癫痫患者猝死被低估:尸检研究揭示漏诊问题
该研究基于旧金山POST SCD人群队列,前瞻性判定18-90岁院外心脏猝死者的癫痫病史与最终死因,并由癫痫专家回顾性复核。结果显示癫痫专家识别出25例癫痫患者,其中72%为明确或可能SUDEP,而多学科委员会仅识别24%(6/25),提示癫痫相关猝死常被漏认。
要点
- 癫痫在猝死者中常被漏诊,癫痫专家复核可提高识别率。
- SUDEP在多学科判定中易被低估,72% vs 24%差异显著。
- 酒精相关癫痫发作的急性症状性癫痫致死可能被忽视。
核心结论
- 癫痫在猝死者中诊断不足,癫痫发作和SUDEP常未被识别为潜在或明确死因。
研究设计与样本
- 基于旧金山POST SCD人群研究,前瞻性判定541例院外心脏猝死(平均62.8岁,69%男性)的癫痫与最终死因,其中525例(97%)尸检。
- 比较多学科委员会与2名癫痫专家对癫痫诊断及死因的回顾性裁定。
主要发现
- 525例尸检中39例(7.4%)有癫痫或发作,占231例非心律失常性猝死的17%。
- 多学科团队识别15例癫痫、6例SUDEP,无急性症状性发作相关死亡。
- 癫痫专家识别25例癫痫、8例明确SUDEP、10例可能SUDEP及5例急性症状性发作潜在死因。
- 癫痫专家判定的25例癫痫中72%(18/25)为明确或可能SUDEP,多学科组仅24%(6/25)。
- 14例酒精相关发作患者中,癫痫专家认为5例急性症状性发作是潜在死因。
临床怎么用
- 对猝死患者应详细询问癫痫病史,必要时由癫痫专科医生复核死因。
- SUDEP应作为癫痫患者猝死的重要鉴别诊断,避免漏认。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the definite and potential frequency of seizures and epilepsy as a cause of death (COD) and how often this goes unrecognized. METHODS: Prospective determination of seizures or epilepsy and final COD for individuals aged 18-90 years with out-of-hospital sudden cardiac deaths (SCDs) from the population-based San Francisco POST SCD Study. We compared prospective seizure or epilepsy diagnosis and final COD as adjudicated by a multidisciplinary committee (pathologists, electrophysiologists, and a vascular neurologist) vs retrospective adjudication by 2 epileptologists with expertise in seizure-related mortality. RESULTS: Of 541 SCDs identified during the 37-month study period (mean age 62.8 years, 69% men), 525 (97%) were autopsied; 39/525 (7.4%) had seizures or epilepsy (mean age: 58 years, range: 27-92; 67% men), comprising 17% of 231 nonarrhythmic sudden deaths. The multidisciplinary team identified 15 cases of epilepsy, 6 sudden unexpected deaths in epilepsy (SUDEPs), and no deaths related to acute symptomatic seizures. The epileptologists identified 25 cases of epilepsy and 8 definite SUDEPs, 10 possible SUDEPs, and 5 potential cases of acute symptomatic seizures as a COD. CONCLUSIONS: Among the 25 patients identified with epilepsy by the epileptologists, they found definite or possible SUDEP in 72% (18/25) vs 24% (6/25) by the multidisciplinary group (6/15 cases they identified with epilepsy). The epileptologists identified acute symptomatic seizures as a potential COD in 5/14 patients with alcohol-related seizures. Epilepsy is underdiagnosed among decedents. Among patients with seizures and epilepsy who die suddenly, seizures and SUDEP often go unrecognized as a potential or definite COD.
引用
- Devinsky O, Friedman D, Cheng JY, et al. Underestimation of sudden deaths among patients with seizures and epilepsy. Neurology. 2017. PMID: 28768851. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000004292
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。