现代神经影像时代急诊科对脑血管事件的误诊:一项荟萃分析
该荟萃分析检索1995-2016年文献,纳入23项研究共15721例患者,评估急诊科对急性脑血管事件(缺血性卒中、TIA、蛛网膜下腔出血)的诊断准确性。总体敏感度91.3%、特异度92.7%,但约9%的脑血管事件在急诊首诊时被漏诊;症状轻微、非特异或短暂时误诊风险显著增高(24%-60%)。
要点
- 急诊科对脑血管事件总体敏感度91.3%、特异度92.7%,但约9%被漏诊。
- 症状轻微、非特异或短暂时误诊风险显著增高,范围24%-60%。
- 误诊差异提示许多误诊与症状特异性因素相关,需针对高危亚组设计纠错策略。
核心结论
- 约9%的脑血管事件在急诊首诊时被漏诊,症状轻微、非特异或短暂时误诊风险显著增高(范围24%-60%)。
研究设计与样本
- 检索MEDLINE和Embase(1995-2016年)报告急诊诊断准确性的研究,最终分析23项研究,共15721例患者,采用QUADAS-2评估偏倚风险。
主要发现
- 总体敏感度为91.3%(95%CI 90.7-92.0),特异度为92.7%(95%CI 91.7-93.7)。
- 精神状态正常的SAH患者假阴性率23.8%,精神状态异常者4.2%,OR为7.03(95%CI 4.80-10.31)。
- 以头晕为表现者假阴性率39.4%,以运动症状为表现者4.4%,OR为14.22(95%CI 9.76-20.74)。
- TIA的假发现率59.7%,缺血性卒中为11.7%,OR为11.21(95%CI 6.66-18.89)。
临床怎么用
- 急诊医生应警惕症状轻微、非特异或短暂的脑血管事件,对头晕、精神状态正常的SAH及TIA患者提高诊断敏感性。
局限性
- 研究间存在显著异质性,基于临床表现为亚组的事后分析可能受混杂因素影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: With the emergency department (ED) being a high-risk site for diagnostic errors, we sought to estimate ED diagnostic accuracy for identifying acute cerebrovascular events. METHODS: MEDLINE and Embase were searched for studies (1995-2016) reporting ED diagnostic accuracy for ischemic stroke, TIA, or subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH). Two independent reviewers determined inclusion. We identified 1,693 unique citations, examined 214 full articles, and analyzed 23 studies. Studies were rated on risk of bias (QUADAS-2). Diagnostic data were extracted. We prospectively defined clinical presentation subgroups to compare odds of misdiagnosis. RESULTS: Included studies reported on 15,721 patients. Studies were at low risk of bias. Overall sensitivity (91.3% [95% confidence interval (CI) 90.7-92.0]) and specificity (92.7% [91.7-93.7]) for a cerebrovascular etiology was high, but there was significant variation based on clinical presentation. Misdiagnosis was more frequent among subgroups with milder (SAH with normal vs abnormal mental state; false-negative rate 23.8% vs 4.2%, odds ratio [OR] 7.03 [4.80-10.31]), nonspecific (dizziness vs motor findings; false-negative rate 39.4% vs 4.4%, OR 14.22 [9.76-20.74]), or transient (TIA vs ischemic stroke; false discovery rate 59.7% vs 11.7%, OR 11.21 [6.66-18.89]) symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: Roughly 9% of cerebrovascular events are missed at initial ED presentation. Risk of misdiagnosis is much greater when presenting neurologic complaints are mild, nonspecific, or transient (range 24%-60%). This difference suggests that many misdiagnoses relate to symptom-specific factors. Future research should emphasize studying causes and designing error-reduction strategies in symptom-specific subgroups at greatest risk of misdiagnosis.
引用
- Tarnutzer AA, Lee SH, Robinson KA, et al. ED misdiagnosis of cerebrovascular events in the era of modern neuroimaging: A meta-analysis. Neurology. 2017. PMID: 28356464. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000003814
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。