右脑:以自我为导向
本文以诗歌与叙事形式反思医学教育中的生物医学视角如何使精神状态检查(MSE)对人物、地点、时间及情境的定向评估变得非个人化。作者通过探望患有阿尔茨海默病的祖母, juxtaposing MSE 定向量表的非个人性与祖母的生活体验,强调临床评估之外对个体性的关注。
要点
- MSE 的定向评估(人物、地点、时间、情境)在临床上实用,但常忽略患者的个体性。
- 作者通过祖母的绘画互动观察到认知改变如何影响自我、地点、时间及情境的定向。
- 作者强调临床环境之外捕捉患者个体体验的重要性。
原文
In medical school, students learn to view the world through a biomedical lens. While necessary clinically, this lens can be impersonal. For example, the mental status examination (MSE) evaluates cognitive function through a brief assessment of alertness and orientation to person, place, time, and situation. While clinically useful, the MSE often neglects to capture a person's individuality. Visiting my grandmother who has Alzheimer disease highlighted this tension. I juxtaposed the impersonality of our MSE orientation scale with my grandmother's lived experiences. My grandmother is identified using a pseudonym. Informed consent was obtained from her health care power of attorney and family.Birds twitter and chirp as they flit into the shade,the covered patio a respite from the morning's heat.I sit with Joanna and show her a painting:an apple, red peppers, a garlic clove, and a grapefruitrest on a white napkin.Produce so vibrant the napkin is stainedwith their vivid reflections.The wrinkles around her eyes deepen as she squints at the picture.She always liked to see my artwork.Bright colors illuminate the lines of confusion on her face.Where did you get all this food?We're rationing for the war to stop Hitler.I have evaluated dementia:limited treatment options, behavioral interventions.Cognitive changes alterorientation to self,place, time, situation.Joanna and I sit on the memory care patio.The birdfeeder dances in the humid summer air.I've shared my artwork with Grandma Jofrom crayons' waxy scrawlto crisp acrylic colors.Today a t-shirt replaces my white coat.The war is over, grandma.The produce is from a grocery store.I redirect with another painting.This is a bridge in a park-She smiles: it's New York City, I miss going there.In the middle of Central Park,a cement bridge in a grassy parkspans a wide, still pond.Today, the colors of the bridge,reflected on the water,spark a glimmer of my grandmother.This time she knows the memory is in the past,as she tells me about New York in the Forties.With the beating of sparrow wings,the moment of clarity endsas past and present are blended again.When the sun sinks, my visit will fade.I clutch what happenedoutside, away from the clinical setting.What we cannot quantifywith A&O x1: oriented to self.
引用
- Geczi K. Right Brain: Oriented to Self. Neurology. 2022. PMID: 36443014. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000201602
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。