评估基于健康社会决定因素的认知常模模型替代基于种族的模型
该横断面分析纳入动脉粥样硬化风险社区研究中2392名无轻度认知障碍或痴呆的黑人与白人参与者,比较6种回归常模模型。含种族、教育质量与社区剥夺指数的「Full」模型拟合最优(似然比≥100);教育质量单独模型在记忆与语言测试中优于社区剥夺或种族单独模型;常规报告的健康社会决定因素变量未能完全解释种族差异。
要点
- 含种族、教育质量与社区剥夺指数的「Full」模型对所有领域/测试(除延迟词语回忆外)拟合均优于嵌套子模型,似然比≥100。
- 教育质量单独模型在记忆与语言测试中优于社区剥夺或种族单独模型,而种族模型在执行功能测试中表现更好。
- 与「Full」模型相比,「Education」和「ADI」模型的一致性较低;黑人参与者(范围8.2%-23.2%)比白人参与者(范围2.2%-3.4%)不一致性更高。
核心结论
- 教育质量作为附加或替代的健康社会决定因素指标在常模模型中优于社区剥夺,可能值得在认知老化研究中收集。
- 常规报告的健康社会决定因素变量(教育水平、教育质量、晚年社区剥夺)未能完全解释观察到的种族差异,未来需在更多样化人群中评估全生命周期的健康社会决定因素。
研究设计与样本
- 对动脉粥样硬化风险社区研究中2011-2013年参加第5次随访、无轻度认知障碍或痴呆的黑人与白人参与者进行横断面分析,共2392人,平均年龄74.4岁,60.4%为女性,17.1%自报黑人种族。
- 参与者完成11项认知测试(3个领域:记忆、执行功能、语言),为每项测试拟合6个回归常模模型,均含年龄与教育,并组合种族、广泛成就测验(教育质量代理)和当前居住地社区剥夺指数,以z分数<-1.5为损害阈值比较模型拟合与一致性/不一致性。
主要发现
- 「Full」模型(含种族、人口学与健康社会决定因素指标)对所有领域/测试(除延迟词语回忆外)均一致优于其他嵌套子模型,似然比≥100。
- 教育质量单独模型(「WRAT」)在记忆和语言测试中总体优于社区剥夺单独模型(「ADI」)或种族单独模型(「Race」),而「Race」模型在执行功能测试中表现更好。
- 将社区剥夺加入教育质量(「WRAT + ADI」)与单独使用「WRAT」相比未改善模型。
- 与「Full」模型相比,「Education」和「ADI」模型的一致性在所有领域/测试中低于其他嵌套模型。
- 尽管数量较少,黑人参与者(范围8.2%-23.2%)比白人参与者(范围2.2%-3.4%)的不一致性更高,尤其在波士顿命名测试和执行功能测试中。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为教育质量作为附加或替代的健康社会决定因素指标在常模模型中优于社区剥夺,可能值得在认知老化研究中收集。
- 作者指出常规报告的健康社会决定因素变量未能完全解释观察到的种族差异,未来工作应在更多样化人群中评估全生命周期的健康社会决定因素。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Race and ethnicity are proxy measures of sociocultural factors that influence cognitive test performance. Our objective was to compare different regression-based cognitive normative models adjusting for demographics and different combinations of easily accessible/commonly used social determinants of health (SDoH) factors, which may help describe cognitive performance variability historically captured by ethnoracial differences. METHODS: We performed cross-sectional analyses on data from Black and White participants without mild cognitive impairment/dementia in the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study who attended visit 5 in 2011-2013. Participants underwent a battery of 11 cognitive tests (3 domains: memory, executive function, language). We fit 6 separate normative models for each cognitive test, all including age and education, with different combinations of race, the Wide Range of Achievement Test (education quality proxy), and area deprivation index (neighborhood deprivation) associated with current residence. We compared model fits and calculated concordances/discordances between models using z-scores derived from each normative model and a z-score <-1.5 threshold for impairment. RESULTS: Participants (n = 2,392) had a mean age of 74.4 years, 60.4% were female, and 17.1% were of self-reported Black race. The "Full" model with race alongside demographic and SDoH measures consistently outperformed other nested submodels (likelihood ratios ≥ 100) for all domains/tests except Delayed Word Recall. Models with education quality alone ("WRAT") generally outperformed models with neighborhood deprivation ("ADI") or race ("Race") alone for memory and language tests while "Race" models performed better for executive function tests. Adding neighborhood deprivation to education quality ("WRAT + ADI") did not improve models vs using "WRAT" alone. Across all domains/tests, the concordance compared with the "Full" model was lower for "Education" and "ADI" models than for other nested models. Although numbers were small, there was greater discordance among Black (range = 8.2%-23.2%) compared with White (range = 2.2%-3.4%) participants, particularly for Boston Naming Test and executive function tests. DISCUSSION: Education quality outperformed neighborhood disadvantage as an additional/alternative SDoH measure in normative models and may be useful to collect in cognitive aging studies. While performance varied across cognitive domains and tests, routinely reported SDoH variables (education level, education quality, late-life neighborhood deprivation) did not fully account for observed ethnoracial variability; future work should evaluate SDoH across the lifespan in more ethnoracially diverse populations.
引用
- Schneider ALC, Reyes A, Henegan JA, et al. Evaluating Social Determinants of Health-Based Alternatives to Race-Based Cognitive Normative Models. Neurology. 2024. PMID: 39546740. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000210030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。