危重神经疾病中的预后语言:一项多中心混合方法研究
该多中心横断面混合方法研究分析了美国7个中心43次临床医生与家属的录音会议记录,涉及39例危重神经疾病患者、78名代理决策者和27名临床医生。临床医生共做出512条预后陈述,其中62%(316/512)为非概率性语言,仅2%(10/512)提供数值估计,21%(9/43)的会议仅含非概率性语言。与认知预后陈述相比,生存(OR 2.50,95%CI 1.01-6.18,p=0.048)和躯体功能(OR 3.22,95%CI 1.77-5.86,p<0.001)的陈述更常使用概率性语言;躯体功能陈述比认知陈述更少基于不确定性(OR 0.34,95%CI 0.17-0.66,p=0.002)。
要点
- 临床医生在危重神经疾病预后讨论中多使用非概率性语言,仅2%陈述含数值估计。
- 与认知预后相比,生存和躯体功能预后陈述更常使用概率性语言。
- 躯体功能陈述比认知陈述更少基于不确定性(OR 0.34,95%CI 0.17-0.66)。
核心结论
- 临床医生在讨论危重神经疾病预后时倾向于不使用估计值(数值或定性),尤其在讨论认知结局时。
- 这些发现可能为改善危重神经疾病预后沟通的干预措施提供信息。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心横断面混合方法研究,分析美国7个中心因神经疾病需重症监护患者(如脑出血、创伤性脑损伤、严重卒中)的临床医生-家属会议去标识录音转录文本。
- 两名编码员对每条临床医生预后陈述的预后语言类型和预后领域进行编码。
- 共分析43次临床医生-家属会议,涉及39例患者、78名代理决策者和27名临床医生。
- 采用单变量和多变量二项逻辑回归检验预后语言与预后领域之间的独立关联。
主要发现
- 临床医生共做出512条关于生存(每次会议中位数0,IQR 0-2)、躯体功能(中位数2,IQR 0-7)、认知(中位数2,IQR 0-6)和总体恢复(中位数2,IQR 1-4)的陈述。
- 多数陈述为非概率性(316/512,62%);512条预后陈述中仅10条(2%)提供数值估计;21%(9/43)的家庭会议仅包含非概率性语言。
- 与认知陈述相比,生存陈述(OR 2.50,95%CI 1.01-6.18,p=0.048)和躯体功能陈述(OR 3.22,95%CI 1.77-5.86,p<0.001)更常为概率性。
- 躯体功能陈述比认知陈述更少基于不确定性(OR 0.34,95%CI 0.17-0.66,p=0.002)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: There are no evidence-based guidelines for discussing prognosis in critical neurologic illness, but in general, experts recommend that clinicians communicate prognosis using estimates, such as numerical or qualitative expressions of risk. Little is known about how real-world clinicians communicate prognosis in critical neurologic illness. Our primary objective was to characterize prognostic language clinicians used in critical neurologic illness. We additionally explored whether prognostic language differed between prognostic domains (e.g., survival, cognition). METHODS: We conducted a multicenter cross-sectional mixed-methods study analyzing deidentified transcripts of audio-recorded clinician-family meetings for patients with neurologic illness requiring intensive care (e.g., intracerebral hemorrhage, traumatic brain injury, severe stroke) from 7 US centers. Two coders assigned codes for prognostic language type and domain of prognosis to each clinician prognostic statement. Prognostic language was coded as probabilistic (estimating the likelihood of an outcome occurring, e.g., "80% survival"; "She'll probably survive") or nonprobabilistic (characterizing outcomes without offering likelihood; e.g., "She may not survive"). We applied univariate and multivariate binomial logistic regression to examine independent associations between prognostic language and domain of prognosis. RESULTS: We analyzed 43 clinician-family meetings for 39 patients with 78 surrogates and 27 clinicians. Clinicians made 512 statements about survival (median 0/meeting [interquartile range (IQR) 0-2]), physical function (median 2 [IQR 0-7]), cognition (median 2 [IQR 0-6]), and overall recovery (median 2 [IQR 1-4]). Most statements were nonprobabilistic (316/512 [62%]); 10 of 512 prognostic statements (2%) offered numeric estimates; and 21% (9/43) of family meetings only contained nonprobabilistic language. Compared with statements about cognition, statements about survival (odds ratio [OR] 2.50, 95% CI 1.01-6.18, p = 0.048) and physical function (OR 3.22, 95% 1.77-5.86, p < 0.001) were more frequently probabilistic. Statements about physical function were less likely to be uncertainty-based than statements about cognition (OR 0.34, 95% CI 0.17-0.66, p = 0.002). DISCUSSION: Clinicians preferred not to use estimates (either numeric or qualitative) when discussing critical neurologic illness prognosis, especially when they discussed cognitive outcomes. These findings may inform interventions to improve prognostic communication in critical neurologic illness.
引用
- Goss A, Ge C, Crawford S, et al. Prognostic Language in Critical Neurologic Illness: A Multicenter Mixed-Methods Study. Neurology. 2023. PMID: 37290972. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000207462
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。