医生如何为合并残疾或痴呆的卒中患者确定照护目标:SEED混合方法研究
本研究采用混合方法,通过半结构化访谈和在线调查了解医生为合并残疾或痴呆的卒中患者确定照护目标的方式及挑战。调查中,病情严重程度和生活质量被多数医生视为决策中非常重要或极其重要,但访谈揭示医生在评估这些因素时存在深刻不确定性,可能造成卒中管理的不良变异。
要点
- 病情严重程度和生活质量是医生决策时最常视为非常重要的因素。
- 医生在评估患者既往健康状况、预后和治疗适宜性时存在显著不确定性。
- 常规记录患者基线健康状况和预立医疗指示可能有助于减轻不确定性。
核心结论
- 医生在为合并残疾或痴呆的卒中患者确定照护目标时面临深刻且多层面的不确定性,可能导致卒中管理的不良变异。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究:邀请参与卒中照护的医生参加半结构化访谈和在线调查,访谈采用解释性扎根理论分析,并与调查描述性分析结果三角验证。
- 82名受邀医生中30人参与访谈(43%来自北美,77%有≥10年经验,60%为神经科医生)。
- 200名同意参与调查的医生中132人完成调查(37%来自北美,51%有≥10年经验,56%为神经科医生)。
主要发现
- 对于卒中前残疾和痴呆,调查受访者最常将既往病情严重程度(87%[95%CI,80%-91%]和89%[95%CI,82%-93%])和生活质量(88%[95%CI,82%-93%]和87%[95%CI,80%-91%])视为决策中非常重要或极其重要。
- 访谈医生强调在评估这些因素以及形成对患者预后和治疗适宜性的感知时存在不确定性。
- 不确定性归因于关于患者既往健康状况和意愿的可靠信息有限,以及缺乏针对合并残疾或痴呆患者的卒中管理证据。
- 医生认识到这些模糊情况似乎需要高度个体化照护,但也意识到随之而来的偏倚影响公平性的高风险。
临床怎么用
- 在临床实践中常规记录患者基线健康状况和预立医疗指示可能有助于减轻决策不确定性。
- 促进合并残疾或痴呆患者纳入卒中研究,并在研究中考虑患者和家庭对生活质量和有利结局的看法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Despite remarkable advances in stroke management, there is a continued lack of evidence to guide care for the 1 in 3 stroke patients living with disability or dementia (PLWD). To help inform best practices, this study sought to understand how physicians approach the complex issue of determining goals of care for PLWD and what challenges they encounter. METHODS: In a mixed-methods investigation, we invited physicians involved in stroke care to participate in semistructured interviews and an online survey, enquiring into perspectives on stroke management in PLWD. Interviews were analyzed using an interpretive grounded theory approach. Qualitative findings were triangulated with results from a descriptive analysis of survey items. RESULTS: Of 82 approached physicians, 30 participated in interviews (43% from North America, 77% with ≥10 years of experience; 60% neurologists); of 200 consenting to the survey, 132 completed it (37% from North America, 51% with ≥10 years of experience, 56% neurologists). For both prestroke disability and dementia, survey respondents most frequently indicated severity of the prior condition (87% [95% CI, 80%-91%] and 89% [95% CI, 82%-93%]) and quality of life (88% [95% CI, 82%-93%] and 87% [95% CI, 80%-91%]) as either very or extremely important in decision-making. However, interviewed physicians emphasized uncertainty in evaluating these factors and forming perceptions of patient prognosis and treatment appropriateness. This was attributed to limited reliable information regarding patients' prior well-being and wishes, and paucity of PLWD-specific evidence to guide stroke management. While these ambiguous circumstances appeared to warrant a highly individualized approach to care, physicians also recognized the consequent high risk of biases affecting equity. CONCLUSIONS: Physicians encounter profound, multifaceted uncertainty in determining goals of care for PLWD, which may contribute to adverse variability in stroke management. This uncertainty may be eased by routinely documenting patients' baseline well-being and advance healthcare directives in clinical practice and promoting inclusion of PLWD in stroke research, in both contexts, considering patient and family perspectives on quality of life and favorable outcomes.
引用
- Drozdowska BA, Betzner W, Cristall N, et al. Physician Approaches to Determining Goals of Stroke Care for Patients Living With Disability or Dementia: Results from the SEED Mixed-Methods Study. Stroke. 2026. PMID: 42339544. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.125.053567
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。