药物过度使用性头痛:一个需要审视的固有观念
本文综述了药物过度使用性头痛(MOH)的证据,指出将频繁使用急性止痛药视为头痛恶化的原因缺乏强证据支持。观察性研究存在适应症混杂,撤药研究多为非对照且脱落率高。作者建议对MOH概念持更怀疑态度,频繁用药应视为头痛控制不佳的指标而非必然原因。
要点
- 现有证据不足以支持急性止痛药过度使用导致头痛频率进展的因果论断。
- 限制或撤除止痛药仅对少数患者有益,且获益小于当前认识、危害更大。
- 频繁使用止痛药应视为头痛控制不佳的指标,而非必然原因。
核心结论
- 现有证据不足以支持药物使用与频繁头痛之间的强因果论断。
- 仅少数被要求限制用药或判定为过度用药的患者可能从限制或撤药中获益。
- 对MOH概念应持更怀疑态度,避免对对症用药的教条态度。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述,评估了观察性研究和药物撤药研究等现有证据。
主要发现
- 观察性研究因适应症混杂而存在固有局限。
- 撤药研究多为非对照且脱落率高。
- 限制或撤除对症药物仅对少数患者有益。
关键数值与推荐
- 常见建议限制治疗每月不超过10或15天(取决于药物类型)以预防头痛频率进展。
- 缺乏关于用药时长、剂量和药物类型导致MOH的共识。
- 药物撤除常被推荐为频繁头痛患者治疗的第一步。
临床怎么用
- 避免教条化地对症用药限制或撤药。
- 将频繁使用止痛药视为头痛控制不佳的指标而非必然原因。
- 对MOH概念保持怀疑,等待更好证据。
局限性
- 观察性研究存在适应症混杂。
- 撤药研究多为非对照且脱落率高。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
It is a widely accepted idea that medications taken to relieve acute headache pain can paradoxically worsen headache if used too often. This type of secondary headache is referred to as medication overuse headache (MOH); previously used terms include rebound headache and drug-induced headache. In the absence of consensus about the duration of use, amount, and type of medication needed to cause MOH, the default position is conservative. A common recommendation is to limit treatment to no more than 10 or 15 days per month (depending on medication type) to prevent headache frequency progression. Medication withdrawal is often recommended as a first step in treatment of patients with very frequent headaches. Existing evidence, however, does not provide a strong basis for such causal claims about the relationship between medication use and frequent headache. Observational studies linking treatment patterns with headache frequency are by their nature confounded by indication. Medication withdrawal studies have mostly been uncontrolled and often have high dropout rates. Evaluation of this evidence suggests that only a minority of patients required to limit the use of symptomatic medication may benefit from treatment limitation. Similarly, only a minority of patients deemed to be overusing medications may benefit from withdrawal. These findings raise serious questions about the value of withholding or withdrawing symptom-relieving medications from people with frequent headaches solely to prevent or treat MOH. The benefits of doing so are smaller, and the harms larger, than currently recognized. The concept of MOH should be viewed with more skepticism. Until the evidence is better, we should avoid dogmatism about the use of symptomatic medication. Frequent use of symptom-relieving headache medications should be viewed more neutrally, as an indicator of poorly controlled headaches, and not invariably a cause.
引用
- Scher AI, Rizzoli PB, Loder EW, et al. Medication overuse headache: An entrenched idea in need of scrutiny. Neurology. 2017. PMID: 28821684. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000004371
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。