缺失仅见于晕厥。作者提出「10/20规则」:肌阵挛少于10次提示晕厥,多于20次提示惊厥性发作。
要点
- 晕厥中肌阵挛中位数2次,惊厥性发作中位数48次,两者无重叠。
- 肌张力缺失见于所有晕厥病例,惊厥性发作中未见。
- 「10/20规则」:肌阵挛少于10次提示晕厥,多于20次提示惊厥性发作。
核心结论
- 晕厥中肌阵挛和强直姿势常见,但半iology与惊厥性发作不同。
- 肌阵挛次数无重叠,少于10次提示晕厥,多于20次提示惊厥性发作(「10/20规则」)。
- 肌张力缺失强烈提示晕厥。
- 脑电图相关提示晕厥中的肌阵挛可能为皮层起源,而强直姿势可能源于脑干去抑制。
研究设计与样本
- 研究视频脑电图记录,纳入15岁及以上参与者的倾斜试验诱发的晕厥和惊厥性发作。
- 晕厥定义:意识丧失(视频评估)、循环变化(血压加速下降伴或不伴心动过缓/心脏停搏)、脑电图改变(慢波或慢-平-慢)。
- 评估肌阵挛和手臂强直姿势,记录发生时间、侧别、同步性和节律性。
主要发现
- 纳入65例晕厥和50次惊厥性发作的视频脑电图记录。
- 晕厥中姿势出现42例(65%),肌阵挛出现33例(51%)。
- 晕厥中肌阵挛中位数2次(范围1-19),惊厥性发作中位数48次(范围20-191),p<0.001。
- 惊厥性发作中肌阵挛节律性高于晕厥(p<0.001)。
- 肌张力缺失见于所有晕厥病例,惊厥性发作中未见。
关键数值与推荐
- 晕厥中肌阵挛中位数2次(范围1-19),惊厥性发作中位数48次(范围20-191),p<0.001。
- 肌阵挛节律性在惊厥性发作中高于晕厥,p<0.001。
- 肌张力缺失见于所有晕厥病例,惊厥性发作中未见。
- 肌阵挛主要出现在慢波期,强直姿势主要出现在平坦脑电图期。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为肌阵挛少于10次提示晕厥,多于20次提示惊厥性发作(「10/20规则」)。
- 作者认为肌张力缺失强烈支持晕厥。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: We assessed motor phenomena in syncope and convulsive seizures to aid differential diagnosis and understand the pathophysiologic correlates. METHODS: We studied video-EEG recordings of tilt-induced syncope and convulsive seizures in participants aged 15 years and older. Syncope was defined as (1) loss of consciousness (video-assessed), (2) circulatory changes (accelerating blood pressure decrease with or without bradycardia/asystole), and (3) EEG changes ("slow" or "slow-flat-slow"). We assessed myoclonic jerks and tonic postures of the arms and noted time of occurrence, laterality, synchrony, and rhythmicity (mean consecutive differences of interclonic intervals). RESULTS: Video-EEG records of 65 syncope cases and 50 convulsive seizures were included. In syncope, postures occurred in 42 cases (65%) and jerks in 33 (51%). Fewer jerks occurred in syncope (median 2, range 1-19) compared to convulsive seizures (median 48, range 20-191; p < 0.001). Jerks were more rhythmic in seizures compared to syncope (p < 0.001). Atonia was seen in all syncope cases, while this was not observed in any seizure. Jerks predominantly occurred during the slow and postures during the flat EEG phase. CONCLUSIONS: Jerks and tonic postures were common in syncope, but semiology differed from convulsive seizures. The lack of overlap in the number of jerks suggests that less than 10 indicates syncope and more than 20 a convulsive seizure: the "10/20 rule." Loss of tone strongly favors syncope. The EEG correlates imply that jerks in syncope are likely of cortical origin, whereas tonic postures may result from brainstem disinhibition.
引用
- Shmuely S, Bauer PR, van Zwet EW, et al. Differentiating motor phenomena in tilt-induced syncope and convulsive seizures. Neurology. 2018. PMID: 29549227. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000005301
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。