描述震颤与肌张力障碍的挑战
震颤定义为振荡性节律运动,肌张力障碍定义为持续或间歇异常姿势、重复运动或两者兼有,二者常共存且可互相模仿。专家组回顾术语后达成共识:震颤应专指节律性运动,明显节律不齐的重复性肌张力障碍运动不应使用暗示震颤的术语;共存时应分别描述而非使用混合术语。
要点
- 震颤应专指节律性运动,明显节律不齐的重复性肌张力障碍运动不应使用暗示震颤的术语。
- 震颤与肌张力障碍共存时,分别使用描述性术语可能比暗示病因的混合术语更有用。
- 床旁鉴别运动有时具有挑战性,未来运动分析或生理学测量可能有助于鉴别临床不确定的运动。
核心结论
- 专家组一致认为震颤应专指节律性运动。
- 专家组一致认为明显节律不齐的重复性肌张力障碍运动不应使用暗示其为一种震颤的术语。
- 当震颤与肌张力障碍共存时,分别使用描述性术语而非暗示疑似病因的混合术语可能临床更有用。
研究设计与样本
- 一组专家被召集回顾术语并制定更一致方法的建议。
主要发现
- 震颤定义为振荡性节律运动,肌张力障碍定义为持续或间歇异常姿势、重复运动或两者兼有。
- 震颤与肌张力障碍常共存于同一个体,可发生在同一身体区域或不同身体区域。
- 肌张力障碍运动可快速重复并模仿震颤。
- 术语dystonic tremor最初用于区分肌张力障碍中的震颤样运动与更常见的震颤如特发性震颤,后被用于指同一身体区域任何肌张力障碍与震颤的组合。
- 其他相关术语包括tremor associated with dystonia、tremulous dystonia、dystonia-tremor syndrome和dystonia with tremor。
临床怎么用
- 专家组一致认为震颤应专指节律性运动。
- 专家组一致认为明显节律不齐的重复性肌张力障碍运动不应使用暗示其为一种震颤的术语。
- 专家组一致认为当震颤与肌张力障碍共存时,分别使用描述性术语而非暗示疑似病因的混合术语可能临床更有用。
- 易用的临床术语至关重要,尽管床旁鉴别运动有时具有挑战性。
- 未来运动分析或生理学测量可能有助于鉴别临床不确定的运动。
局限性
- 床旁鉴别运动有时具有挑战性。
- 专家意见 regarding 这些术语的应用存在分歧。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Tremor is defined as an oscillatory and rhythmical movement. By contrast, dystonia is defined by sustained or intermittent abnormal postures, repetitive movements, or both. Tremor and dystonia often coexist in the same individual. Sometimes tremor and dystonia occur in the same body region, and sometimes they occur in separate body regions. In other cases, dystonic movements are rapid and repetitive, and they may mimic tremor. The varied clinical phenomenology of dystonia and tremor were recognized in the earliest descriptions of dystonia, and various terms have been used to describe the relationships between tremor and dystonia. The term dystonic tremor was first introduced to distinguish tremor-like movements in dystonia from more common tremors such as essential tremor. Subsequently, the same term was adopted to refer to any combination of dystonia and tremor in the same body region. Both applications of this term continue to be used in the modern literature. Other related terms have also been proposed such as tremor associated with dystonia, tremulous dystonia, dystonia-tremor syndrome, and dystonia with tremor. The proliferation of terms has become confusing, and expert opinion regarding application of these terms is divided, so a group of specialists was assembled to review the terminology and to develop recommendations for a more consistent approach. The group agreed that the term tremor should exclusively refer to rhythmic movements. The group also agreed that repetitive dystonic movements that are grossly arrhythmic should not be labeled with terms that imply they are a type of tremor. Moreover, when tremor and dystonia coexist, it may be clinically more useful to describe them separately, using descriptive terms rather than hybrid terms that imply suspected etiology. Easy-to-use clinical terms are essential, although bedside discrimination of movements may sometimes be challenging. In the future, motion analysis or physiologic measures may aid in the discrimination of movements that remain clinically uncertain.
引用
- Shaikh AG, Fasano A, Pandey S, et al. Challenges in Describing Tremor and Dystonia. Neurology. 2024. PMID: 39724539. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000210209
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。