DWI-ASPECTS与DWI-FLAIR不匹配在取栓候选者中的评分者内与评分者间一致性研究
本研究评估临床医生在机械取栓候选的急性缺血性卒中患者中评定DWI-ASPECTS和DWI-FLAIR不匹配的评分者内与评分者间一致性。18名评分者对30例患者的MRI独立评分两次,结果显示DWI-ASPECTS的评分者间一致性轻微(κ=0.17),而二分类化后提升至显著水平(κ=0.62和0.68);DWI-FLAIR不匹配一致性为中等(κ=0.43)。结论认为当前一致性可能不足以支持可重复的临床决策。
要点
- DWI-ASPECTS原始评分的一致性仅轻微(κ=0.17),重复决策可靠性不足。
- 将DWI-ASPECTS二分类为0-5 vs 6-10或0-6 vs 7-10可提高一致性至显著水平。
- DWI-FLAIR不匹配的评分者间一致性为中等(κ=0.43)。
核心结论
- 临床医生评定DWI-ASPECTS和DWI-FLAIR不匹配的一致性可能不足以在机械取栓中做出可重复的临床决策。
- DWI-ASPECTS的二分类化(0-5 vs 6-10或0-6 vs 7-10)改善了评分者间和评分者内一致性,但其对取栓患者选择的价值需随机试验验证。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入来自多中心取栓试验的30例参与者的匿名MRI扫描,由18名评分者在两次独立阅读中评分。
- 一致性使用Fleiss κ和Cohen κ统计量测量。
主要发现
- DWI-ASPECTS的评分者间一致性为轻微(κ=0.17 [0.14-0.21]),仅4名评分者(22.2%)达到显著或更高的评分者内一致性。
- DWI-ASPECTS二分类为0-5 vs 6-10时评分者间一致性κ=0.62 [0.48-0.75],0-6 vs 7-10时κ=0.68 [0.55-0.79],均达显著水平,且17/18名评分者(94.4%)达到显著或更高的评分者内一致性。
- DWI-FLAIR不匹配的评分者间一致性为中等(κ=0.43 [0.33-0.57]),11名评分者(61.1%)达到显著或更高的评分者内一致性。
关键数值与推荐
- DWI-ASPECTS评分者间一致性κ=0.17 [0.14-0.21](轻微)。
- DWI-ASPECTS二分类0-5 vs 6-10的评分者间一致性κ=0.62 [0.48-0.75];0-6 vs 7-10的κ=0.68 [0.55-0.79]。
- DWI-FLAIR不匹配评分者间一致性κ=0.43 [0.33-0.57](中等)。
临床怎么用
- 在机械取栓决策中,使用DWI-ASPECTS连续评分或DWI-FLAIR不匹配评估时需注意观察者间一致性有限。
- 可考虑将DWI-ASPECTS二分类化以提高一致性,但其对患者选择的影响尚未经随机试验验证。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入30例参与者的MRI扫描,样本量较小。
- 二分类化DWI-ASPECTS对取栓患者选择的相关性需随机试验验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: We aimed to study the intrarater and interrater agreement of clinicians attributing DWI-ASPECTS (Diffusion-Weighted Imaging-Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Scores) and DWI-FLAIR (Diffusion-Weighted Imaging-Fluid Attenuated Inversion Recovery) mismatch in patients with acute ischemic stroke referred for mechanical thrombectomy. METHODS: Eighteen raters independently scored anonymized magnetic resonance imaging scans of 30 participants from a multicentre thrombectomy trial, in 2 different reading sessions. Agreement was measured using Fleiss κ and Cohen κ statistics. RESULTS: Interrater agreement for DWI-ASPECTS was slight (κ=0.17 [0.14-0.21]). Four raters (22.2%) had a substantial (or higher) intrarater agreement. Dichotomization of the DWI-ASPECTS (0-5 versus 6-10 or 0-6 versus 7-10) increased the interrater agreement to a substantial level (κ=0.62 [0.48-0.75] and 0.68 [0.55-0.79], respectively) and more raters reached a substantial (or higher) intrarater agreement (17/18 raters [94.4%]). Interrater agreement for DWI-FLAIR mismatch was moderate (κ=0.43 [0.33-0.57]); 11 raters (61.1%) reached a substantial (or higher) intrarater agreement. CONCLUSIONS: Agreement between clinicians assessing DWI-ASPECTS and DWI-FLAIR mismatch may not be sufficient to make repeatable clinical decisions in mechanical thrombectomy. The dichotomization of the DWI-ASPECTS (0-5 versus 0-6 or 0-6 versus 7-10) improved interrater and intrarater agreement, however, its relevance for patients selection for mechanical thrombectomy needs to be validated in a randomized trial.
引用
- Fahed R, Lecler A, Sabben C, et al. DWI-ASPECTS (Diffusion-Weighted Imaging-Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Scores) and DWI-FLAIR (Diffusion-Weighted Imaging-Fluid Attenuated Inversion Recovery) Mismatch in Thrombectomy Candidates: An Intrarater and Interrater Agreement Study. Stroke. 2017. PMID: 29191851. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.117.019508
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。